BI06-05 Biology Watch
Respiration: aerobic and anaerobic
In this lesson
Respiration for GCSE Biology, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8461, Edexcel 1BI0 and OCR J247 GCSE. Plant energy 5 of 7. More at https://scholafly.com
By the end: Compare aerobic and anaerobic respiration in animals, plants and fungi for what they need, what they make and how much energy they transfer.
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: respiration: aerobic/anaerobic
- 0:36 What respiration
- 3:33 A leaf in sunshine
- 6:19 Three kinds side by side
- 9:31 What is wrong with each sentence?
- 11:22 Quick quiz
Key words
About this video
Respiration: aerobic and anaerobic | GCSE Biology | BI06-05
Respiration for GCSE Biology, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8461, Edexcel 1BI0 and OCR J247 GCSE. Plant energy 5 of 7.
More at https://scholafly.com
Watch first: BI06-01 - https://youtu.be/bu2fiExkqCI
Video code: BI06-05 (search "ScholaFly BI06-05")
#GCSEBiology #PlantEnergy
For teachers
This GCSE Biology lesson teaches respiration: aerobic and anaerobic. By the end, students should be able to compare aerobic and anaerobic respiration in animals, plants and fungi for what they need, what they make and how much energy they transfer. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8461
- 4.4.2.1
Edexcel 1BI0
- 8.10
- 8.9
OCR J247
- B1.3a
- B1.3b
- B1.3c
Read the transcript
What do rising bread dough and a cyclist's burning legs have in common? Leave dough in a warm bowl and it doubles in size, with a faint smell of alcohol. Push hard up a steep hill and your thighs start to burn. In both, living cells are breaking down glucose without enough oxygen. Yet one ends in alcohol, and the other in an acid. To see why the endings differ, start with the version that has oxygen to spare.
Respiration is a reaction in every living cell that breaks down glucose to release energy. It runs all the time, in plants, animals and fungi alike, not only when you exercise. This is on every course, at both Foundation and Higher. Respiration is exothermic: energy is transferred from the reaction to the surroundings. That's the opposite of photosynthesis, which takes energy in. Cells use that energy to build larger molecules, to move, and, in birds and mammals, to keep warm. Respiration is not breathing. Breathing, also called ventilation, moves air in and out of your lungs. Respiration is a reaction inside each cell. A diver holds her breath for a minute. Are her muscle cells still respiring? Yes. Her breathing has stopped, but every one of her cells is still respiring, breaking down glucose to release energy. When there's plenty of oxygen, respiration is aerobic, which means with oxygen. Glucose plus oxygen gives carbon dioxide plus water. It happens in the mitochondria, tiny structures inside the cell. Now put that equation underneath the one for photosynthesis. What do you notice about the two equations, one above the other? One is the other, run backwards. Photosynthesis builds glucose from carbon dioxide and water, and aerobic respiration breaks it back down into them. One examiner's report on a Higher paper spells out a full answer. For this question candidates were asked how the athlete gained energy from aerobic respiration. The accepted answer included the idea that glucose and oxygen reacted to form carbon dioxide and water. It goes on: Both reactants and products were required. The idea that this happens in the mitochondria and is an exothermic reaction was also credited. Marks were lost for just stating that oxygen was needed rather than glucose and oxygen or confusing reactants and products. The fix is to give all four: glucose and oxygen in, carbon dioxide and water out. Then say where, in the mitochondria, and that it is exothermic.
Plants raise a question of their own, because they photosynthesise as well. Does a leaf cell respire while it's photosynthesising in bright sunshine? Yes. Every living cell respires all the time, day and night, including a leaf cell that is photosynthesising at the same moment. It's easy to miss, because in daylight a leaf gives out more oxygen than it uses, so the respiration is hidden inside the photosynthesis. One examiner's report on a Higher paper explains why very few students scored full marks on one part: it was due to a lack of understanding that both the plant and the animal were respiring. The habit that fixes it: whenever a living plant is in a question, treat it as respiring, day and night. Now take the oxygen away. When cells can't get enough oxygen, they can respire anaerobically, which means without oxygen. The two letters a and n at the front are the whole difference: they mean without. In muscle cells, anaerobic respiration turns glucose into lactic acid. Glucose gives lactic acid, and that is the whole equation: no oxygen in, and no carbon dioxide out. Without oxygen, the glucose is only partly broken down. That is called the incomplete oxidation of glucose, and it's why far less energy is released than in aerobic respiration. Yeast, a single-celled fungus, respires without oxygen too, but differently. Dough rises. Which gas must yeast be giving off when it respires without oxygen? Carbon dioxide, the gas that makes dough rise. In yeast, glucose gives ethanol plus carbon dioxide, and ethanol is the alcohol. This reaction in yeast is called fermentation. It's used to make bread, where the carbon dioxide raises the dough, and alcoholic drinks, where the ethanol is the point. Plant cells short of oxygen, such as roots in waterlogged soil, respire anaerobically the same way as yeast, making ethanol and carbon dioxide.
