ScholaFly

EL02-10 English Literature Watch

Victorian London: the Poor Law, the workhouse and Malthus

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit. AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 10 of 18. Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k More at https://scholafly.com

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: A Christmas Carol: Poor Law
  2. 0:29 A Christmas Carol: Poor Law: the charity appeal
  3. 3:19 Scrooge's position
  4. 5:58 Beyond London

About this video

A Christmas Carol: Victorian London: the Poor Law, the workhouse and Malthus | EL02-10

A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit.
AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 10 of 18.
Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k
More at https://scholafly.com

Video code: EL02-10 (search "ScholaFly EL02-10")

#GCSEEnglishLit #AChristmasCarol #AChristmasCarolPoorLaw

For teachers
This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Poor Law.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8702
- 3.1.2, Paper 1 Section B The 19th-century novel
Edexcel 1ET0
- Component 2 (1ET0/02) Section A 19th-century novel
Eduqas C720QS
- Component 2 Section B 19th Century Prose
OCR J352
- Component 01 (J352/01) Section B 19th century prose

Read the transcript

Where should the history in an essay on A Christmas Carol come from? It is tempting to bring it in from a history book, as a block of facts. But Scrooge names the union workhouses, and that one word, union, carries a law his first readers lived under. Dickens points at the history; your job is to say what it meant.

Christmas Eve, in the counting-house: two well-dressed gentlemen come in collecting for charity. This is stave one, the novella's first chapter, which Dickens calls a stave, like the verse of a carol. One of them explains, very politely, that it is more than usually desirable that we should make some slight provision for the poor and destitute, who suffer greatly at the present time. Provision means supplies, and destitute means having nothing at all. The language is careful and apologetic, which is how asking a rich man for money sounded. He gives numbers: Many thousands are in want of common necessaries; hundreds of thousands are in want of common comforts, sir. Want here means lack, going without. Keep hold of that word want. In stave three the Ghost of Christmas Present will give it to a starving child as her name. Scrooge answers with questions. First, are there no prisons? Plenty of prisons, the gentleman says. Then: And the union workhouses? Are they still in operation? A workhouse was where the poorest people were sent to live, and to work for their food. Union is a technical word. The new Poor Law of eighteen thirty-four grouped parishes into unions, and each union ran a workhouse. Dickens's first readers would have heard that law inside one word. Then: The Treadmill and the Poor Law are in full vigour, then? Full vigour means working at full strength. The Treadmill was a huge wheel that prisoners were made to walk on for hours, as punishment. The Poor Law was the law deciding what help the poor could get. Scrooge says he is glad to hear both are busy. One of these three names is not in that conversation, or anywhere else in the book: the Poor Law, the Treadmill, or Malthus. Which of those three is never named out loud in the novella? Malthus. The economist Thomas Malthus is never mentioned. His idea is there, in two words of Scrooge's, but his name is not, so write the idea and name him yourself as context.

Now Scrooge's reasons. He has a position, and Dickens lets him state it clearly. I help to support the establishments I have mentioned - they cost enough; and those who are badly off must go there. Workhouses and prisons were paid for by local taxes, so Scrooge is speaking as a taxpayer: he has paid his share, and that is enough. The gentleman's reply is one line long, and it is the only plain fact in the conversation: Many can't go there; and many would rather die. Many would rather die because the new workhouses were made deliberately harsh, so that only the truly desperate would go in, and families were split up inside them. Scrooge's answer is that if they would rather die, they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population. This is the idea from Malthus. He argued that population grows faster than the food to feed it, so there will always be too many poor people. Scrooge has borrowed the theory, and turned it into a reason to give nothing.

So the history starts from a line inside the book, and that is the context that works in an essay: consequence, not biography. Not that Dickens had a hard childhood, but that the workhouse was where the poor were sent, that it split families, and that Scrooge knows it and calls it enough.

Two context sentences. First: Dickens worked in a factory as a child, so he hated poverty. Second: when Scrooge asks if the union workhouses are still running, he is pointing at an institution his readers knew split families apart. Which of those two uses context to say something about the novella? The latter one. The opening sentence is about the author's life, and tells you nothing about the book. The other takes a line of the novella and shows what it meant to its readers. How much this background earns depends on your own paper; the video called Your exam: four boards, and eighteen forty-three is worth a third on one and nothing on another sorts that out.

Dickens also makes sure you cannot think of poverty as a London problem. In stave three the Ghost of Christmas Present flies Scrooge out to a bleak moor. Asked where they are, it says: A place where Miners live, who labour in the bowels of the earth. The bowels of the earth means deep underground. Inside one hut there is a cheerful company round a fire: An old, old man and woman, with their children and their children's children, and another generation beyond that. Four generations crammed into one hut. The poorest household in the book is also the fullest and the happiest, and it is far from any city. Poverty is the condition of the whole country.

Time to bring that one conversation back, a gap at a time, and then to use it on a line from later in the book. Scrooge's question: the Treadmill and the Poor Law are in full what, then? Vigour. Working at full strength, and Scrooge is glad of it. Now the collector's reply: many can't go there; and many would rather what? Die. Many would rather die than enter a workhouse, which tells you how harsh they were made. Try the name: whose idea is decrease the surplus population? Thomas Malthus, the economist, though the novella never names him, only borrows his idea of a surplus population. Last, a step on. In stave three the Spirit throws Scrooge's own question about the workhouses back at him, about two starving children. Which fact from this video makes that question hit hardest? That they were built to be harsh, and broke families up. Sending a brother and sister there is no help at all; it is the place so many would rather die than enter.

A context sentence about the novella rather than about Dickens, written without help, means fully understood, so let the thumb go up. Not yet? Store it away and test a sentence against a real past paper extract later in the week.

Next in the chapter: Poverty and social responsibility. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly E L oh two, eleven.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For teachers

This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Poor Law.