DT09-02 Design and Technology Watch
Freehand sketching and annotation
In this lesson
Freehand sketching and annotation: how to sketch a design idea freehand in 2D and 3D, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8552, Cambridge 0445, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Sketching ideas 2 of 3. More at https://scholafly.com
By the end: Sketch a design idea freehand in 2D and 3D, using a light crate so it reads clearly, and annotate it so that each note explains and justifies a decision - feature, reason, and what it means for this user; and give linked advantages and disadvantages of freehand sketching compared with CAD.
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: freehand sketching: annotation
- 0:38 Why sketch freehand
- 4:36 Freehand sketching: annotation: 2D and 3D sketches
- 7:42 Label or annotation
- 11:26 Back through it
- 12:21 Freehand sketching: annotation: two more
- 13:09 Feature, reason, meaning
Key words
About this video
Freehand sketching and annotation | GCSE Design & Tech | DT09-02
Freehand sketching and annotation: how to sketch a design idea freehand in 2D and 3D, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8552, Cambridge 0445, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Sketching ideas 2 of 3.
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: DT09-02 (search "ScholaFly DT09-02")
#GCSEDesignTech #SketchingIdeas
For teachers
This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches freehand sketching and annotation. By the end, students should be able to sketch a design idea freehand in 2D and 3D, using a light crate so it reads clearly, and annotate it so that each note explains and justifies a decision - feature, reason, and what it means for this user; and give linked advantages and disadvantages of freehand sketching compared with CAD. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8552
- 3.3.5
Edexcel 1DT0
- 1.17.1
- 1.17.2
Eduqas C600QS
- 2.2 core.8
OCR J310
- 4.1a
Cambridge 0445-2027
- 1 > Communication of design ideas > b1
- 1 > Generation of possible ideas > b1
- 5 > Freehand drawings > b1
Cambridge 0445-2028
- 1.2.3/b1
- 1.3.1/b1
Read the transcript
Picture two sketches of the same bike phone mount, drawn by the same hand, that get opposite answers from the client. What could make the difference? The first sketch has three labels on it: strap, clip and rubber. The client reads them and asks, "So what?" The second sketch is the same drawing with three notes in place of the labels, and the client reads those and says yes. What those three notes say is where this video ends up.
A freehand sketch is a drawing made by hand, without a ruler, a compass or any other instrument. Designers sketch first because it is fast and cheap. A pencil and paper are all it needs, so it works anywhere, on a bus or across a table in a meeting. That speed lets a designer try many ideas and change direction, before time or money has gone into any one of them. Now a quick one. A designer has fifteen minutes in a coffee shop and wants to try six different shapes for a lamp. Freehand sketching, or CAD, which is designing on a computer, and why? Sketching. Six rough shapes take minutes with a pencil, and nothing has to be set up or switched on first. A sketch is judged on how well it explains an idea, not on how pretty it is. A rough sketch that explains beats a polished one that does not. Sketching has drawbacks too. Compared with CAD, a sketch is less accurate, because nothing in it is drawn to exact sizes. A sketch is harder to edit, copy, store or send. It cannot go straight to a machine, and how clear it is depends on the skill of whoever drew it. Now an exam-style task. A designer is developing a clip that holds a reusable water bottle on a backpack strap. The task wants an advantage of developing the clip by freehand sketching rather than in CAD, and a disadvantage too. Underline who each answer is about: freehand sketching, compared with CAD. Two answers for the advantage. Answer A says it is cheap. Answer B says a sketch needs only a pencil and paper, so ten clip shapes can be tried on the bus, far quicker than setting up a CAD model. Which one scores, and why? B scores. It makes a point about sketching, gives the reason, and links it to CAD and to this clip. A gives no reason and never mentions the clip. Now the disadvantage. How would you make the weak one, it is not accurate, work for this clip? Have a go at this one before I show you. A sketch is not drawn to exact sizes, so it cannot show whether the clip will grip a twenty-five millimetre strap. Every change means redrawing it, whereas a CAD model can be resized in seconds. Both strong answers start with the words a sketch, which keeps them written from the sketching side. One examiner's report on this kind of question says some students "did misread the question, where an advantage and disadvantage of CAD drawing was given rather than freehand sketching." The fix is to start each answer with the words a sketch. If a CAD advantage comes to mind, turn it round: a sketch cannot be resized in seconds, unlike CAD. The same report also notes that students "were able to explain with confidence about both an advantage and disadvantage of freehand sketching." Written from the right side, this is a question you can win.
