HI02-01 History Watch
How far the Weimar economy recovered under Stresemann, 1924-1929
In this lesson
Weimar and the nazi rise for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0, OCR J410 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Weimar and the Nazi rise 1 of 8. More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: weimar and the nazi rise
- 0:42 Weimar and the nazi rise: gustav Stresemann
- 6:08 Weimar and the nazi rise: the gains
- 8:06 Which mattered more for the recovery
- 11:39 Weimar and the nazi rise: recall
About this video
Weimar and the Nazi Rise: how far the Weimar economy recovered under Stresemann, 1924-1929 | HI02-01
Weimar and the nazi rise for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0, OCR J410 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Weimar and the Nazi rise 1 of 8.
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: HI02-01 (search "ScholaFly HI02-01")
#GCSEHistory #WeimarAndTheNaziRise
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches how far the Weimar economy recovered under Stresemann, 1924-1929. By the end, students should be able to students can explain how far the Weimar economy recovered in the Stresemann years. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8145
- 1A/B Part one: Weimar democracy
Edexcel 1HI0
- 31 1.3
OCR J410
- J410/02 The rise and consolidation of the Nazi regime
Eduqas C100
- 1G Recovery of Weimar
- 2B Weimar Germany
Read the transcript
In November nineteen twenty-three, Germans carried bags of banknotes to buy a single loaf of bread. By nineteen twenty-eight, German factories were making more than they had before the war. So was that a real recovery? The tempting answer is a plain yes, five years from ruin to boom. But much of the money paying for the boom had been lent by American banks, and a loan can be called back. Hold on to that borrowed money, because the verdict at the end turns on it.
Gustav Stresemann, leader of the German People's Party, became Chancellor, the head of the government, in August nineteen twenty-three. That autumn, money had become worthless and French troops held the Ruhr, Germany's industrial heartland. One sentence of that crisis is all a recovery answer needs. Stresemann was Chancellor for only about a hundred days, then foreign minister until his death in October nineteen twenty-nine. That is why these years carry his name, and a question that ends in nineteen twenty-three stops before his recovery begins. His government called off the strike against the French in the Ruhr, and in November nineteen twenty-three it brought in a new currency, the Rentenmark. The banker Hjalmar Schacht managed it. The Rentenmark was backed by a mortgage, a legal claim, on German land and industry, and the old worthless notes were withdrawn. Now a question about order, before any other measure arrives. Why did the new money have to come before any other fix? Because while money was worthless, nobody could plan. Shops could not fix a price, wages lost their value within days, and nobody would lend. Everything else had to stand on steady money. It worked. Prices steadied, and in nineteen twenty-four the Rentenmark was replaced by the Reichsmark, a currency backed by gold. The next weight on the economy was reparations, the payments Germany owed the Allies for the war. In nineteen twenty-four the Dawes Plan, worked out with the American banker Charles Dawes, lowered the yearly payments to a level Germany could pay, rising over five years. It came with an American loan of eight hundred million gold marks, and by nineteen twenty-five French and Belgian troops had left the Ruhr. Now picture yourself as a banker in New York, deciding where to put your money. Why would that plan make American banks willing to lend to Germany? Because Germany now looked like a safe borrower. Its currency was steady, its payments were ones it could keep, and its factories in the Ruhr were back in its own hands. And lend they did. Between nineteen twenty-four and nineteen thirty, about twenty-five billion marks was lent to Germany, much of it from America. That money paid for new factories and machinery, roads, housing and public buildings, which meant jobs and a building boom in German cities. Now follow that money round. American banks lent to Germany, and Germany used some of it to pay reparations to Britain and France. Britain and France used those payments to pay back what they had borrowed from America during the war. The same money went round in a circle. Now make a prediction, before going any further. What happens to that circle if the American banks stop lending? It breaks at the first link. Germany loses the money that built its factories and paid its reparations, and the payments to Britain, France and America stop too. That risk was sharper because much of the lending was short-term, which means the lender could ask for it back within months. A factory built on a short-term loan was standing on borrowed time. The last measure came in nineteen twenty-nine. The Young Plan, worked out with the American businessman Owen Young, cut the total reparations bill. It fell from a hundred and thirty-two billion gold marks, the figure set in nineteen twenty-one, to thirty-seven billion, with fifty-nine years to pay. Yet nationalists, including the press owner Alfred Hugenberg and Adolf Hitler, campaigned against it. Why would anyone campaign against a plan that cut the bill so far? Because it still meant paying for fifty-nine years. To nationalists, every payment accepted the Treaty of Versailles and the war guilt they rejected.
