ScholaFly

DT08-03 Design and Technology Watch

Social footprint: the responsibilities of designers and manufacturers

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

Social footprint for GCSE Design & Tech, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8552, Cambridge 0445, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Ethics and fair trade 3 of 4. More at https://scholafly.com

By the end: Students can explain a product's social footprint - its effect on people through the way it is made, used and disposed of - and the responsibilities AQA names for designers and manufacturers: safe working conditions, reducing oceanic and atmospheric pollution, and reducing the negative impact on others, each with a specific example and what can be done.

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: social footprint: duties
  2. 0:46 Social footprint: duties: what it means
  3. 2:19 Three duties towards people
  4. 4:23 Duty two: ocean and air pollution
  5. 7:09 Duty three: impact on others

Key words

About this video

Social footprint: the responsibilities of designers and manufacturers | GCSE Design & Tech | DT08-03

Social footprint for GCSE Design & Tech, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8552, Cambridge 0445, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Ethics and fair trade 3 of 4.
More at https://scholafly.com

Video code: DT08-03 (search "ScholaFly DT08-03")

#GCSEDesignTech #EthicsAndFairTrade #SocialFootprintDuties

For teachers
This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches social footprint: the responsibilities of designers and manufacturers. By the end, students should be able to students can explain a product's social footprint - its effect on people through the way it is made, used and disposed of - and the responsibilities AQA names for designers and manufacturers: safe working conditions, reducing oceanic and atmospheric pollution, and reducing the negative impact on others, each with a specific example and what can be done. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8552
- 3.2.3:Social issues in the design and manufacture of products
Edexcel 1DT0
- 2.2.6
- 3.2.7
- 5.2.7
- 6.2.8
- 7.2.7
Eduqas C600QS
- 2.1 core.2
- 2.1 in-depth a.2
- 2.1 in-depth b.2
- 2.1 in-depth c.2
- 2.1 in-depth d.2
- 2.1 in-depth e.2
- 2.1 in-depth f.2
OCR J310
- 5.3c
Cambridge 0445-2027
- 1 > Environment and sustainability > b4

Read the transcript

Cracks appear in the walls of a factory building. What should happen the next morning? The obvious answer is that nobody goes in until it is checked and made safe. Near Dhaka, in Bangladesh, in April two thousand and thirteen, that is not what happened. Cracks were found in an eight-storey building full of garment factories. The next morning, the workers were told to come back in, and the building collapsed. More than eleven hundred people were killed. They had been making clothes for high-street shops like the ones you use. That factory floor returns at the end, when the cost to people has a name.

A product's social footprint is the effect it has on people, through the way it is made, used and thrown away. Those people are the workers who make it, the communities where it is made, the people who use it, and people far away who never see it. A carbon footprint is a different measure: the amount of carbon dioxide released across a product's life. A social footprint is the effect on people. Here are two points about a fleece jacket. The first point: a lorry delivering the jackets burns diesel and releases carbon dioxide. The other: the dye works that colours the fabric lets its waste into a river, and families downstream can no longer wash or fish in it. Which of the two is a social footprint point, and why? The dye in the river. It names the people harmed, the families downstream, and what it does to them. The lorry is a carbon footprint point. One examiner's report records this: It seemed that many were unfamiliar with a social footprint and so veered towards the more familiar carbon footprint in their answers. The fix is to name the people in every social footprint point: who is affected, and what it does to them.

Designers and manufacturers carry three duties towards people. They must provide safe working conditions, reduce pollution of the oceans and the air, and reduce the harm their products do to others. Safe working conditions come first: a safe building, guards on machines, protective equipment, clean air wherever paints, glues and dyes are used, and reasonable hours. Without them, people are injured or made ill making the product. Take a factory that makes steel bike frames, then spray-paints them. What are two ways to make that factory safe, and the harm each one prevents? For the paint, spray the frames inside an extraction booth, which pulls the fumes away, and give the painters respirator masks. That way they do not breathe in solvent fumes that can damage their lungs. For the machinery, fit guards to the cutting and grinding machines and train every worker first, so that hands cannot reach moving blades. A safe building, rest breaks and reasonable hours count as well. Each of those fixes names this factory's own process, spraying the frames or cutting the tubes, where a point about factories in general could be about anywhere. One examiner's report, on a question about making a steel toolbox, puts it this way: Most responses to this question were too implicit and did not make explicit reference to the toolbox's production. Candidates are expected to provide evidence of specific and relevant examples of production processes in the answers they provide. The fix: tie every point to a named process, such as spray-painting the frames, rather than to factories in general.

