ScholaFly

DT06-03 Design and Technology Watch

Renewable energy: wind, solar, tidal, hydroelectric and biomass

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

Renewable energy for GCSE Design & Tech, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8552, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Energy and power 3 of 4. More at https://scholafly.com

By the end: Explain how wind, solar, tidal, hydro-electric and biomass power make electricity, argue for and against choosing renewable energy, and work a ratio calculation from energy data.

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: renewable energy: pros and cons
  2. 0:34 Renewable energy: pros and cons: one link, many pushes
  3. 1:59 Solar and biomass
  4. 3:57 What turns the generator?
  5. 5:26 What is one reason to choose renewable
  6. 7:53 Sharing in a ratio

Key words

About this video

Renewable energy: wind, solar, tidal, hydroelectric and biomass | GCSE Design & Tech | DT06-03

Renewable energy for GCSE Design & Tech, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8552, Edexcel 1DT0, Eduqas C600QS and OCR J310 GCSE. Energy and power 3 of 4.
More at https://scholafly.com

Watch first: DT06-01 - https://youtu.be/jCEfM0puX-A, DT06-02 - https://youtu.be/P4tZyctlqhY
Video code: DT06-03 (search "ScholaFly DT06-03")

#GCSEDesignTech #EnergyAndPower

For teachers
This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches renewable energy: wind, solar, tidal, hydroelectric and biomass. By the end, students should be able to explain how wind, solar, tidal, hydro-electric and biomass power make electricity, argue for and against choosing renewable energy, and work a ratio calculation from energy data. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8552
- 3.1.2:Renewable energy
Edexcel 1DT0
- 1.3.1
- 1.3.1b
- 1.3.1c
- 1.3.1d
- 1.3.1e
- 1.3.1f
Eduqas C600QS
- 2.1 core.3
OCR J310
- 3.2a

Read the transcript

Wind and sunlight are free, and they will never run out. So why can't the country run on them all the time? Picture a still, dark winter evening at teatime. The turbines off the coast barely turn, and every solar panel is making nothing. The usual guess is cost, but no amount of money makes the wind blow. Each of the five sources gets walked first, and then the winter evening gets its answer.

Most power stations, and most renewable sources, share one link. Something pushes a turbine round, a shaft lined with blades, and the turbine turns a generator, which turns spinning into electricity. In a wind turbine, the wind pushes the blades round. They turn a shaft and, through a gearbox, a generator in the housing at the top. No fuel is burned and no steam is made. Hydro-electric power uses water stored behind a dam. The water flows down through pipes and spins turbines at the bottom, which turn the generators. In a tidal lagoon, what pushes the turbines round? The tide itself. As it rises and falls, the sea rushes through gaps in the lagoon wall and drives them. A lagoon or a barrage is a wall built across a bay or an estuary, with turbines set into it. A tidal stream scheme puts the turbines underwater instead, where the tide runs fast. Tides come in and out about twice a day, on a timetable known years ahead, so the output is predictable.

Solar panels are the odd one out, because nothing in them moves. They are made of photovoltaic cells, PV for short, which turn light straight into electricity, with no turbine and no generator. Biomass power burns wood pellets, crops or waste. The heat boils water, and the steam spins a turbine and generator, as in a coal power station. Bio-fuels are used a different way: biodiesel made from rapeseed is burned in engines, in place of ordinary diesel. If burning biomass gives off carbon dioxide, how can it be called carbon neutral? Because the plants took in about as much carbon dioxide while they grew as they give off when they burn. The next crop takes it in again, so the carbon goes round in a loop. So carbon neutral means the carbon released by burning is about the same as the carbon the plants took in. It does not mean no carbon dioxide at all, and it only holds if the crops and trees are replanted. One examiner's report, on a question about bio-fuels, says very few could explain carbon neutral successfully. The same report says quite a few candidates understood it was sustainable but justified the sustainable by saying it meant no pollution, being environmentally friendly or giving off less greenhouse gasses. The fix is to keep pollution out of both reasons. Biomass is renewable because the plants regrow, not because it is clean. It is carbon neutral because the regrowing plants take back what was burned.

Five real sites come next, and for each one, the thing to name is what turns the generator. An offshore wind farm. A dam across a valley in Wales. A tidal lagoon in a bay. A power station burning wood pellets. Solar panels on a school roof. What turns the generator at each site, from the wind farm to the school roof? At the wind farm, the wind pushes the blades round, and they turn the generator. At the dam, water falling from the reservoir through pipes spins the turbines, which turn the generators. In the lagoon, the tide flowing in and out through the wall turns the turbines. At the pellet station, burning boils water, and the steam spins a turbine, which turns the generator. On the school roof, nothing turns at all. The photovoltaic cells turn sunlight straight into electricity. One examiner's report, on answers describing how a renewable source makes electricity, says other candidates gave descriptions which were too vague or described the creation incorrectly. The fix is to name what turns the generator every time, and to say plainly that solar has nothing turning.

