ScholaFly

DT08-04 Design and Technology Watch

Environmental, social and economic challenges in design and making

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

Environmental for GCSE Design & Tech, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8552, Cambridge 0445, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Ethics and fair trade 4 of 4. More at https://scholafly.com

By the end: Students can explain how environmental, social and economic challenges influence designing and making, and how AQA's three named challenges - deforestation, a possible increase in carbon dioxide leading to global warming, and the need for fair trade - each present opportunities and constraints for a named product.

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: environmental: challenges
  2. 0:45 Environmental: challenges: three kinds of challenge
  3. 2:23 Environmental: challenges: deforestation
  4. 4:29 Rising carbon dioxide
  5. 6:36 Fair trade and carbon dioxide

Key words

About this video

Environmental, social and economic challenges in design and making | GCSE Design & Tech | DT08-04

Environmental for GCSE Design & Tech, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8552, Cambridge 0445, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Ethics and fair trade 4 of 4.
More at https://scholafly.com

Watch first: DT08-02 - https://youtu.be/gctmXdhqVws, DT07-05 - https://youtu.be/B5CJmHuvImM, DT07-03 - https://youtu.be/TxFkAoB3BFE, DT07-04 - https://youtu.be/lHcGpC7BMdE
Video code: DT08-04 (search "ScholaFly DT08-04")

#GCSEDesignTech #EthicsAndFairTrade #EnvironmentalChallenges

For teachers
This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches environmental, social and economic challenges in design and making. By the end, students should be able to students can explain how environmental, social and economic challenges influence designing and making, and how AQA's three named challenges - deforestation, a possible increase in carbon dioxide leading to global warming, and the need for fair trade - each present opportunities and constraints for a named product. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8552
- 3.3.2
Edexcel 1DT0
- 1.14.2
Eduqas C600QS
- 2.2 core.4
OCR J310
- 3.3a
- 3.3a.ii
Cambridge 0445-2027
- 1 > Design & technology in society > b1
Cambridge 0445-2028
- 1.2.5/b5

Read the transcript

Why would anyone pay more for a table made from old, scarred planks than for a brand-new one? Tables made from old scaffold boards keep their nail holes, saw marks and paint splashes. Even so, they can cost more than a brand-new pine table. The look is part of the answer. So is worry about forests being cut down faster than they are replanted, because a table like that needs no new tree felled. A problem for the planet has become something people pay extra for. The scaffold-board table gets its full answer after three big challenges are laid out.

Three kinds of challenge push on every design: environmental, social and economic. Environmental challenges are about the planet: forests, the climate and pollution. Social challenges are about people and communities. Economic challenges are about money: costs, prices, jobs, and what customers will pay. Here is a factor a lamp maker faces: customers will only pay twenty pounds for a lamp. Which kind of challenge is that: environmental, social or economic? Economic. It is about price and what customers will pay, and it caps what the product can cost to make. Every challenge pushes on a design in two ways. A constraint is a limit on what the designer or maker can do, such as cost, materials, suppliers, processes or the law. An opportunity is a chance for a new or better product, a new group of customers, or a selling point. This video works with three challenges. Deforestation, and a possible rise in carbon dioxide leading to global warming, are environmental. The need for fair trade is social and economic, and every one of them has an economic side, cost and sales, where the design decision gets made.

Deforestation is forests being cut down faster than they are replanted. How products cause it has its own video, in the sustainability chapter. Take a maker of children's wooden toys, facing that challenge. What is one constraint and one opportunity for the toys? Give it a go before the reveal. One constraint: the maker must buy certified timber, such as FSC-certified beech. The FSC, the Forest Stewardship Council, marks wood that was harvested responsibly. That wood can cost more and narrows the choice, so the toys may be priced higher. The designer might use smaller, simpler parts, or offcuts for the little pieces. One opportunity: the toys can be sold as made from sustainably sourced wood. That appeals to parents who care about forests, and it helps the brand stand out from plastic toys. The same challenge opens other doors too: reclaimed timber, taken from old buildings and used again, upcycled wood turned into something worth more, and boards made from waste wood. How would you make this vague point specific for the toys: use eco materials? One way: make the toy bodies from FSC-certified beech, and cut the small wheels from beech offcuts. That names the wood and the change. One examiner's report puts it this way: Many candidate responses were quite vague and did not give a specific enough example to be awarded the mark. The fix is to name the change: the timber, the part, the process.

