ScholaFly

DT09-01 Design and Technology Watch

Communicating design ideas: choosing the right technique

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

Communicating design ideas: how to choose the right technique to communicate a design idea for a given purpose and audience. AQA 8552, Cambridge 0445, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Sketching ideas 1 of 3. More at https://scholafly.com

By the end: Choose the right technique to communicate a design idea for a given purpose and audience - a client, a user or a maker - name it precisely and justify the choice; and explain how audio and visual recordings, mathematical modelling, system and schematic diagrams and modelling with materials help a designer develop and record ideas.

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: communicating design ideas
  2. 0:43 Communicating design ideas: what a technique
  3. 3:39 Communicating design ideas: the drawings
  4. 7:45 System or schematic
  5. 9:48 Modelling with materials
  6. 11:54 Audio and visual recording
  7. 15:11 A justified choice
  8. 18:42 Quick recap
  9. 20:13 Back to the phone case

Key words

About this video

Communicating design ideas: choosing the right technique | GCSE Design & Tech | DT09-01

Communicating design ideas: how to choose the right technique to communicate a design idea for a given purpose and audience.
AQA 8552, Cambridge 0445, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Sketching ideas 1 of 3.
More at https://scholafly.com

Video code: DT09-01 (search "ScholaFly DT09-01")

#GCSEDesignTech #SketchingIdeas #CommunicatingDesignIdeas

For teachers
This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches communicating design ideas: choosing the right technique. By the end, students should be able to choose the right technique to communicate a design idea for a given purpose and audience - a client, a user or a maker - name it precisely and justify the choice; and explain how audio and visual recordings, mathematical modelling, system and schematic diagrams and modelling with materials help a designer develop and record ideas. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8552
- 3.3.5
Edexcel 1DT0
- 1.17.1
- 1.17.1a
- 1.17.1b
- 1.17.1e
- 1.17.1f
- 1.17.1g
- 1.17.1h
- 1.17.1j
- 1.17.1k
Eduqas C600QS
- 2.2 core.8
OCR J310
- 4.1a
Cambridge 0445-2027
- 1 > Communication of design ideas > b1
Cambridge 0445-2028
- 1.2.4/b2
- 1.3.1/b2

Read the transcript

Imagine one phone case idea and three people to convince by Friday. What do you put in front of each of them? The client wants to see how the case will look, but has never read a technical drawing. The factory wants every size, down to a tenth of a millimetre. And the user wants to hold the case before believing it will slip into a pocket. Hand all three the same quick sketch, and two of them are lost. By the close, you will make all three choices yourself, with a reason for each.

A communication technique is a way of showing a design idea, so that someone other than the designer can see it, judge it or make it. Every technique is something you could point at. A sketch on paper is one, and so is a card model in your hand or a video on a phone. An email is not a technique, and neither is a video call. Each of them only carries the idea from one place to another. The technique is whatever arrives at the other end: the drawing, the model or the recording that the person looks at. Try this one. A designer posts a client a printed, shaded 3D drawing of a lamp, then texts to ask what the client thinks. Which of the three is the technique: the post, the text or the shaded drawing? It is the shaded 3D drawing. The post and the text only carry it, and the drawing is what shows the client how the lamp will look. One examiner's report, on a question about how designers communicate their ideas, says many students "focused on information communication methods such as email and telephone." The fix is to name the thing the person looks at, and never the way it travels to them. Two things decide which technique you choose. The first is the purpose, meaning what the work is for at that moment. Early on, a designer explores lots of rough ideas. Later, the job is developing one idea, recording what was tried, presenting it, or telling someone how to make it. The second thing is the audience, the person who has to use what you show them. A client is the person or company that asked for the design. A user is whoever will use the finished product. A maker is whoever builds it, in a workshop or a factory. Now apply it. A hospital asks a design team for a new bedside table, and nurses will use it every shift. Who is the client here, and who are the users? The hospital is the client, because it asked for the design. The nurses are users, and so are the patients lying beside the table. That gives the rule for every choice that follows. The right technique is the one this person can use, for this job, and a drawing covered in sizes is no use to someone who has never learned to read one.