Now the arguments: what is one reason to choose renewable energy? It will not run out. It gives off little or no carbon dioxide while generating, biomass aside. The fuel is free, so running costs are low, and less fuel has to be imported. Against it, wind and solar depend on the weather and on daylight. Turbines, dams and solar farms cost a great deal to build, and they change the look of the countryside. Turbines can be noisy, too. Dams flood whole valleys, and tidal walls change estuaries where wading birds feed. Land used for biomass crops cannot also grow food. That is the still, dark winter evening again. The fuel is free, but wind and sunlight are not there on demand, so the country still needs something it can switch on. Storing spare energy for evenings like that is where the video on powering products picks up. A strong answer on renewable energy weighs both sides and ties each point to a real scheme. A tidal lagoon is a good one to practise on. A council plans a tidal lagoon across part of a river estuary. One student argues for it by writing that tidal power is renewable. Another writes that the tides come twice a day on a timetable known years ahead, so the council knows when the lagoon will generate. Which of the two is the stronger argument for this lagoon, and why? The second. It gives the fact, the reason, and what it means for this scheme, while the first could be said of any renewable source. Now can you build one argument against the lagoon, the same way? The wall costs a very large sum before any electricity is sold. It also changes how water flows over the mudflats, where wading birds feed, so the scheme could harm the estuary's wildlife.

Energy questions bring numbers too, and the method here is ratio, which means sharing a total in a given proportion. In one year, an island's renewable generators produced fifty-two point nine gigawatt hours of electricity. A gigawatt hour is a unit for very large amounts of electrical energy. The ratio of tidal power to all its other renewable sources was one to six. The question asks how much came from tidal power, to one decimal place. One student divides fifty-two point nine by six, and gets eight point eight gigawatt hours. What has that student done wrong in dividing by six? Six is only the share for the other sources. The ratio has one part for tidal plus six parts for the rest, so the total is seven parts, not six. So, step one, the total number of parts. One plus six makes seven parts. Step two, the size of one part. Fifty-two point nine gigawatt hours, divided by seven, is seven point five five seven gigawatt hours, and the digits keep going. Step three: tidal is one part, so tidal is seven point five five seven gigawatt hours. Round only now, at the end. To one decimal place, that is seven point six gigawatt hours. A ratio answer can be checked against the total it came from. Now check it: what do the other sources make, and do the two add back to the total? The other sources are six parts. Six times seven point five five seven is forty-five point three four, so forty-five point three. Seven point six plus forty-five point three is fifty-two point nine gigawatt hours, the total.

Time to check what has stuck, from the school roof back to that winter evening.

Which of the five sources has nothing turning, and how does it make electricity? Solar. Its photovoltaic cells turn light straight into electricity, with no turbine at all. Next one: a farm burns straw from its own wheat. Why can that be called carbon neutral? The wheat took in about as much carbon dioxide while growing as the straw gives off when burned, and next year's crop takes it in again. Try forty-two gigawatt hours shared one to five, solar to the rest: how much is solar? Six parts in total. Forty-two divided by six is seven, so solar is seven gigawatt hours. Now back to that still, dark winter evening: why can't wind and solar carry it? Wind needs wind and solar needs daylight, so neither can be switched on when demand peaks. The fuel is free, but it is not there on demand.

If you could explain all five sources and share out a ratio, you own this one, and a thumbs up keeps it off your re-watch list. If the ratio or carbon neutral still feels shaky, three questions in, it starts to feel normal, so try a few before you come back.

Next in the chapter: Powering products: batteries, mains, solar and choosing a power source. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly D T oh six, oh four.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8552, Edexcel GCSE 1DT0, Eduqas GCSE C600QS, OCR GCSE J310

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 85523.1.2:Renewable energy{'ref': None, 'text': 'How power is generated from: • wind • solar • tidal • hydro-electrical • biomass.'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'Arguments for and against the selection of renewable energy.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.3.1{'ref': '1.3.1a', 'text': 'fossil fuels – oil, gas, coal'}; {'ref': '1.3.1b', 'text': 'biofuels – biodiesel and biomass'}; {'ref': '1.3.1c', 'text': 'tidal'}; {'ref': '1.3.1d', 'text': 'wind'}; {'ref': '1.3.1e', 'text': 'solar'}; {'ref': '1.3.1f', 'text': 'hydroelectric.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.3.1a
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.3.1b
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.3.1c
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.3.1d
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.3.1e
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.3.1f
Eduqas GCSE C600QS2.1 core.3Renewable and non-renewable energy sources
OCR GCSE J3103.2aHow electricity is generated and how energy is stored and transferred
For teachers

This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches renewable energy: wind, solar, tidal, hydroelectric and biomass. By the end, students should be able to explain how wind, solar, tidal, hydro-electric and biomass power make electricity, argue for and against choosing renewable energy, and work a ratio calculation from energy data. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.