ScholaFly

RS01-08 Religious Studies Watch

Christian responses to the problem of evil and suffering

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

Christian beliefs on God for GCSE Religious Studies, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8062, Edexcel 1RA0, OCR J625, Edexcel 1RB0 and Eduqas C120 GCSE. Christian beliefs on God 8 of 8. More at https://scholafly.com

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: christian beliefs on god: evil
  2. 0:43 Two kinds of evil
  3. 2:48 The problem of evil
  4. 6:41 Response one: free will
  5. 12:29 Christian beliefs on god: evil: job and the psalms
  6. 16:02 Catholic meaning of suffering
  7. 18:29 Does suffering disprove love?
  8. 21:55 Back to the bedside

About this video

Christian Beliefs on God: Christian responses to the problem of evil and suffering | RS01-08

Christian beliefs on God for GCSE Religious Studies, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8062, Edexcel 1RA0, OCR J625, Edexcel 1RB0 and Eduqas C120 GCSE. Christian beliefs on God 8 of 8.
More at https://scholafly.com

Video code: RS01-08 (search "ScholaFly RS01-08")

#GCSEReligiousStudies #ChristianBeliefsOnGod #ChristianBeliefsOnGodEvil

For teachers
This GCSE Religious Studies lesson teaches christian responses to the problem of evil and suffering. By the end, students should be able to explain how Christians respond to the problem that evil and suffering raise for belief in an all-powerful, all-loving God. It works through six worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8062
- 3.1.2.1 Key beliefs
Edexcel 1RA0
- 1B 1.7
- 1B 1.8
- 2B 1.7
- 2B 1.8
- 3A 1.8
OCR J625
- J625/01 Beliefs and teachings > The problem of evil and suffering and a loving and righteous God
- J625/06 The existence of God > The Question of God
Edexcel 1RB0
- 1B 1.7
- 1B 1.8
- 2B 1.7
- 2B 1.8
- 3A 2.8
- 3B 1.7
- 3B 1.8
Eduqas C120
- 2.2 Beliefs and teachings / The nature of God
- 2.4 Theme 2: Good and Evil / Beliefs: Incarnation
- 2.4 Theme 2: Good and Evil / Good, Evil and Suffering
- 2.4 Theme 2: Good and Evil / Sources: Jesus and moral authority

Read the transcript

If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why does anyone suffer? Psalm one hundred and three praises God, "who forgives all your sins and heals all your diseases." Christians pray those words beside hospital beds, and the person in the bed may still be ill the next morning. One response is to decide the psalm must be empty words. The Christians who pray it do not think so, and they give reasons. Before the reasons comes the problem itself, stated with care.

Christians see good as whatever fits God's nature and will, and evil as whatever goes against it and causes suffering. Natural evil, also called natural suffering, is suffering caused by the natural world, with no human choice behind it. Earthquakes, floods and diseases are natural evil. Moral evil, also called moral suffering, is suffering caused by human choices. Murder, war and theft are moral evil. The causes differ, then. Moral evil comes from human free will, and natural evil from the way the natural world works. Many Christians also link both to the Fall, which the video on Christian beliefs about the Fall and original sin explains. Now a harder case. An earthquake strikes a city, and many people die because builders cut corners to save money. Is that earthquake disaster natural evil, moral evil, or both? Both. The earthquake is natural evil, but the deaths from cheap building are moral evil, because they came from human choices. If you can describe natural suffering, you are on firm ground. One examiner's report found most students knew how to describe it. The same report sets a warning beside that praise. Some students described examples, and some explained moral suffering when natural suffering was asked for, and they gained much lower marks. The fix is to find which kind the question names, define it and explain it, with an example only as support.

