DT08-01 Design and Technology Watch
Ethics in design: who makes a product, where, and who benefits
In this lesson
Ethics in design for GCSE Design & Tech, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8552, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Ethics and fair trade 1 of 4. More at https://scholafly.com
By the end: Students can judge a product or a new technology from an ethical perspective - whether it is made, sold and used in a way that is fair to people - by asking who makes it and in what conditions, where it and its materials come from, and who benefits and who pays, and can explain an ethical issue with a specific example and its consequence.
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: ethics in design: who benefits
- 0:44 What ethics in design asks
- 2:49 Three questions for any product
- 6:02 An ethical point as a chain
- 9:15 Test yourself
Key words
About this video
Ethics in design: who makes a product, where, and who benefits | GCSE Design & Tech | DT08-01
Ethics in design for GCSE Design & Tech, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8552, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Ethics and fair trade 1 of 4.
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: DT08-01 (search "ScholaFly DT08-01")
#GCSEDesignTech #EthicsAndFairTrade #EthicsInDesignWhoBenefits
For teachers
This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches ethics in design: who makes a product, where, and who benefits. By the end, students should be able to students can judge a product or a new technology from an ethical perspective - whether it is made, sold and used in a way that is fair to people - by asking who makes it and in what conditions, where it and its materials come from, and who benefits and who pays, and can explain an ethical issue with a specific example and its consequence. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8552
- 3.1.1:How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions
Edexcel 1DT0
- 1.2.3
- 1.2.3a
- 1.2.3b
- 1.2.3c
Eduqas C600QS
- 2.1 core.1
OCR J310
- 2.2a
- 3.3a
Read the transcript
The phone in your pocket does dozens of jobs, and does them well. Is it a good design? Most people would say yes, because it works. But its battery holds a metal called cobalt. Most of the world's cobalt is mined in one country, the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Some of that cobalt is dug by hand, in tunnels with no safety equipment, sometimes by children. Working well is only part of what makes a design good. Keep that phone in mind; the people behind it decide what good design has to mean.
Ethics in design asks whether a product is made, sold and used in a way that is fair to the people involved. Designers have to ask it, because their choices decide where a product is made, what it is made from and what it costs. Each of those choices lands on real people. Ethics is one of the angles you judge any new product or new technology from. Before something new is made, someone should ask who it is fair to, and who it is not. That makes an ethical point a point about people. It names who is harmed or helped, and how. The environment is a separate angle, about what a product does to the planet: its energy, its waste and the resources it uses up. It has its own video, in the sustainability chapter. Here are three points about a cheap plastic toy car. One point: it is made from crude oil, which will run out. Another: it cannot be recycled, so it ends up in landfill. And the last: the workers who spray-paint it breathe in fumes all day, with no masks. Which of those three is an ethical point, and why? The painters breathing fumes. It names people and what the work does to them. The oil and the landfill are real problems, but they belong to the environment. One examiner's report puts it plainly: Many candidates however, focussed only on environmental rather than both environment and ethical factors. That question asked for both angles, and the people went missing. The fix is one check on every sentence you write: it has to name a person or a group of people.
To judge a product ethically, put three questions to it. The first is who makes it: the people who grow, mine and assemble it. It asks whether they are paid enough to live on, and whether they work safely, for reasonable hours. It also asks whether they are free, with no child labour and no forced labour, which is work people cannot refuse or leave. The second question is where it comes from: where the factory is, and where the raw materials are grown or mined. Take a wooden chair, put together in a clean, safe factory with fair pay. Can that chair still fail the where-from question, and why? Yes. The timber may have been felled by loggers working in dangerous conditions for very little pay, and the question reaches back to them. A phone battery works the same way. Its cobalt passes through the hands of miners long before any factory sees it. The third question is who benefits, and who pays. The company makes a profit and the buyer gets the product. The workers and the people living nearby may carry a cost that never shows on the price tag. When a product is very cheap, someone else is often carrying part of the cost. Now put all three to one product: a pair of trainers that sells for fifteen pounds. Who makes those trainers, and in what conditions? Factory workers stitch and glue the uppers, the fabric top of each shoe, often in countries where wages are low and safety laws are weaker. The glues contain solvents, liquids that give off fumes as they dry. Without good ventilation, those fumes harm the workers' health. Where they come from reaches back further. The rubber sole may start on a plantation, where workers tap trees for their sap. The synthetic upper starts as crude oil, made into a polymer. And the shoes are assembled far from the shop, so the buyer never sees the conditions. Now the third question: at fifteen pounds, who benefits, and who pays? The brand makes a profit and the buyer gets cheap trainers. The workers and the families around the factories carry the hidden cost. That leads to a judgement. At fifteen pounds, it is hard for everyone in the chain to be paid fairly. An ethical brand would audit its factories, inspecting pay, hours and safety, and could charge more so it can pay fairly.