The second duty is reducing pollution of the oceans and the air. It shows best across one product's whole life, following each kind of pollution to where it goes, and then to the people it reaches. Take a polyester fleece jacket. Polyester is made from crude oil, and the plants and factories that make it burn fossil fuels for power. How could making that polyester harm the air people breathe? That burning releases gases such as sulphur dioxide, which irritates the lungs, along with fine soot particles. People nearby breathe poorer air, and further away the gases fall as acid rain, rain made acidic by them. Dyeing the fabric can release dye and chemicals into rivers, which carry them to the sea, past anyone who drinks from or fishes in those rivers on the way. Now the jacket is in someone's wardrobe. How could washing it pollute the sea? Every wash sheds tiny plastic fibres, called microfibres. Some slip through water treatment and reach the sea, where sea creatures eat them, and they enter the food chain that people eat from. Then disposal. In landfill, polyester can last for hundreds of years, and burned, it gives off fumes. Of those three stages, which is hardest for the designer to control, and why? Washing. It happens in every home, for years, out of the designer's reach. The fabric and the dyeing are in the designer's hands, but the washing needs designer and user working together. What can be done: make the fleece from recycled plastic bottles, knit it more tightly, which can cut shedding, sell a washing bag that traps fibres, and filter the dye works' waste water. One examiner's report, on a question about pollution from making, using and disposing of products, notes this: Students are to be commended on how many responses focused in on the required manufacture, use and disposal of products. Many responses correctly considered both atmospheric and oceanic forms of pollution. That shape works. The habit that lifts it is a specific example at every stage, with the people the pollution reaches named.

The third duty is reducing the harm done to others: people living near mines, farms and factories, and people downstream or far away. That harm can be water drained or poisoned, noise, or damage to their health. Here is a question about denim jeans: explain one way making them can harm people living near the cotton farms or the dye works. The first student writes: it is bad for the environment. The second writes: cotton needs huge amounts of water to grow, so rivers and wells near the farms can run low, leaving local families short of water for drinking and for their own crops. Which of the two answers would you back, and what is the other missing? The water answer. It names the cause, cotton's thirst for water, what it does, rivers and wells running low, and who it harms, local families. The first names no cause and no people. Another answer that works: a dye works that lets untreated dye into a river leaves people downstream with polluted water. One examiner's report records this about one question: Answers, however, were quite narrow, focusing on carbon footprint in transportation and poor working conditions, pay of employees. The fix is to reach across all three duties, with a different point for each: working conditions, the oceans and air, and the people around.

Four questions on the duties now, and the last one returns to that factory near Dhaka. What is a product's social footprint? A product's social footprint is its effect on people, through the way it is made, used and thrown away. Now a new workshop: a firm sands and varnishes wooden chairs. One hazard, and its fix? The hazard is fine sawdust or varnish fumes. The fix is dust extraction and masks, so the workers do not breathe them in. Here's a village instead: a mine drains its wells dry. Which duty does that fall under? That duty is reducing the harm done to others. The villagers never touch the product, but they carry its cost. Now the cracked walls near Dhaka: which duty failed, and what should it have meant? Safe working conditions. A safe building comes first, so the cracks should have kept everyone out until the building was checked and made safe.

If the three duties are clear in your head, you own this one, and a thumbs up now saves you watching it twice. If they are not, keep the video saved, and know that nobody holds all three duties straight first time.

