ScholaFly

HI01-08 History Watch

The Munich Putsch of 1923: why it happened, why it failed and what followed

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

Germany 1890 to 1923 for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Germany 1890 to 1923 8 of 8. More at https://scholafly.com

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: germany 1890 to 1923: putsch
  2. 0:39 Germany 1890 to 1923: putsch: why November 1923
  3. 2:17 Germany 1890 to 1923: putsch: 8 November 1923
  4. 5:20 After the Putsch
  5. 8:27 The chapter question
  6. 12:06 One more reader

About this video

Germany 1890 to 1923: why it happened, why it failed and what followed | GCSE History | HI01-08

Germany 1890 to 1923 for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Germany 1890 to 1923 8 of 8.
More at https://scholafly.com

Video code: HI01-08 (search "ScholaFly HI01-08")

#GCSEHistory #Germany1890To1923 #Germany1890To1923Putsch

For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches the Munich Putsch of 1923: why it happened, why it failed and what followed. By the end, students should be able to students can explain the reasons for, events and consequences of the Munich Putsch of 1923. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8145
- 1A/B Part one: Weimar democracy
Edexcel 1HI0
- 31 2.2
Eduqas C100
- 1G Impact of the First World War

Read the transcript

How did a failed takeover, broken up by police gunfire within a day, end up making Hitler stronger? On the evening of the eighth of November, nineteen twenty-three, Adolf Hitler fired a pistol into the ceiling of a crowded Munich beer hall and announced a national revolution. Little more than a year later he was out of prison, known across Germany, and the author of a book setting out his ideas. It begins with why nineteen twenty-three looked like his moment.

By the autumn of nineteen twenty-three the Republic looked close to collapse. French troops were in the Ruhr, and hyperinflation had made money almost worthless. In September the new Chancellor, Gustav Stresemann, called off passive resistance in the Ruhr, because Germany could no longer pay for it. Nationalists saw that as surrender to France. In Bavaria, the right-wing leaders were themselves hostile to the government in Berlin. And there was an example to copy: in October nineteen twenty-two Benito Mussolini, leader of Italy's Fascists, had marched on Rome and been made Prime Minister. Hitler planned a putsch, an armed attempt to seize power, starting in Munich and then marching on Berlin. His SA had grown to thousands of men, and they were restless. Some courses want the reasons, events and results of the Putsch, and others want it as one of the attacks on the Republic, so this video gives both. Think about who held the guns in Bavaria. What did Hitler need from Bavaria's leaders for his plan to work? Their backing, because they controlled Bavaria's government, its army units and its police. Without them, his men would face the forces of the state alone.

On the evening of the eighth of November, those three leaders were addressing a meeting of about three thousand people in the Bürgerbräukeller, a large Munich beer hall. Gustav von Kahr ran Bavaria's government, General Otto von Lossow commanded the army there, and Colonel Hans von Seisser headed the state police. The SA surrounded the hall. Hitler burst in, fired into the ceiling, and took the three leaders into a side room, where he forced them at gunpoint to agree to support a march on Berlin. General Erich Ludendorff, Germany's wartime commander, arrived and backed Hitler. Then, while Hitler was away from the hall, Ludendorff let the three leaders go, on their word of honour. Three men who had agreed at gunpoint were now free. What do you think they did once they were out? They turned against it. Overnight Kahr, Lossow and Seisser ordered the army and police to put the rising down. On the ninth of November about two thousand Nazis marched into the centre of Munich anyway. At the Odeonsplatz, a square in the city centre, armed police blocked the way, and shots were fired. Sixteen Nazis and four policemen were killed. Hitler fled, and two days later he was arrested. Now a judgement on the failure. One option is the police at the Odeonsplatz. The other option is the loss of Kahr, Lossow and Seisser overnight. Which mattered more to the failure, and why? Losing the three leaders. They controlled the army and the police, so once they turned, the police at the Odeonsplatz were there to stop the march, not join it. The shooting was the result of that loss. A longer question might ask you to explain why the Putsch failed, with hints about the three leaders and the police. Three reasons answer it. First, Hitler let Kahr, Lossow and Seisser slip away, and they controlled Bavaria's government, army and police, which meant he had no official backing. Second, the army and police stayed loyal to the state, so the march was broken up at the Odeonsplatz in minutes. Third, the Putsch was badly planned, and no mass rising came to support it, which meant a small armed group faced the state alone.