Most communication techniques are drawings, and each kind is named by what it shows. A freehand sketch is drawn by hand, with no ruler or instruments. It is quick and rough, which makes it the tool for exploring ideas early on. How to sketch well and annotate is the freehand sketching video's job. A 2D drawing shows one flat face of an object, with no depth. A 3D drawing shows three faces at once, so the object looks solid. Isometric and perspective are two named kinds of 3D drawing. In isometric, the sides slope up at thirty degrees. In perspective, lines shrink towards a point in the distance, the way your eye sees a long road. Now one to try. A client wants a drawing of a new kitchen that looks the way it would to someone standing in the doorway. Isometric or perspective, and why? Perspective. It shows the kitchen as a person in the doorway would see it, with the far wall smaller than the near one, so it looks real to the client. Isometric draws the far wall the same size as the near one. An annotated drawing carries notes that explain the design decisions, so a reader can follow how an idea developed from one stage to the next. An exploded diagram pulls a product's parts apart along lines, so you can see how they fit together. A torch comes with a leaflet showing its case, battery, spring and lens pulled apart along one line. Who is that drawing for, and why does it suit them? It is for the user, who has to change the battery. Spread out in order along one line, the pieces show the order in which the torch is rebuilt. A working drawing gives a maker everything needed to make the product. It is drawn in third angle orthographic projection, dimensioned in millimetres, and drawn to scale. Orthographic projection shows the object as separate flat views, usually a front view, a plan from above and an end view. Each view shows true shapes and sizes, which is why a workshop can measure straight from it. Third angle is the named layout, with the plan drawn above the front view, and each end view drawn on the side of the end it shows. Drawing these yourself is the technical drawing chapter's job. Here you only need to know each one by name, and who it suits. Now a different one. Three students name a drawing of a lamp base that has a front view, a plan and an end view, with the plan above the front view. One writes technical drawing, one writes side view, and one writes third angle orthographic projection. Which name is right, and why not the other two? Third angle orthographic projection is right. Technical drawing could mean a dozen kinds of drawing, and side view names only one of the three views. One examiner's report on a naming question like this says the answer needed a specific mention of third angle, or of orthographic, before it earned the mark. So write the full name every time. Write isometric, not a 3D drawing, and exploded diagram, not a picture of the parts.

A system diagram shows the stages of a product as labelled blocks joined by arrows, while a schematic diagram uses standard symbols to show how the components are wired together. Picture a night light that comes on when it senses movement, drawn both ways. Which technique is this: three labelled boxes, movement sensor, then control, then LED lamp, joined by arrows? That technique is a system diagram. It shows the stages and how they link, but not what any part looks like. The three boxes are the input, the process and the output, read in order along the arrows. Now the same night light again, with symbols for a battery, a switch, a resistor and an LED, and lines joining them. Which technique is that? A schematic diagram, which in electronics is often called a circuit diagram. It shows how the components connect, using symbols. One more on this pair. Which of the two could someone wire the light from, and why not the other one? Only the schematic, because it shows every component and every connection. The system diagram shows only the stages, so it explains the idea but nobody could build from it. That is why a system diagram suits explaining or planning a product, and a schematic suits whoever builds the circuit. How the sensor and the control do their work belongs to the electronic systems video.

Some techniques leave paper behind. Modelling with materials means building the idea in three dimensions, so it can be held, tried and checked. A mock-up in card or foam shows size and shape. A toile is a trial version of a garment, sewn in cheap fabric. A breadboard is a board you push components into, so a circuit can be tried without soldering. A model suits a user, because a person can hold it, wear it or press its buttons long before the real product exists. How to build and test one is the modelling and prototyping video's job. Mathematical modelling uses calculations, formulae or a spreadsheet to predict how a design will perform, or what it will cost, before anything is made. Say a shelf has to hold thirty paperbacks, and each one is about twenty-five millimetres thick. We multiply the number of books by the thickness of one. Thirty times twenty-five millimetres is seven hundred and fifty millimetres. That means the shelf needs at least seven hundred and fifty millimetres of space inside, and the designer knows it before a single plank is cut. Now name one. A spreadsheet works out how the material cost of a desk lamp changes as its aluminium stem gets longer. Which technique is that, and what does it give the designer? Mathematical modelling. It predicts the cost with numbers, so the designer can choose a stem length before any aluminium is bought. Computer-based tools are a technique too, from editing software to 3D models a client can turn round on a laptop. How they weigh up against a pencil is the digital tools video's job.

