EL02-11 English Literature Watch
Poverty and social responsibility
In this lesson
A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit, with the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 11 of 18. Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: A Christmas Carol: Poverty
- 0:29 A Christmas Carol: Poverty: move one: the decider
- 2:16 Move two: business redefined
- 3:18 Move three: not pitiful
- 4:10 Move four: the Ghost names it
- 6:11 A Christmas Carol: Poverty: the examiner's eye
- 7:09 How does Dickens use the people who never
About this video
A Christmas Carol: Poverty and social responsibility | GCSE English Lit | EL02-11
A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit, with the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 11 of 18.
Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: EL02-11 (search "ScholaFly EL02-11")
#GCSEEnglishLit #AChristmasCarol #AChristmasCarolPoverty
For teachers
This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Poverty. It works through the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8702
- 3.1.2, Paper 1 Section B The 19th-century novel
Edexcel 1ET0
- Component 2 (1ET0/02) Section A 19th-century novel
Eduqas C720QS
- Component 2 Section B 19th Century Prose
OCR J352
- Component 01 (J352/01) Section B 19th century prose
Read the transcript
The first time A Christmas Carol argues about the poor, how many poor people take part? You might expect at least one, a beggar at the door pleading his own case. There are none. Two charity collectors and Scrooge argue about the poor, and not one poor person has a say. That tells you who Dickens's argument is really aimed at.
Here is the claim this video argues: Dickens's real subject is responsibility, who decides what happens to the poor, and what that decision says about the person making it. Start in stave one, the novella's first chapter, or stave, as Dickens calls it. Two gentlemen ask Scrooge for money to buy the poor food and warmth at Christmas. His answer is a question about institutions: Are there no prisons? Then he asks about the workhouses, the places the poorest were sent to live and work. Told that many would rather die than go there, he says they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population. Notice what Scrooge never does. He never looks at a poor person. He answers with prisons, workhouses and a theory, the idea of the economist Thomas Malthus that there are simply too many poor people. That is the context to use: the Poor Law of eighteen thirty-four and its workhouses, named inside the book. Dickens is attacking that law and that argument, which is a sharper point than calling him a socialist. In that scene, who decides what the poor deserve: the poor, the collectors, or Scrooge? Scrooge. The collectors can only ask, and the poor are not even present. One comfortable man decides, in a sentence, that they may as well die.
A dead man supplies the second piece of evidence. That night Marley's ghost, Scrooge's old business partner, arrives in a chain he made from his own selfish life. Scrooge tries to comfort him: Marley was always a good man of business. Marley answers by changing what the word business means. Mankind was my business. The common welfare was my business; charity, mercy, forbearance, and benevolence, were, all, my business. Common welfare means everybody's wellbeing. Dickens answers Scrooge's economics with economics: looking after people was the real business all along, and failing at it is what the chain is made of. So the chain is the price of a life spent deciding that other people were none of your business.
Then comes the surprise. When Dickens finally shows poor people up close, he refuses to make them pitiful. At the Cratchits' Christmas dinner in stave three, the family's glassware is two tumblers and a cup with no handle. These held the hot stuff from the jug, however, as well as golden goblets would have done. And as the Ghost of Christmas Present leads Scrooge away, Dickens sums them up: happy, grateful, pleased with one another, and contented with the time. Four descriptions, and not one of them is about money. Poor does not mean miserable, or worse people. The problem in the book is never the character of the poor.
Last, the Ghost of Christmas Present says the theme out loud, twice. Note which spirit it is, because these scenes are easy to hand to the wrong ghost. Asked if Tiny Tim, Bob Cratchit's disabled son, will live, the Ghost throws Scrooge's surplus population line back at him, and then asks a question. The Ghost asks: Will you decide what men shall live, what men shall die? Who is that aimed at? Scrooge first, and then the reader. The question is put to anyone who has ever said the poor should look after themselves. And it goes further: Oh God! to hear the insect on the leaf pronouncing on the too much life among his hungry brothers in the dust! Pronouncing means giving a verdict. A rich man becomes an insect sitting high on a leaf, judging that there is too much life down in the dust, among the hungry, who are his brothers. At the end of the same stave the Ghost shows two starving children: This boy is Ignorance. This girl is Want. Ignorance means no education; want means going without.
So when the poor are first discussed, not one of them has a say, and that is the point. Dickens's subject is not poverty so much as the decision about it. The families he shows up close are brave and happy; the thing that is wrong is a comfortable man deciding the answer is prisons. The insect on the leaf is Dickens describing who gets to talk about the poor.
One examiner's report describes the strongest answers to a question on the suffering of the poor in exactly these terms. Many successfully challenged the question, it says, arguing that while the Cratchits did indeed suffer, Dickens also presented them as a close knit, happy family. That family, in the report's words, demonstrated that the poor were not morally inferior people, but rather were deserving of the same dignity and respect as anyone in society. The weaker route is to agree with the question and list sad moments, as if the novella were only asking you to feel sorry for the poor. The fix is a habit: when a question says suffering, show the dignity first, then show who causes the suffering. That turns a list of sad scenes into an argument.
Now an essay question to plan, in the shape the exam uses: How does Dickens use the people who never speak for themselves to argue about poverty? Three nudges. Start with who is allowed to talk about the poor, and who is not. Count how many poor characters actually complain. And ask what the charity collectors are for, given that Dickens never gives them names. Pause and plan three paragraphs, each one built round a quotation. Here is one plan. First, the people in need are talked about, not to: Are there no prisons? is said about men and women who are not in the room. Second, when the poor are shown, they do not complain: the Cratchits are happy, grateful, and their cups serve as well as gold. Third, the nameless collectors and the voiceless children turn the question onto the reader: the Ghost asks whether you will decide what men shall live. Two wrong turns to avoid. The first is retelling the plot; a published mark scheme puts it plainly: Re-telling sections of the text without commentary is of little or no value. The second is opening with Dickens's childhood, when the Poor Law is right there in the book. And keep to the book, not the films. In the novella Scrooge sends the turkey without his name and spends Christmas afternoon at Fred's house, not with the Cratchits.
The argument comes back now, one step at a time, and the last question uses a line this video has not quoted. Scrooge's answer to the collectors: are there no what? Prisons. Are there no prisons answers people with institutions, and never looks at a single poor person. Now Marley: the common what was my business? Welfare. Everybody's wellbeing was Marley's real business, and he says so too late. Try the insect: who is the insect on the leaf, and who is in the dust? The insect is the comfortable man passing judgement, Scrooge and anyone like him. The dust holds the hungry, and the Ghost calls them the insect's own brothers. And one more. In stave five Scrooge meets one of the collectors again, whispers a sum in his ear, and adds: Not a farthing less. How does that line answer his stave one decision? It reverses that stave one decision. The man who chose prisons now chooses to give, and Dickens never tells us the amount, because the point is what he decides, not the figure.
Building a poverty argument that never once calls it sad puts you on top of this one; the thumbs up says so. Out of reach for now? Keep it and rebuild the plan on paper tomorrow, because the plan is what sticks.
Next in the chapter: Redemption: does Dickens actually convince you. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly E L oh two, twelve.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For teachers
This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Poverty. It works through the mistakes examiners report.