Now the consequences, which turned a failure into a gain. First, the losses. Sixteen of Hitler's followers were dead, he was under arrest, and the Nazi Party was banned. Hitler went on trial for treason in February nineteen twenty-four. Treason means trying to overthrow your own country's government. He used the courtroom as a stage, making long speeches that attacked the Republic and the treaty, and newspapers reported them across Germany. Nationalist judges backed him. He got five years for treason but served about nine months in Landsberg. Ludendorff was acquitted. Weigh up what that trial gave Hitler. Why did the trial help Hitler more than it hurt him? Because it made him famous. Before the trial he was a Bavarian troublemaker. Afterwards his name and his ideas had been read about across Germany, and his light sentence showed that powerful people sympathised with him. In prison he dictated a book to Rudolf Hess, a loyal follower, and it was published in nineteen twenty-five as Mein Kampf, which means My Struggle. Its ideas were Hitler's racist and nationalist beliefs, not facts. He claimed an Aryan race was superior, and he poured out hatred of Jews. He wanted Lebensraum, living space for Germans in the east, the destruction of communism, one all-powerful leader, and the Treaty of Versailles overturned. Hitler also drew a lesson. The party would have to win power legally, through elections, not by force. How he rebuilt it for that is a later chapter's story. And the Republic survived, which showed it could defeat the right when the army and police stayed loyal. In nineteen twenty-three Hitler led a small party, banned after the Putsch. He would not become Chancellor until January nineteen thirty-three. Here are two verdicts on the Putsch. The first says it was a complete failure for Hitler. The second says it failed as a revolution, but it brought Hitler fame, time to write, and a new plan. Which verdict is better supported, and why? The verdict about fame and a new plan. It admits the failure, with the deaths, the arrests and the ban. But it weighs that against the gains, and the gains are what turned Hitler into a national figure.

This video closes the story of the Republic's crisis years, so one last question can use the whole chapter. It asks which had the bigger effect on the Republic between nineteen nineteen and nineteen twenty-three, armed attempts to seize power, or the economic crisis. One examiner's report on an essay about these years says some also wrote about Stresemann and loans from America, losing focus on the dates of the question. Stresemann calling off passive resistance in nineteen twenty-three fits, but the recovery that came afterwards does not. The fix is to mark the start and end dates before writing, and leave out the Kaiser before them and the recovery after them. Both sides need real detail, then a verdict that weighs them. Try planning both sides and your verdict on paper, then check it against the model. Armed attempts first. The Spartacist rising of January nineteen nineteen and the Kapp Putsch of March nineteen twenty showed the Republic could not defend itself. It relied on the Freikorps against the left, and when the army would not fire on Kapp's men it survived only through a general strike. The Munich Putsch of November nineteen twenty-three showed the right still wanted to destroy the Republic. These risings damaged it, because they proved it depended on groups that did not support it. Then the economic crisis. Reparations, the occupation of the Ruhr in January nineteen twenty-three and the hyperinflation that followed wiped out the savings of millions of middle-class Germans. That hit people who had been the Republic's natural supporters, and it fuelled the anger the Munich Putsch tried to exploit. The verdict: the economic crisis had the bigger effect. Every armed rising was defeated, but hyperinflation turned ordinary, law-abiding Germans against the Republic, and the crisis of nineteen twenty-three gave Hitler his moment to try at all. A report on an essay like this found that the best answers kept both points in play, and made a well-supported judgement often, though not only, based on how economic problems created political unrest. The verdict you just heard makes that link.

Last stretch: questions on the Putsch.

What made November nineteen twenty-three look like the right moment?

The crisis made the Republic look close to collapse, and nationalists were furious that passive resistance had been called off. Bavaria's leaders were hostile to Berlin, and Mussolini had shown a march on a capital could work.

Now another: what did Hitler gain from the Putsch, despite its failure?

National fame from his trial, a light sentence, time in prison to write Mein Kampf, and a new plan to win power through elections.

One more, about a reader this video did not meet. Imagine a shopkeeper in Hamburg, far from Munich, reading the courtroom speeches in her newspaper every morning in March nineteen twenty-four.

Which consequence of the Putsch is she part of?

The national publicity. The trial carried Hitler's name and ideas far beyond Bavaria, to people who had not heard of him before.

So back to that pistol shot in the beer hall. The Putsch failed as a revolution, with sixteen of his followers dead and Hitler in prison. But it gave him publicity, time to think and write, and a new plan to win power by votes. And with it, the story of the Republic's crisis years is complete.

If you can explain why the Putsch happened, why it failed and how it helped Hitler, press the thumbs-up, nailed it. If it hasn't landed, save it, and try the two-sided question on paper again before you rewatch.

The next chapter is Weimar recovery and the Nazi rise to power, nineteen twenty-four to nineteen thirty-three. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly H, I, oh two, oh oh.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8145, Edexcel GCSE 1HI0, Eduqas GCSE C100

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 81451A/B Part one: Weimar democracy
Edexcel GCSE 1HI031 2.2
Eduqas GCSE C1001G Impact of the First World War
For teachers

This GCSE History lesson teaches the Munich Putsch of 1923: why it happened, why it failed and what followed. By the end, students should be able to students can explain the reasons for, events and consequences of the Munich Putsch of 1923. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.