Now line all three up side by side: aerobic respiration, anaerobic respiration in muscle, and anaerobic respiration in yeast. Compare them on four things. Is oxygen needed? What is broken down? What are the products? And how much energy is released? Only aerobic respiration needs oxygen. All three break down glucose. The products are carbon dioxide and water, then lactic acid, then ethanol and carbon dioxide. The last row, energy, needs a reason as well as an answer. Which releases more energy from each glucose, aerobic or anaerobic, and why? Aerobic, by a long way. Anaerobic breaks each glucose down only part of the way, so much of its energy is still held in what it makes. One examiner's report on a Foundation paper records that: Relatively few candidates had a good grasp of the differences between aerobic respiration and anaerobic respiration. It adds: Very few candidates were able to compare the release of energy by these types of respiration, but some were familiar with the different products of each process. Give the energy its own sentence, then, with its reason: aerobic releases much more energy per glucose, because anaerobic only partly breaks it down. On some courses, the energy from respiration is carried in the cell by a molecule called ATP, and aerobic respiration gives a much higher yield of ATP per glucose than anaerobic. If ATP isn't on your course, energy released is all you need. Three cells are respiring. A yeast cell in sealed dough. A muscle cell in a sprinter's leg, fifteen seconds into a race. And a root cell in well-drained soil. Each one needs a decision and an equation to go with it. Classify all three cells, then say which releases the most energy per glucose. The yeast cell in sealed dough is respiring anaerobically: glucose gives ethanol plus carbon dioxide. The sprinter's muscle cell is respiring anaerobically as well: glucose gives lactic acid. The root cell in well-drained soil has oxygen, so it is aerobic: glucose plus oxygen gives carbon dioxide plus water. So the root cell releases the most energy per glucose, because it is the only one breaking its glucose down completely.
Last, three sentences of the kind students write, each with something wrong. First: aerobic respiration makes lactic acid. Second: anaerobic respiration is when you breathe faster because there is no oxygen. Third: respiration produces energy. Each one sounds fine at first, and each one would lose you something. What is wrong with each of those three sentences? The first has the two kinds swapped. Lactic acid comes from anaerobic respiration in muscle, and aerobic respiration makes carbon dioxide and water. The second describes breathing, not respiration. Anaerobic respiration is a reaction inside cells, using no oxygen. And the third: energy is never produced. Respiration releases energy from glucose, and that energy is transferred to the cell. One examiner's report on a Foundation paper puts the first slip plainly: Many students got aerobic and anaerobic respiration mixed up, and aerobic respiration produced lactic acid and aerobic respiration is the absence of oxygen. The fix is in the word itself. An means without, so anaerobic is the one without oxygen, and that is the one that makes lactic acid in muscle. Measuring how fast something respires has its own video: the required practical on measuring the rate of respiration.
Quick quiz on everything here, and the dough comes back at the end. A germinating seed in a warm, airy jar: which respiration, and what shows it's exothermic? Aerobic, because there's oxygen to spare. The jar warms up, because the reaction gives energy out to its surroundings. Now grapes, crushed and sealed with yeast away from the air. Which two products build up? Ethanol and carbon dioxide. With no oxygen, the yeast ferments the sugar in the grapes. Another: why does anaerobic respiration release less energy per glucose? The glucose is only partly broken down: an incomplete oxidation, so much of its energy is left in the products. So the dough and the cyclist's legs share the same shortage of oxygen. Yeast stops at ethanol and carbon dioxide, and muscle stops at lactic acid.
Every video up to this one is listed now, this one last. When this one's done for you, leave it a like, so your list shows what's sorted. If it felt like a lot, that's normal; keep the playlist handy and return to the table.
Next in the chapter: the body's response to exercise. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly B I oh six, oh six.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8461, Edexcel GCSE 1BI0, OCR GCSE J247
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8461 | 4.4.2.1 | Aerobic and anaerobic respiration |
| Edexcel GCSE 1BI0 | 8.10 | Compare the process of aerobic respiration with the process of anaerobic respiration |
| Edexcel GCSE 1BI0 | 8.9 | Describe cellular respiration as an exothermic reaction which occurs continuously in living cells to release energy for metabolic processes, including aerobic and anaerobic respiration |
| OCR GCSE J247 | B1.3a | Describe cellular respiration as a universal chemical process, continuously occurring that supplies ATP in all living cells |
| OCR GCSE J247 | B1.3b | Describe cellular respiration as an exothermic reaction |
| OCR GCSE J247 | B1.3c | Compare the processes of aerobic respiration and anaerobic respiration |
For teachers
This GCSE Biology lesson teaches respiration: aerobic and anaerobic. By the end, students should be able to compare aerobic and anaerobic respiration in animals, plants and fungi for what they need, what they make and how much energy they transfer. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.