Now weigh how far the economy recovered, starting with the gains. Money was stable, and by nineteen twenty-eight industrial output was above its nineteen thirteen level, the last year before the war. Exports were rising and cities were building. Politics calmed down too, with Paul von Hindenburg elected President in nineteen twenty-five and coalition governments lasting longer. On some courses this study starts in nineteen twenty-five, with the Republic's strengths and weaknesses, and these gains are its strengths. Now the weaknesses. Unemployment stayed above a million in the late nineteen twenties. From nineteen twenty-seven farmers faced falling prices and debt. And the middle classes who lost their savings in nineteen twenty-three never got them back. Add one more weakness to those three, and you have four options. Option one, unemployment above a million. Option two, farmers in debt. Option three, savers who never got their money back. Option four, the short-term American loans. Which option could bring down the recovery all at once? Option four, the short-term loans. The other three hurt particular groups, but the loans held up the factories, the jobs and the reparations together, and they could be recalled within months. Some courses ask whether these years were a golden age. They were golden compared with nineteen twenty-three, but they were built on borrowed money.
One kind of exam question asks which mattered more for the recovery, the new currency or American loans, and wants both sides explained before a judgement. Start with the currency side. The Rentenmark ended hyperinflation, the price rises that had made money worthless, which meant businesses could plan, wages kept their value and savings could build up again. For the loans side, here are two sentences a student might write. The first: under the Dawes Plan, Germany received an American loan of eight hundred million gold marks. The second: American loans paid for new factories and machinery, which meant output grew until it passed its pre-war level by nineteen twenty-eight. Which sentence explains, the first or the second? The second sentence explains. The first is true, but it only describes, while the second says what the loans led to, and that which-meant link is what turns a fact into an explanation. Now the judgement. The new currency was more important, because no American bank would have lent a single dollar to a country whose money was worthless. The loans built the boom on top of it, but short-term loans could be withdrawn, which made that boom fragile. A different question asks how successful the government was in solving Germany's money troubles from nineteen twenty-three to nineteen twenty-nine. Writing about that question, one examiner's report records many students giving a large amount of context on hyperinflation, which left them less time and space for how the problems were dealt with. The fix is one sentence of nineteen twenty-three to set the scene, then straight on to the solutions and their limits. Now pause it there, and plan that answer from its opening line to its verdict. Here is one plan. It opens with one line: in nineteen twenty-three hyperinflation had made money worthless. Then the successes. The Rentenmark ended hyperinflation, and the Dawes Plan made reparations payable and brought in loans, so by nineteen twenty-eight output was higher than before the war. The Young Plan then cut the bill to thirty-seven billion gold marks. After that come the limits: short-term loans, unemployment above a million, farmers in debt, and savers who never got back what they lost. And the verdict: the government solved the immediate crisis, but it did not make the economy secure. Another report, from an earlier exam, notes the work of Stresemann was well known on one paper. If you have the measures, you are in good company. The step up is to end each one with which meant, tied to the words of the question.
Time to pull the lesson together, and this time you do the recalling.
What made people trust the Rentenmark?
The Rentenmark was backed by a mortgage on German land and industry, and the old notes were withdrawn.
Now the Dawes Plan: what two things did it give Germany?
The Dawes Plan gave Germany yearly reparations payments it could afford, and a large American loan to start the lending.
Now, why did short-term loans make the boom fragile?
Because lenders could call them back within months, and the factories, jobs and reparations all depended on them.
Now a different kind of question, one this video has not asked. It wants one strength of the Republic between nineteen twenty-five and nineteen twenty-eight, with a detail.
What would you name, and what detail would back it up?
The economy was more stable. After the Dawes Plan, American loans flowed in, so by nineteen twenty-eight industrial output was higher than in nineteen thirteen.
From bags of banknotes in November nineteen twenty-three to booming factories, then. The recovery was real, but it rested on loans that could be called back, as nineteen twenty-nine would show.
If you could weigh that recovery out loud now, give this video a thumbs-up, so you know you're solid on this. If it still feels hazy, give it a day and look again.
Next in the chapter is How Stresemann won Germany international acceptance. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly H, I, oh two, oh two.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8145, Edexcel GCSE 1HI0, OCR GCSE J410, Eduqas GCSE C100
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8145 | 1A/B Part one: Weimar democracy | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1HI0 | 31 1.3 | |
| OCR GCSE J410 | J410/02 The rise and consolidation of the Nazi regime | |
| Eduqas GCSE C100 | 1G Recovery of Weimar | |
| Eduqas GCSE C100 | 2B Weimar Germany |
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches how far the Weimar economy recovered under Stresemann, 1924-1929. By the end, students should be able to students can explain how far the Weimar economy recovered in the Stresemann years. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.