The second challenge is a possible rise in carbon dioxide, a gas that traps heat in the air, leading to global warming. How products add to it has its own video too. As a constraint, a maker has to cut the energy used in manufacture and use less material. It also has to cut product miles, the distance a product and its materials travel, to meet what customers and the law expect. As an opportunity, a designer can create energy-saving products, a lower-carbon range, or products made locally from fewer materials. Now two answers on how rising carbon dioxide affects a product's design. The first: climate change is bad for the planet, so companies should help stop it. The second: so the designer uses fewer materials and sources them locally, which cuts the energy and transport behind each product. Which answer is about the product, and what does the other one do instead? The answer about fewer materials, sourced locally. Every sentence ends at the product: its materials, its energy, its making. The first is about the climate in general, and never reaches the product. One examiner's report, on a question about how rising carbon dioxide affects design and manufacture, records this: There were a number of responses that did not relate to the question, with discussion of global warming and climate change in isolation. The same report also notes: Common responses considered the sourcing of materials, energy consumption and using fewer materials. Both lines describe the same question. Many students found the right links, and some never reached the product. The fix for the second group is to end every sentence at the product.

The third challenge is the need for fair trade, which guarantees producers in developing countries a fair price. The fair trade video explains how it works. Now a company is designing a new range of hoodies. One opportunity and one constraint each, for fair trade and for carbon dioxide? Fair trade first. The opportunity: the hoodies can carry the Fairtrade mark and be sold to customers who choose ethical clothing, which builds the brand's reputation. The constraint: Fairtrade cotton costs more and fewer suppliers are certified, so the designer may simplify the hoodie, with fewer panels and less fabric, to hold the price. Now carbon dioxide. The opportunity: a lower-carbon range, made nearer to the UK or with recycled polyester in the blend, can be marketed as climate-conscious. The constraint: the company must cut the energy used in dyeing and sewing, and cut product miles. That may limit where it can manufacture and which processes it uses, and may raise costs. Every one of those four ends at the hoodie itself: its fabric, its panels, where it is made, and how it is sold.

To close the chapter, four questions on challenges, with the scaffold-board table last. What is the difference between an opportunity and a constraint? A constraint limits what the designer or maker can do. An opportunity is a chance for a new or better product, a new market or a selling point. Now a furniture maker uses chipboard from waste wood. Which challenge, and which side? Deforestation, as an opportunity. A board made from waste wood needs fewer trees felled, and the maker can sell it that way. A different one, for a kettle: global warming is a big problem. Make it end at the product. Something like: so the kettle is designed to boil only the water needed, which cuts its energy use and lets it be sold as energy-saving. Now the scaffold-board table from the start: which challenge, and which side of it? Deforestation, and it shows both sides. Worry about forests limits new timber, a constraint, and the maker turns old boards into a table people pay more for, an opportunity.

If opportunities and constraints click now, you've nailed it: a thumbs up on this one, and every video in this chapter is ticked off your list. If it still feels loose, save it, give it a day, and look again.

That completes our chapter on Ethics, fair trade and responsibility in design. Next chapter: Sketching and communicating design ideas. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly D T oh nine, oh oh.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8552, Edexcel GCSE 1DT0, Eduqas GCSE C600QS, OCR GCSE J310, Cambridge GCSE 0445

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 85523.3.2{'ref': None, 'text': 'The environment, social and economic challenges that influence design and making.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'How the following might present opportunities and constraints that influence the processes of designing and making: • deforestation • possible increase in carbon dioxide levels leading to potential global warming • the need for fair trade.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.14.2Environmental, social and economic issues: fair trade, carbon offsetting, disassembly and disposal
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.2 core.4{'ref': None, 'text': 'Investigate factors, such as environmental, social and economic challenges, in order to identify opportunities and constraints that influence the processes of designing and making.', 'role': 'content_statement', 'lines': [44, 50]}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Designing should not take place in isolation but there are wider needs to be considered:', 'role': 'lead_in', 'lines': [51, 52]}
OCR GCSE J3103.3a{'ref': '3.3a.i', 'text': 'environmental initiatives'}; {'ref': '3.3a.ii', 'text': 'fair trade'}; {'ref': '3.3a.iii', 'text': 'social and ethical awareness'}; {'ref': '3.3a.iv', 'text': 'global sustainable development.'}
OCR GCSE J3103.3a.i
OCR GCSE J3103.3a.ii
OCR GCSE J3103.3a.iii
OCR GCSE J3103.3a.iv
Cambridge GCSE 0445missingthe plan names no spec point for this board
For teachers

This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches environmental, social and economic challenges in design and making. By the end, students should be able to students can explain how environmental, social and economic challenges influence designing and making, and how AQA's three named challenges - deforestation, a possible increase in carbon dioxide leading to global warming, and the need for fair trade - each present opportunities and constraints for a named product. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.