A 2D sketch shows one flat face or outline of an object, while a 3D sketch shows three faces at once, so the object looks solid. A 3D sketch can be isometric, with the sides sloping up at about thirty degrees, or perspective, with lines shrinking towards a point in the distance. Here both are drawn by eye. Drawing them accurately, with a set square or with vanishing points, belongs to the technical drawing chapter. A 3D sketch usually starts from a crate. A crate is a faint box, sketched first, about the size of the whole object. You then cut the shape out of the crate, the way a carver cuts a figure out of a block of wood, and firm up the final outline with a darker line. Why start with a faint box, rather than drawing the outline straight away? The box fixes the overall size and the slope of every edge before any detail goes in, so everything taken from it stays in proportion. Faint marks hardly show once the edges are gone over, so a wrong mark does no harm. Draw it big. A large sketch has room for detail and for notes, and a tiny one hides both. Take a desk stand that holds a tablet at an angle the user can change. Start with a faint crate, a box roughly the size of the stand, with its edges sloping at about thirty degrees. Cut a base plate and a back support out of the crate, then go over their outline with a darker line. The sketch now has to show the angle changing. One student writes angle adjusts beside the back. Another draws a hinge, a curved slotted arm and a wing nut, with an arrow for the back swinging. Which sketch shows how the idea works, and why? The second. A label only says what a part does, while the drawing shows the thing that does it, so anyone can see how the angle changes. A small detail sketch, a close-up of the wing nut clamping the arm in its slot, makes the mechanism plainer still. One examiner's report on a design sketching question says it was sometimes unclear how a design idea would work. The reason it gives is that the sketches only had labels saying what a part did, rather than details of the actual mechanism. So if the idea has to do something, draw the part that does it, and add an arrow for the movement.
A label names a part, while an annotation is a note that explains a design decision and justifies it. Each annotation does that in three pieces: the feature, the reason for it, and what it means for this product and its user. The tablet stand's note reads: wing nut on a slotted arm, loosen, swing and tighten, so the tablet can be set anywhere from thirty to seventy degrees and stays there. Notes on a design sketch do three jobs. They show how each requirement is met, how the idea works, and how the idea developed from one sketch to the next. A development note says what changed and why, such as: second version, arm made wider, because the first one slipped on a thick phone case. Keep each note short and readable, with a leader line, a thin line running from the note to the exact part it describes. Now back to the bike phone mount. Its client wants three things from it. It must hold phones from sixty-five to eighty millimetres wide. It must fit handlebars from twenty-two to thirty-two millimetres across. And it must go on without tools. A weak note for the first requirement would read: holds phones sixty-five to eighty millimetres wide. What is wrong with that note? That note only copies out what the client asked for. Nothing in it says how the mount manages to do it. One examiner's report on a sketching question records that in many cases the sketches were very small, and the notes lacked detail, often only restating features already given in the specification. Draw big, then, and make each note say how the requirement is met, rather than what the requirement is. A strong note names the feature: a silicone rubber cradle with stretchy side arms. It gives the reason: the arms stretch about fifteen millimetres. And it says what that means: any phone from sixty-five to eighty millimetres wide is gripped without scratching. Now the second requirement, the range of handlebar widths. The feature drawn for it is a clamp that swings open, moulded in plastic, with ridges on the inside surface. How would you annotate that clamp? Try it on paper before I show you the answer. Hinged polypropylene clamp with a ribbed inner face. The hinge opens wide and the ribs bite, so it closes tight on any bar from twenty-two to thirty-two millimetres across. One more, and this time the feature is given: a thumb screw closes the clamp. Why does that meet the third requirement? The thumb screw is turned by hand, so no tools are needed to fit the mount, and that ticks off the third requirement. Each requirement now has its own note on its own leader line, so the client can tick every one off.
