ScholaFly

EL02-12 English Literature Watch

Redemption: does Dickens actually convince you?

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit, with the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 12 of 18. Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k More at https://scholafly.com

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: A Christmas Carol: Redemption
  2. 0:32 A Christmas Carol: Redemption: marley's chain
  3. 2:18 Stave 2: small, early roots
  4. 3:24 A Christmas Carol: Redemption: the condition
  5. 4:18 Scrooge states the law
  6. 5:53 A Christmas Carol: Redemption: the examiner's eye
  7. 6:45 How far does Dickens make Scrooge's

About this video

A Christmas Carol: Redemption: does Dickens actually convince you? | GCSE English Lit | EL02-12

A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit, with the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 12 of 18.
Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k
More at https://scholafly.com

Video code: EL02-12 (search "ScholaFly EL02-12")

#GCSEEnglishLit #AChristmasCarol #AChristmasCarolRedemption

For teachers
This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Redemption. It works through the mistakes examiners report.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8702
- 3.1.2, Paper 1 Section B The 19th-century novel
Edexcel 1ET0
- Component 2 (1ET0/02) Section A 19th-century novel
Eduqas C720QS
- Component 2 Section B 19th Century Prose
OCR J352
- Component 01 (J352/01) Section B 19th century prose

Read the transcript

Is Scrooge's happy ending earned, or is it a cheat? Mean at the start of the book and generous at the end, he can look like a man changed by magic. Cheat is the easy verdict, and the weak one. Dickens saw that charge coming, and built a defence into the book from its very first chapter, a defence you can actually write. By the end, that chapter-one defence will be yours to write.

Redemption means being saved from a life of wrongdoing, a religious idea Dickens's Christian readers knew well. Here is the claim: the change is earned, because Dickens shows it was always possible, and makes Scrooge do the work. The first move is in stave one, the novella's first chapter, or stave, as Dickens calls it. Marley's ghost explains the chain he drags round with him. I made it link by link, and yard by yard; I girded it on of my own free will, and of my own free will I wore it. Girded means fastened on. Free will is said twice. If the chain was chosen, link by link, then it can be unchosen the same way, and that is what makes redemption possible for Scrooge. Before the next move, a quick test on who says what. Later in the book, someone states the law of change: that a life's direction leads to an end, unless it is changed. The choices are Marley, the silent final spirit, or Scrooge. Which of those three states the law of change in the novella? Scrooge himself, in stave four, at the graveside. It is easy to give the line to a ghost, but the printed text has said Scrooge right after it.

Small and early: that is how the change begins, in stave two, long before the grave. It is Dickens defending himself against the charge that it is too sudden. At his old school, the Ghost of Christmas Past shows Scrooge himself as a lonely boy, and he cries, in pity for his former self. Then he says something quietly: There was a boy singing a Christmas Carol at my door last night. I should like to have given him something: that's all. He turned that boy away on Christmas Eve. Now, unprompted, he wishes he had not. It is tiny, and it looks backwards, but it is the first regret in the book, and it is his own. Even the scene with Belle, the fiancee who leaves because, as she puts it, another idol has displaced her, a golden one, shows a younger man who could have chosen differently.

Then comes the condition, in stave three, where the Ghost of Christmas Present tells Scrooge that Tiny Tim, Bob Cratchit's disabled son, may die. Its words: If these shadows remain unaltered by the Future, the child will die. The future is shadows, not certainties, so it can be altered. In stave four, at the grave, Scrooge asks the silent third spirit directly. Are these the shadows of the things that Will be, or are they shadows of the things that May be only? Will be means fixed. May be means possible. The whole novella depends on the answer, and the spirit refuses to give it.

With no answer from the spirit, Scrooge works the rule out for himself, and that is the last piece of the defence. Men's courses will foreshadow certain ends, to which, if persevered in, they must lead. But if the courses be departed from, the ends will change. A course is a direction of life. Persevered in means kept going with. Departed from means left. If you keep going, you arrive; if you change direction, you do not. That is the law of the book, and Scrooge says it, not a ghost. Then the claim: I am not the man I was. And then a plea: Oh, tell me I may sponge away the writing on this stone! To sponge away writing is housework, like wiping a slate clean. Change is offered as something ordinary that a person can do with his own hands.

So the ending is earned, not a cheat. Dickens knows the turn looks too fast, so he builds the defence in early: Marley chose his chain, Scrooge regrets the carol-singer in stave two, and it is Scrooge who states the law. The novella does not claim a man was transformed overnight. It claims he was returned to who he once was.

One examiner's report, on a question about the scene where Belle ends the engagement, puts the strongest approach in a single sentence. It reads: Many saw this as a turning point in the novel where Scrooge is forced to look at his past behaviours and learn from them in order to redeem himself. The weaker route is to walk through the staves in order and call that the change. That is a story retold, not an argument about how redemption works. The fix is to treat each scene as a turning point and name the lesson it teaches. Scrooge learns that the boy was lonely, that the chain was chosen, and that his own course can be departed from.

Now a question to plan: How far does Dickens make Scrooge's change believable rather than convenient? Some hints to start you off. Find the earliest moment something in him moves, and start there. Look for who states the rule about change. And test the ending against stave one, line by line, instead of as a mood. Have a go at this one before I show you. One way to plan it runs like this. First, the change has early roots: pity for his former self, and the carol-singer he wishes he had paid. Second, it has a mechanism, and Scrooge names it himself: if the courses be departed from, the ends will change. Third, the ending answers stave one point by point. The collector he refused is given a whispered gift; Fred's door, refused, is knocked on. The narrator says he was better than his word. Two wrong turns. Retelling the plot in stave order is one. Calling the ending unrealistic because it happens in one night is the other: argue about how the change works, not how fast. And check the evidence is from the book. Scrooge sends the turkey without his name and spends Christmas afternoon at Fred's, not at the Cratchits'; the films change both.

Four turns of the argument to bring back, and a word to weigh at the end. Marley's chain: I girded it on of my own free what? Will. Of my own free will, twice, so what was chosen can be unchosen. Now the law: if the courses be departed from, the ends will what? Change. The ends will change, and remember who says it: Scrooge, at the grave, not a spirit. Try stave five: Scrooge was better than his what? His word. And he wakes as light as a feather, the opposite of Marley's chain. And a word to weigh. Scrooge's promise at the grave is: I will honour Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year. Which single word in that promise makes it more believable? Try. He does not promise to be perfect; he promises effort, every day of the year, and stave five shows him making that effort.

Arguing both sides of whether the change is earned means you're sure of this one, so the thumb goes up and you move on. Still unsure? Keep the video and argue it out with a friend who thinks the ending is a cheat; a real opponent sharpens the answer.

Next in the chapter: Christmas, joy and generosity. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly E L oh two, thirteen.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For teachers

This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Redemption. It works through the mistakes examiners report.