Now the problem. Psalm one hundred and three, verse thirteen, describes the God Christians believe in: "As a father has compassion on his children, so the LORD has compassion on those who fear him." Verse nineteen adds "his kingdom rules over all." Put that beside suffering and the problem appears. If God is omnipotent, God could stop suffering. If God is benevolent, God would want to. Yet suffering exists. The three statements do not seem to fit together, so this argument is sometimes called the inconsistent triad. That label names the argument, and it is not an answer to it. Two answers are given to a question asking how suffering challenges what Christians believe about God. The first lists earthquakes, wars and diseases. The second says an all-powerful God could stop an earthquake, so its happening makes some Christians doubt God's power. Which answer explains the problem, the first or the second? The second answer. The first describes suffering in the world, but only the second links it to what Christians believe about God. One examiner's report says students who did not do so well could explain the problem, but did not link it to how this was a challenge to the omnipotence and benevolence of God. The habit is to end every point on omnipotence or benevolence, saying which belief the suffering presses on, and how. The challenge is old. It is credited to the Greek philosopher Epicurus, who lived about three hundred years before Jesus, though his words survive only through later writers. The best-known English version comes from the philosopher David Hume. In outline, the questions run like this. If God wants to prevent evil but cannot, God is not all-powerful. If God can but does not want to, God is not all-loving. And if God both can and wants to, evil should not exist at all. For believers this is more than an argument. Some lose their faith over suffering, and many more struggle with it and keep believing. Now a fuller task, which asks for two ways the existence of suffering challenges Christian beliefs about God. How would you explain two ways suffering challenges Christian beliefs about God? First, it challenges God's omnipotence. Christians believe God is all-powerful, so God could have stopped the Indian Ocean tsunami of two thousand and four, which killed more than two hundred thousand people. Because it happened, some people conclude that God either cannot stop such things or does not exist, and some believers begin to question their faith. Second, it challenges God's benevolence. Psalm one hundred and three describes God as compassionate, like a father with his children, yet a loving parent who could prevent their children's suffering would do so. That is why suffering makes some Christians ask whether God loves them at all.

That is the problem, and a question asking for Christian responses is a different question. One examiner's report on such a question says most students knew what was meant by a response, although some described the problem instead and gained no marks. When a question asks for responses, give responses, and let the problem be the lead-in only. The first response is free will, taught by Saint Augustine, a bishop in North Africa who died in the year four hundred and thirty. He taught that God made humans free so that they could love God and choose good. A world of puppets could not love anyone. Freedom brings the risk of misuse, and when people misuse it, moral evil follows, so on this view much suffering comes from human choices rather than from God. Augustine also traced natural evil back to the Fall, when human sin spoiled a good creation. Now weigh that first response for yourself. Which kind of evil do many Christians say free will explains best, and which is harder? Many Christians say it explains moral evil best, because that comes from human choices. Some find natural evil harder: a flood or a disease is nobody's choice, unless, like Augustine, you trace it back to the Fall. The second response is the vale of soul-making. Saint Irenaeus, a bishop in the second century, taught that humans are made in God's image but must grow into God's likeness. In the twentieth century the philosopher John Hick developed this, calling the world "a vale of soul-making", a phrase he took from the poet John Keats. A vale is a valley. On this view, a world with real hardship lets people develop courage, patience and compassion that an easy world could never produce. Soul-making means a person's character being shaped, and Catholics also teach that suffering can help develop the virtues. A nurse says years of caring for dying patients taught her a patience she never had before. Which Christian response does her story fit? The vale of soul-making. Hardship has shaped her character, which is the growth Irenaeus and Hick describe. Soul-making does not mean God making a soul. One examiner's report says a significant number of students did not know the term, and wrote about the making of a soul, some with reference to God breathing life into Adam. The fix is to define it as growth through hardship, such as courage learned in danger or compassion learned in pain. Christians disagree about how well these responses work. Some find free will weaker on the sheer scale of suffering. Of soul-making, some ask why suffering breaks some people rather than building them, and others reply that God's purposes reach beyond this life. Now an evaluation to weigh: human free will is a complete answer to why people suffer. For it: many Christians, following Augustine, argue that love needs freedom, so God could not make beings able to love without the risk of evil. Much suffering, from war to cruelty, comes from human choices, and Augustine traced natural suffering to the Fall in Genesis three. Against it: other Christians find that free will explains moral evil far better than natural evil, and some do not read the Fall as the cause of disasters and illness. Some also ask why an all-powerful God does not step in to stop the worst choices. Now two openings for a paragraph in that answer. The first says: evil and suffering are found everywhere in the world. The second says: free will explains the suffering caused by war, but not the suffering caused by floods. Which opening keeps weighing free will, the first or the second? The second opening does. The first talks about evil in general, and never says what free will can or cannot explain. Many Christians therefore hold free will alongside other responses. A strong answer might conclude that free will is a strong Christian answer to moral evil but not a complete one, because it says little about natural suffering. Both sides there are Christian voices. When a question asks for Christian views, an atheist or humanist argument does not count, so the other side comes from Christians who see it differently.