Back through it now, and each time you answer before I do.
What is a crate, and what does it do for a 3D sketch? It is a faint box the size of the object, sketched first. The shape is cut out of it, so the sketch stays in proportion.
Now a fresh one. A lunchbox sketch carries the label wide catch. How would you turn it into an annotation? Something like: wide catch on the lid, big enough to push with a whole thumb, so a young child can open it without help. That is the feature, the reason, and what it means for the user.
Another one. A sketch of a folding chair carries the label folds flat. What should the designer draw instead? Draw the hinge that lets the chair fold, with an arrow for the movement, and add a note saying how it works.
One more to finish. What is a disadvantage of freehand sketching compared with CAD, written from the sketching side? For example: a sketch cannot go straight to a machine, so the design has to be redrawn in CAD before any part can be cut.
That is the difference between the two sketches of the bike mount. Each of the second sketch's three notes named a feature, gave the reason, and said what it meant for the rider, while the first sketch only named the parts.
When this one feels like it is in the bag, give it a thumbs-up. If it is not there yet, save it, because it comes with the questions, so try a few and come back.
Next in the chapter is Digital tools for developing and sharing design ideas. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly D T oh nine, oh four.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8552, Edexcel GCSE 1DT0, Eduqas GCSE C600QS, OCR GCSE J310, Cambridge GCSE 0445
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8552 | 3.3.5 | {'ref': None, 'text': 'freehand sketching, isometric and perspective'}; {'ref': None, 'text': '2D and 3D drawings'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'system and schematic diagrams'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'annotated drawings that explain detailed development or the conceptual stages of designing'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'exploded diagrams to show constructional detail or assembly'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'working drawings: 3rd angle orthographic, using conventions, dimensions and drawn to scale'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'audio and visual recordings in support of aspects of designing: eg interviews with client or users'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'mathematical modelling'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'computer based tools'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'modelling: working directly with materials and components, eg card modelling, producing a toile when designing garments, constructing a circuit using breadboard.'} |
| Edexcel GCSE 1DT0 | 1.17.1 | {'ref': '1.17.1a', 'text': 'freehand sketching (2D and/or 3D)'}; {'ref': '1.17.1b', 'text': 'annotated sketches'}; {'ref': '1.17.1c', 'text': 'cut and paste techniques'}; {'ref': '1.17.1d', 'text': 'digital photography/media'}; {'ref': '1.17.1e', 'text': '3D models'}; {'ref': '1.17.1f', 'text': 'isometric and oblique projection'}; {'ref': '1.17.1g', 'text': 'perspective drawing'}; {'ref': '1.17.1h', 'text': 'orthographic and exploded views'}; {'ref': '1.17.1i', 'text': 'assembly drawings'}; {'ref': '1.17.1j', 'text': 'system and schematic diagrams'}; {'ref': '1.17.1k', 'text': 'computer-aided design (CAD) and other specialist computer drawing programs.'} |
| Edexcel GCSE 1DT0 | 1.17.2 | Recording and justifying design ideas in writing |
| Eduqas GCSE C600QS | 2.2 core.8 | {'ref': None, 'text': 'Formal and informal 2D and 3D drawing.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'System and schematic diagrams.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Annotated sketches.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Exploded diagrams.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Models.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Presentations.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Written notes.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Flow diagrams'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Working drawings.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Schedules.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Audio and visual recordings.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Mathematical modelling.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Computer-based tools.'} |
| OCR GCSE J310 | 4.1a | Graphical techniques to communicate design ideas to a third party |
| Cambridge GCSE 0445 | missing | the plan names no spec point for this board |
For teachers
This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches freehand sketching and annotation. By the end, students should be able to sketch a design idea freehand in 2D and 3D, using a light crate so it reads clearly, and annotate it so that each note explains and justifies a decision - feature, reason, and what it means for this user; and give linked advantages and disadvantages of freehand sketching compared with CAD. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.