ScholaFly

DT05-06 Design and Technology Watch

Critically evaluating new technology: scenarios, perspectives and innovation

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

Evaluating new technology: how to evaluate a new or emerging technology in a product from more than one point of view, using AQA's four checks. AQA 8552, Edexcel 1DT0 and OCR J310 GCSE. New technologies 6 of 6. Full New technologies playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLLIcu-YWvU_A More at https://scholafly.com

By the end: Evaluate a new or emerging technology in a product from more than one point of view, using AQA's four checks - planned obsolescence, design for maintenance, ethics and the environment - and pick out which features are genuinely innovative, ending in a judgement tied to the product.

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: evaluating new technology
  2. 0:37 Evaluating new technology: critical evaluation
  3. 2:02 Innovative features
  4. 5:04 School tablets
  5. 6:50 The method at work

Key words

About this video

Evaluating New Technology: scenarios, perspectives and innovation | GCSE Design & Tech | DT05-06

Evaluating new technology: how to evaluate a new or emerging technology in a product from more than one point of view, using AQA's four checks.
AQA 8552, Edexcel 1DT0 and OCR J310 GCSE. New technologies 6 of 6.
Full New technologies playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLLIcu-YWvU_A
More at https://scholafly.com

Video code: DT05-06 (search "ScholaFly DT05-06")

#GCSEDesignTech #NewTechnologies #EvaluatingNewTechnology

For teachers
This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches critically evaluating new technology: scenarios, perspectives and innovation. By the end, students should be able to evaluate a new or emerging technology in a product from more than one point of view, using AQA's four checks - planned obsolescence, design for maintenance, ethics and the environment - and pick out which features are genuinely innovative, ending in a judgement tied to the product. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8552
- 3.1.1:How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions
Edexcel 1DT0
- 1.2.1
- 1.2.2
OCR J310
- 2.2a

Read the transcript

Why did some older iPhones suddenly get slower? The first guess was that the phones had worn out. In twenty seventeen, Apple confirmed that an update was holding back the speed of some older iPhones with aged batteries, to stop sudden shutdowns. A new battery brought the speed back. Apple apologised, and cut the price of a replacement battery. So, was holding the speed back a good design decision? Whose side you stand on decides it, and the method comes first.

To critically evaluate a new technology is to weigh its benefits and drawbacks from more than one point of view, then reach a judgement. The points of view are people: the user, the maker, and the wider community. It works the same on a technology already in products, like an app-connected heater, and on one that could arrive, like drones delivering parcels. Four checks give the weighing its shape. The first is planned obsolescence: whether it makes the product go out of date sooner. The second is design for maintenance: whether it can be repaired, updated, or have parts swapped. The third is ethics: who gains, who loses, and whose data it is. The last is the environment: the materials and energy, and what happens at the end. A smart speaker stops getting updates after three years. Which check does that raise? Planned obsolescence. The speaker is left behind by its maker while the hardware still works. It touches design for maintenance too, because it can no longer be updated. Each check has a full video of its own; here each one is a question to ask.

Some questions ask about innovation in a product. An innovative feature is a new, technology-led feature that changes what the product can do for its user. It is not the same as an ordinary improvement, like more seating or a bigger bin. And it is not an ergonomic feature, one that makes a product comfortable to use, like a softer grip. A council wants to update the drinking-water refill stations in its parks. One idea is a touch-free sensor that starts the water when a bottle is placed. Another is a second bench beside the station. Another is a spout at a comfortable height for children. The last is a small display counting the plastic bottles the station has saved. Which of the four ideas are innovative, and what kind of feature is each of the others? The sensor and the display are innovative: new technology that changes what the station does. The bench is an ordinary improvement, and the spout height is ergonomic. One examiner's report, on a question about improving bus stops, records this. Where responses just focused on listing existing features and improving the bus stops, for example, adding more seating or adding a door, marks were not awarded. A report on a different innovation question notes that strong responses invariably focused on the interactive screen features and how they improved the overall experience of exercise for the user. Less successful responses tended to repeat ergonomic features. Sort first, then put every idea in its bin, write only about the innovative ones, and say what each does for the user. That habit answers both reports. Now take the touch-free sensor: what does it do for users, and which check does it raise? The sensor is more hygienic for users, with no shared button to press. But it needs power, and a fault stops the station, so keep a manual push-button as a backup. That is design for maintenance. The bottle counter encourages people to refill, and it is cheap to add. A UV lamp, ultraviolet light that sterilises the spout between users, is reassuring, but the lamp wears out, so the panel must open easily for a technician. And an app map of working stations only lasts while the council keeps the app updated. The judgement: the touch-free sensor with a manual backup is the one to choose. It is a real gain in hygiene, with a backup if it fails.