Next in the chapter: Environmental, social and economic challenges in design and making. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly D T oh eight, oh four.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8552, Edexcel GCSE 1DT0, Eduqas GCSE C600QS, OCR GCSE J310, Cambridge GCSE 0445

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 85523.2.3:Social issues in the design and manufacture of productsSocial issues: safe working conditions, reducing pollution and negative impact on others
Edexcel GCSE 1DT02.2.6{'ref': '2.2.6a', 'text': 'trend forecasting'}; {'ref': '2.2.6b', 'text': 'impact of extraction and material production on communities and wildlife'}; {'ref': '2.2.6c', 'text': 'ease and difficulty of recycling and disposal.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT03.2.7{'ref': '3.2.7a', 'text': 'trend forecasting'}; {'ref': '3.2.7b', 'text': 'impact of material production on communities and wildlife'}; {'ref': '3.2.7c', 'text': 'impact of logging and material production on communities and wildlife'}; {'ref': '3.2.7d', 'text': 'recycling/disposal – ethical responsibility'}; {'ref': '3.2.7e', 'text': 'reduction of packaging materials – reduction in litter/waste/energy use'}; {'ref': '3.2.7f', 'text': 'brand identity – consumerism, changing the packaging of products over time.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT05.2.7{'ref': '5.2.7a', 'text': 'relying on scarce and/or hazardous elements used in components and systems – cobalt, tantalum, lithium'}; {'ref': '5.2.7b', 'text': 'effects of using components and systems, including modern communications – mobile phones, computers, games consoles, social media networks.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT06.2.8{'ref': '6.2.8a', 'text': 'trend forecasting'}; {'ref': '6.2.8b', 'text': 'impact of material production on communities and wildlife'}; {'ref': '6.2.8c', 'text': 'impact of farming and material production on communities and wildlife'}; {'ref': '6.2.8d', 'text': 'recycling/disposal – ethical responsibility'}; {'ref': '6.2.8e', 'text': 'reduction of chemical finishes – surface and aftercare treatments'}; {'ref': '6.2.8f', 'text': 'reduction of packaging materials – reduction in litter/waste/energy use'}; {'ref': '6.2.8g', 'text': 'brand identity – consumerism, changing the packaging of products over time.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT07.2.7{'ref': '7.2.7a', 'text': 'trend forecasting'}; {'ref': '7.2.7b', 'text': 'impact of logging on communities'}; {'ref': '7.2.7c', 'text': 'ease and difficulty of recycling and disposal.'}
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.1 core.2{'ref': None, 'text': 'How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions; considering contemporary and potential future scenarios from different perspectives, such as ethics and the environment', 'role': 'content_statement', 'lines': [161, 171]}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'The focus of this content is how the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions.', 'role': 'lead_in', 'lines': [172, 173]}
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.1 in-depth a.2Functional benefits and limitations of components
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.1 in-depth b.2{'ref': None, 'text': 'The way in which the selection of materials or components is influenced by a range of factors, such as functional, aesthetic, environmental, availability, cost, social, cultural and ethical', 'role': 'content_statement', 'lines': [32, 42]}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Advantages and disadvantages of common paper, card and boards for commercial and everyday use: layout paper, tracing paper, copier paper, recycled paper, cartridge paper, mounting board, folding boxboard and corrugated board.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'The reasons for use of paper, card and boards in everyday products.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'The aesthetic properties of paper, card and boards.'}
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.1 in-depth c.2{'ref': None, 'text': 'The way in which the selection of materials or components is influenced by a range of factors, such as functional, aesthetic, environmental, availability, cost, social, cultural and ethical', 'role': 'content_statement', 'lines': [30, 40]}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Functional properties of natural and manufactured timbers.'}
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.1 in-depth d.2Aesthetic and functional properties of named metals
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.1 in-depth e.2Aesthetic and functional properties of plastics in everyday products
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.1 in-depth f.2{'ref': None, 'text': 'The way in which the selection of materials or components is influenced by a range of factors, such as functional, aesthetic, environmental, availability, cost, social, cultural and ethical', 'role': 'content_statement', 'lines': [51, 61]}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Different methods of enhancing the appearance, prolonging and protecting life.'}
OCR GCSE J3105.3cEcological, social and ethical issues of processing materials into workable forms
Cambridge GCSE 0445missingthe plan names no spec point for this board
For teachers

This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches social footprint: the responsibilities of designers and manufacturers. By the end, students should be able to students can explain a product's social footprint - its effect on people through the way it is made, used and disposed of - and the responsibilities AQA names for designers and manufacturers: safe working conditions, reducing oceanic and atmospheric pollution, and reducing the negative impact on others, each with a specific example and what can be done. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.