PH08-03 Physics Watch
Changes of state and conservation of mass
In this lesson
Changes of state: how to explain, using particles, why a change of state conserves mass and can be reversed to give back the original material. AQA 8463, Edexcel 1PH0 and OCR J249 GCSE. Particles and matter 3 of 10. More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: changes of state: mass
- 0:31 Changes of state
- 2:45 Mass is conserved
- 4:57 Physical or chemical
- 9:32 Changes of state: mass: the candle
Key words
About this video
Changes of state and conservation of mass | GCSE Physics | PH08-03
Changes of state: how to explain, using particles, why a change of state conserves mass and can be reversed to give back the original material.
AQA 8463, Edexcel 1PH0 and OCR J249 GCSE. Particles and matter 3 of 10.
More at https://scholafly.com
Watch first: PH08-01 - https://youtu.be/ignl5CWsYNM
Video code: PH08-03 (search "ScholaFly PH08-03")
#GCSEPhysics #ParticlesAndMatter #ChangesOfStateMass
For teachers
This GCSE Physics lesson teaches changes of state and conservation of mass. By the end, students should be able to explain, using particles, why a change of state conserves mass and can be reversed to give back the original material. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8463
- 4.3.1.2
Edexcel 1PH0
- 14.5
OCR J249
- P1.2a
- P1.2b
Read the transcript
A lit candle is doing two different things to its wax at the same time. Could cooling it down undo both? The wax that runs down the side sets again as wax, and you could pick it off and melt it back on. The wax that reaches the flame is gone for good, and no amount of cooling will ever bring it back. The candle's two kinds of change get sorted out by the end.
In the particle model, a solid's particles touch in neat rows, a liquid's touch with no pattern, and a gas's are far apart. When a substance moves from one of those states to another, that is a change of state, and there are six of them. Heat a solid enough and its particles break out of their fixed rows, but stay touching and start to slide. Solid to liquid is called melting. Run that backwards and the sliding particles lock into fixed positions in a regular pattern. Liquid to solid is called freezing. Now a liquid whose particles separate and fly off far apart, moving fast in every direction. Which two words name that change, from the liquid state into the gas state? Boiling, or evaporating. Both take a liquid to a gas, and how they differ is not something the course asks for. Backwards again, gas particles slow, come together and touch, with no pattern. Gas to liquid is called condensing. The sixth is rarer. A solid's particles leave their fixed rows and go straight to being far apart, skipping the liquid. Solid to gas is called sublimating. Dry ice, which is frozen carbon dioxide, does this at room temperature, which is why it shrinks away without ever making a puddle. Notice the order in every one of those: what the particles do first, and the name second. That order matters. One examiner's report, on a Higher paper, notes that many answers which scored nothing named and described the changes of state and never talked about particles. The fix is to describe the arrangement, spacing and movement of the particles before you name the change.
During a change of state, the mass of the substance stays the same, and the particles explain why. No particles are added, and none are destroyed. The same particles are present, so the mass is the same. One examiner's report, on a Foundation paper, says around half the students explained this fully, and the second part needed particles, for example, the same molecules are present. So the habit is to end every mass answer with the particle sentence, not just the word conserved. Here is a jar with its lid on, with a mass of three hundred and ten grams. A hundred and twenty grams of ice is sealed inside, and the jar sits on a balance. What does the balance read, in grams, before the ice melts and after? Three hundred and ten plus a hundred and twenty is four hundred and thirty, and it reads four hundred and thirty both times. Melting rearranges the water particles, and every one of them is still inside the sealed jar. Then the lid comes off, and the jar spends a week on a sunny windowsill. The balance now reads three hundred and ninety-five. A different question now. If mass is conserved, why has the reading dropped? Four hundred and thirty minus three hundred and ninety-five is thirty-five grams. Thirty-five grams of water evaporated, and those particles left the jar for the air in the room. They still exist, out in the room. The jar lost them, but nothing was destroyed. Mass was conserved both times. The second time, particles left the system, which moves them without destroying them.
A change of state is called a physical change, because the same particles are only rearranged and re-spaced. A physical change can be reversed, and the material gets its original properties back. Melted butter that cools sets again as butter. A chemical change is different, because it makes new substances. Cooling or warming usually cannot turn them back into what you started with. The candle's flame is a chemical change. The wax burns into new substances, and how burning works is a chemistry topic. That puts the rule the right way round: physical changes are the reversible ones. One examiner's report, on a Foundation paper, names its most common misconception: that physical changes were hard to reverse, and chemical changes easy. The Higher report from the same exam series says most students there had it the right way round. It is an easy idea to flip, rather than a hard one to learn. The fix is to tie it to the candle. The drip that sets again is physical, and the wax that burns is chemical. Here are four changes to sort into physical and chemical. Butter melts in a pan and sets again. Water vapour condenses on a cold mirror. Candle wax burns in the flame. An iron gate rusts. Pick physical or chemical for each one, and hold on to your reason before I show you. The butter is physical, because cooling it gives butter again. The mirror is physical too, because warming it evaporates the water back off. The burning wax is chemical, because new substances are made and cooling does not give wax back. Rust is chemical, because rust is a new substance and not iron. One more, using everything so far. Molten metal is poured into a mould, and it sets solid. Your job is to describe what happens to the particles, then explain why the solid has the same mass as the liquid. Write your description now, particles first and then the mass. In the liquid, the metal's particles touch but slide past each other in no pattern. As it sets, they lock into fixed positions in a regular pattern and only vibrate. That change is freezing, which for a metal is often called solidifying. The same particles are present before and after, with none added and none removed, so the mass is the same.
To finish, four questions on what the particles do. First, what do the particles do when a gas condenses? When a gas condenses, its particles come close together until they touch, with no pattern, forming a liquid. Now a new case. Sealed iodine goes straight from solid to gas: what is that called, and does its mass change? That change is sublimating, and the mass does not change, because the same particles stay in the sealed tube. Another new case. Is boiling an egg physical or chemical? Boiling an egg is chemical. New substances form, and cooling the egg does not uncook it. Now the rule itself. Why is mass conserved in a change of state? The same particles are present, with none added and none destroyed, so the mass is conserved.
And the candle. The drip that sets again is a physical change, so it can be undone, while the wax burned in the flame became new substances for good.
If you can describe the particles in any change of state and say why the mass stays put, give this a thumbs-up, because this one's done. If not, leave it un-thumbed and return, and say the rule out loud once and it sticks.
Next in the chapter is Internal energy and what heating does to a system. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly P H oh eight, oh four.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8463, Edexcel GCSE 1PH0, OCR GCSE J249
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8463 | 4.3.1.2 | Changes of state |
| Edexcel GCSE 1PH0 | 14.5 | Describe that when substances melt, freeze, evaporate, boil, condense or sublimate mass is conserved and that these physical changes differ from some chemical changes because the material recovers its original properties if the change is reversed |
| OCR GCSE J249 | P1.2a | Describe how mass is conserved when substances melt, freeze, evaporate, condense or sublimate |
| OCR GCSE J249 | P1.2b | Describe that physical changes differ from chemical changes because the material recovers its original properties if the change is reversed |
For teachers
This GCSE Physics lesson teaches changes of state and conservation of mass. By the end, students should be able to explain, using particles, why a change of state conserves mass and can be reversed to give back the original material. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.