A bigger decision gets the same treatment, from two points of view. A school plans to give every Year 10 student a tablet computer instead of printed textbooks. One answer reads: tablets are light, the content can be updated without reprinting, and videos and quizzes sit inside the lesson, so it is a great idea. What is that answer about the tablets missing? The answer is missing the other side, and a real judgement. It gives benefits only, from one point of view, and none of the four checks. Now run the four checks: how do they come out for the students and the school? Planned obsolescence, for students: a tablet may stop getting updates after a few years, while a textbook stays usable for many more. Design for maintenance, for the school: with a glued-in battery, a worn battery means a new tablet. A replaceable battery lasts longer. Ethics: students without internet at home are left behind, and the metals in the battery may be mined in poor conditions. Environment: every tablet ends as electronic waste, though reprinting thousands of books costs energy and trees too. The judgement: worth doing only if the school chooses tablets with long update support and replaceable batteries, and lends devices with internet access to students who need them.

To finish, the method goes to work on things this video has not shown, then back to the phones.

A park bench gets a wider seat, or a solar panel that charges phones. Which is innovative? The solar charging panel. It lets the bench do something it never could. A wider seat is an ordinary improvement. Now a future one: drones deliver medicine to hill villages. One drawback for a villager? Noise overhead, and cameras on drones raise privacy worries. That falls under the ethics check. Here's the maker's side: one drawback of those drones for the pharmacy? Drones cannot fly in high wind or heavy rain, so a back-up van is still needed. For the patient, though, medicine arrives the same day without a long trip. The same technology looks different from each side. Now the iPhones from the start: was holding back their speed a good design decision? From the user's side, stopping sudden shutdowns helped. But users were not told clearly, which fails the ethics check. And a battery that could be swapped would have shrunk the problem. Holding the speed back had a case; keeping it quiet did not.

Four checks, two sides and one judgement on any new technology means you own this one, and the thumb is your tick. If it hasn't clicked, save the chapter's playlist, as it often lands on a second viewing.

That completes the chapter on new and emerging technologies. Next chapter: Energy: generation, storage and powering products. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly D T oh six, oh oh.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8552, Edexcel GCSE 1DT0, OCR GCSE J310, Cambridge GCSE 0445

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 85523.1.1:How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions{'ref': None, 'text': 'planned obsolescence'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'design for maintenance'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'ethics'}; {'ref': None, 'text': 'the environment.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.1{'ref': '1.2.1a', 'text': 'budget constraints'}; {'ref': '1.2.1b', 'text': 'timescale'}; {'ref': '1.2.1c', 'text': 'who the product is for'}; {'ref': '1.2.1d', 'text': 'the materials used'}; {'ref': '1.2.1e', 'text': 'manufacturing capabilities.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.1a
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.1b
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.1c
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.1d
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.1e
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.2{'ref': '1.2.2a', 'text': 'natural disasters'}; {'ref': '1.2.2b', 'text': 'medical advances'}; {'ref': '1.2.2c', 'text': 'travel'}; {'ref': '1.2.2d', 'text': 'global warming'}; {'ref': '1.2.2e', 'text': 'communication.'}
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.2a
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.2b
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.2c
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.2d
Edexcel GCSE 1DT01.2.2e
OCR GCSE J3102.2aHow new and emerging technologies influence design decisions, now and in possible futures
Cambridge GCSE 0445missingthe plan names no spec point for this board
For teachers

This GCSE Design & Tech lesson teaches critically evaluating new technology: scenarios, perspectives and innovation. By the end, students should be able to evaluate a new or emerging technology in a product from more than one point of view, using AQA's four checks - planned obsolescence, design for maintenance, ethics and the environment - and pick out which features are genuinely innovative, ending in a judgement tied to the product. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.