An ethical point holds up best as a chain of four links: the issue, who it affects, what it does to them, and what should change. A bare opinion, such as calling something wrong, names nobody and shows nothing. The chain shows who is harmed and how, so the point stands up on its own. Here is a company planning to make its new smartwatch in whichever factory offers the lowest wages. It needs one ethical issue, explained as a chain. Can you build all four links for the smartwatch? Pause and work it out. The issue is choosing a factory only because its wages are lowest. It affects the workers who assemble the watch. What it does to them: they may not earn enough to live on, and may work very long hours in poor conditions. The company and its buyers get a cheaper watch while the workers carry the cost. That is exploitation, which means using people's weak position to pay them too little or work them too hard. What should change: the company checks the factory for fair pay, safe conditions and reasonable hours, even if the watch then costs more to make. Now two answers to one question: explain an ethical issue in making a cheap T-shirt. The first says clothes should be made ethically, because treating workers badly is wrong. The second says the workers sewing the T-shirts may work twelve-hour shifts for wages too low to live on, so the brand should check the factory's pay and hours. Which answer is stronger, and what is the weaker one missing? The answer about the workers sewing the T-shirts. It names the product, the people and the condition, then says what should change. The other names no one, and wrong on its own is only an opinion. One examiner's report records the same gap, on a question about making circuit boards ethically: Most responses to this question were too implicit and did not make explicit reference to the ethical use of circuit boards in electronic products. Candidates are expected to provide evidence of specific and relevant examples of products in the answers they provide. Too implicit means the link was left for the reader to guess. The fix is the second answer's habit: name the product, the people and the condition in every point. The same report also notes this: Most answers referred to good working conditions and fair pay. Both lines are true at once. Most students had the right idea, and most left it general. You already have the idea, so the work is making it specific.
Time to test what has stuck, and the last question goes back to the phone in your pocket. What does ethics in design ask about a product? It asks whether the product is made, sold and used in a way that is fair to the people involved. Now a kettle point: it wastes electricity. Ethical or environmental, and why? Environmental. It names no person, so it is about the planet rather than people. Try this: which of the three questions reaches back to the mine or plantation? Where it comes from. It follows the materials back past the factory, to whoever grows or digs them. One more, back to the phone: what would make it a good design, not only a useful one? A good design works well and is fair to the people behind it, down to the miners digging its cobalt. Put the three questions to the phone, and every answer has to name who is helped or harmed.
If ethics in design feels clear now, you could teach this one, so give it a thumbs up and it is marked as done when revision comes round. If not, save it, and write the three questions on paper once, because written down they tend to stay.
Next in the chapter: Fair trade. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly D T oh eight, oh two.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8552, Edexcel GCSE 1DT0, Eduqas GCSE C600QS, OCR GCSE J310
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8552 | 3.1.1:How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions | {'ref': None, 'text': 'planned obsolescence'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'design for maintenance'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'ethics'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'the environment.'} |
| Edexcel GCSE 1DT0 | 1.2.3 | {'ref': '1.2.3a', 'text': 'where it was made'}; {'ref': '1.2.3b', 'text': 'who was it made by'}; {'ref': '1.2.3c', 'text': 'who will it benefit'}; {'ref': '1.2.3d', 'text': 'fair trade products.'} |
| Edexcel GCSE 1DT0 | 1.2.3a | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1DT0 | 1.2.3b | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1DT0 | 1.2.3c | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1DT0 | 1.2.3d | |
| Eduqas GCSE C600QS | 2.1 core.1 | {'ref': None, 'text': 'The impact of new and emerging technologies on: industry enterprise sustainability people culture society the environment production techniques systems', 'role': 'content_statement', 'lines': [120, 132]}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'The focus of this content is the impact of new and emerging technologies on the areas identified below.', 'role': 'lead_in', 'lines': [133, 134]}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'market pull – responding to demands from the market;'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'technology push – development in materials and components, manufacturing methods;'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'consumer choice – consumers wishing to own the latest technologies/products.'} |
| OCR GCSE J310 | 2.2a | How new and emerging technologies influence design decisions, now and in possible futures |
| OCR GCSE J310 | 3.3a | {'ref': '3.3a.i', 'text': 'environmental initiatives'}; {'ref': '3.3a.ii', 'text': 'fair trade'}; {'ref': '3.3a.iii', 'text': 'social and ethical awareness'}; {'ref': '3.3a.iv', 'text': 'global sustainable development.'} |
For teachers
This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches ethics in design: who makes a product, where, and who benefits. By the end, students should be able to students can judge a product or a new technology from an ethical perspective - whether it is made, sold and used in a way that is fair to people - by asking who makes it and in what conditions, where it and its materials come from, and who benefits and who pays, and can explain an ethical issue with a specific example and its consequence. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.