An audio or visual recording captures what a person said or did, or what a model did, using a phone, a camera or a microphone. A designer might record an interview with a client, film a user trying a model, film a test, or photograph each model as the idea changes. Three things sit in a design folder: a voice memo of a client interview, a sheet of six sketches, and photos of each card model as it changed. Which one is not a recording? The sheet of sketches. The designer drew it, so it shows the designer's own ideas, and it captures nothing that anyone said or did. One examiner's report, on a question about the advantages of recordings, says: "Responses talking about design sheets and sketches were not acceptable responses." Before you write about a recording, check that it involves a phone, a camera or a microphone. If none of them is there, the answer has drifted to sketching. A recording is fast to make with a phone, and it can be replayed or slowed down later. It is an accurate record that does not rely on anyone's memory, and it is evidence to show a client and keep in the design folder. It is also dated evidence of when an idea was yours, if anyone ever questions who owns it. Who owns a design belongs to the video on learning from other designers without copying. There are drawbacks too. You need permission before you record anyone, and the files take time to watch back and space to store. Now a worked one. A student designing the buckle on a child's bike helmet films five-year-olds trying to open and close a card and plastic model of it. Which two advantages does making that video bring while the buckle is developed? Write both down before you hear them. First, the video can be replayed and slowed down. That lets the designer see where small fingers slip and the direction they push in, detail that notes scribbled during the session would miss, and change the grip to suit. Second, the video is an accurate record of what the children did, so the designer does not rely on memory. Every change to the buckle can be backed by real evidence to show the client. Each advantage has the same shape: the point, the reason, and what it means for this buckle. The same report also says many students "made reference to ease and speed of creating recordings to inform the development of design ideas at a later time." If you had that, you have the first half of each advantage. The product in the question gives you the second half.

Choosing a technique is half an answer. The other half is the justification: the technique, what it shows, and why that suits this person and this job. Picture a folding camping stool, with aluminium legs and a canvas seat, and three jobs for its designer. First, the client, who does not read technical drawings, needs to see what the finished stool will look like. That job calls for a 3D presentation drawing, such as a shaded perspective sketch or a computer render. It shows form, colour and material the way the eye sees them, so a client with no technical training understands it at a glance. Second, the workshop needs every size it takes to cut the aluminium legs and the canvas seat. Which technique goes to the workshop, and why? Take your pick, and hold on to your reason before I show you. A working drawing in third angle orthographic projection, dimensioned in millimetres and drawn to scale. Each view shows true shapes and sizes, so the workshop can measure and cut without asking the designer. Third, the designer has to check that the seat height suits most adults before anything is made. This time the technique is given: a full-size mock-up in card, foam or scrap timber that people can sit on. The new step is yours. Why does a mock-up that adults sit on suit this seat check better than a drawing? Because real adults sit on it, the seat is tried for real before any aluminium is bought. A drawing can state a number, but it cannot tell you how that number feels. A spreadsheet of seat heights, built from measurements of real adults, could also do this job. That is mathematical modelling, answering the same question with numbers. Now a different question. Two students say how the stool's designer should present the design to the person who ordered it. Answer A lists sketches, models and computer drawings. Answer B gives a shaded perspective drawing, because the eye sees the stool that way, and that fits a person who cannot read technical drawings. Which answer is stronger, and why? B is stronger. A is a list of names with nothing about how each would be used, or why it suits this client, while B links the technique, what it shows and who it is for. One examiner's report on communicating design ideas records this weakness. Some students listed several techniques, such as sketching, modelling and computer simulations, but gave little detail about how each one would be used. The habit that fixes it: every technique you name gets its own reason, saying what it shows and why that suits this person.

Quick run back through it, and this time the remembering is yours.

What two things decide which technique a designer chooses? Two things decide it: the purpose, which is what the work is for at that moment, and the audience, the person who has to use it.

Now a quick sort. A video call with the client, to talk through a model: is the call a technique? No. The call only carries the idea, and the technique is the model the client looks at during it.

Another kind. A fashion designer wants a client to try the fit of a jacket before the final fabric is cut. Which technique suits, and why? A toile, the trial version sewn in cheap fabric. The client can wear it, and the fit can be changed before the real fabric is touched.

One more: what are the three parts of a justified choice? The three parts are the technique, what it shows, and why that suits this person and this job.

Now back to the phone case and its three people. Which technique does each one get, and why? Pause it there and work it out for yourself. The client gets a 3D presentation drawing, such as a render, because it shows how the case will look to someone who cannot read a technical drawing. The factory gets a working drawing in third angle orthographic projection, dimensioned in millimetres, because every size is there to measure. And the user gets a model to hold, because only holding it shows whether it slips into a pocket. One quick sketch could never have done all three jobs.

If you could teach this one to a friend, give it a thumbs-up and move on. If any part still feels shaky, save it, give it a day and look again.

Next in the chapter is Freehand sketching and annotation. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly D T oh nine, oh two.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8552, Edexcel GCSE 1DT0, Eduqas GCSE C600QS, OCR GCSE J310, Cambridge GCSE 0445

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 85523.3.5{'ref': None, 'text': 'freehand sketching, isometric and perspective'}; {'ref': None, 'text': '2D and 3D drawings'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'system and schematic diagrams'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'annotated drawings that explain detailed development or the conceptual stages of designing'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'exploded diagrams to show constructional detail or assembly'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'working drawings: 3rd angle orthographic, using conventions, dimensions and drawn to scale'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'audio and visual recordings in support of aspects of designing: eg interviews with client or users'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'mathematical modelling'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'computer based tools'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'modelling: working directly with materials and components, eg card modelling, producing a toile when designing garments, constructing a circuit using breadboard.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1{'ref': '1.17.1a', 'text': 'freehand sketching (2D and/or 3D)'}; {'ref': '1.17.1b', 'text': 'annotated sketches'}; {'ref': '1.17.1c', 'text': 'cut and paste techniques'}; {'ref': '1.17.1d', 'text': 'digital photography/media'}; {'ref': '1.17.1e', 'text': '3D models'}; {'ref': '1.17.1f', 'text': 'isometric and oblique projection'}; {'ref': '1.17.1g', 'text': 'perspective drawing'}; {'ref': '1.17.1h', 'text': 'orthographic and exploded views'}; {'ref': '1.17.1i', 'text': 'assembly drawings'}; {'ref': '1.17.1j', 'text': 'system and schematic diagrams'}; {'ref': '1.17.1k', 'text': 'computer-aided design (CAD) and other specialist computer drawing programs.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1a
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1b
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1c
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1d
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1e
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1f
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1g
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1h
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1i
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1j
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.17.1k
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.2 core.8{'ref': None, 'text': 'Formal and informal 2D and 3D drawing.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'System and schematic diagrams.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Annotated sketches.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Exploded diagrams.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Models.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Presentations.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Written notes.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Flow diagrams'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Working drawings.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Schedules.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Audio and visual recordings.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Mathematical modelling.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Computer-based tools.'}
OCR GCSE J3104.1aGraphical techniques to communicate design ideas to a third party
Cambridge GCSE 0445missingthe plan names no spec point for this board
For teachers

This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches communicating design ideas: choosing the right technique. By the end, students should be able to choose the right technique to communicate a design idea for a given purpose and audience - a client, a user or a maker - name it precisely and justify the choice; and explain how audio and visual recordings, mathematical modelling, system and schematic diagrams and modelling with materials help a designer develop and record ideas. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.