Christians also respond from the Bible. In the book of Job, a righteous man loses his children, his wealth and his health. In Job chapter one, verse eight, God says of him, "There is no one on earth like him; he is blameless and upright." In the verses that follow, God allows Satan to test Job, to see whether his faith will hold. Job complains bitterly and demands an answer. At the end he gets no explanation, but he meets God, and in chapter forty-two, verse three, he says "Surely I spoke of things I did not understand, things too wonderful for me to know." Why might Job's story help a suffering Christian more than an argument would? Because Job is never given a reason, yet his faith survives. Many Christians take him as a model of trusting without being told why, since the divine view is far beyond theirs. Psalm one hundred and nineteen offers comfort too. Verse fifty says "My comfort in my suffering is this: your promise preserves my life." Verse seventy-one goes further: "It was good for me to be afflicted so that I might learn your decrees." Christians also respond in practice. Prayer is one way: Christians pray for strength and comfort, and they pray for those who suffer. Charity is another. In Jesus' parable of the sheep and the goats, in Matthew twenty-five, serving the hungry, the sick and the prisoner is serving Jesus himself. Christian charities, and the Church's guidance known as Catholic Social Teaching, put that into action. Now picture a church after a local flood. It sends volunteers with food and blankets, and it holds a vigil to pray for the families. Which two practical responses are the volunteers and the vigil? Charity, in the volunteers and their supplies, following the sheep and the goats. And prayer, in the vigil, asking for strength and comfort. Christians weigh these responses against each other. Many say charity changes lives now, though it does not explain why suffering happens. Others value prayer for the strength it brings, or Job's example of trust without an answer. One examiner's report notes only a very small percentage of students were able to evaluate practical ways such as charity by contrasting them with other responses, such as prayer or the suffering of Job. The habit that answers it is to set one response against another, saying what each can do and what it cannot.

Catholic teaching holds two things about suffering at once. Suffering is an evil to be relieved, which is why Catholics run hospitals and hospices. Yet Catholics also teach that suffering can gain meaning. Christians read Isaiah fifty-three as a picture of Jesus. Verse three describes a servant "despised and rejected by mankind, a man of suffering, and familiar with pain", and verse five says "by his wounds we are healed." If Christians read that servant as Jesus, what does it say about God and pain? That God is not distant from suffering. Christians believe that in Jesus, God became human and shared suffering from the inside, even to death on a cross. Pope John Paul the Second wrote about this in a letter called Salvifici Doloris, in nineteen eighty-four. In section thirteen he teaches that love, shown on the cross, is the answer to the meaning of suffering. In section twenty-three he teaches that people who suffer can share in Christ's sufferings. For Catholics, then, suffering joined to Christ's can draw a person closer to God, while it remains something to relieve. A practical task comes after that, set close to home. It asks for three ways a Catholic might respond when someone they love is suffering, each with a source. Which three ways might a Catholic respond to a loved one's suffering? First, they pray, for the person's healing and for strength, as Psalm one hundred and nineteen finds comfort in God's promise. Second, they act with charity, caring for the person and for others in need, following the sheep and the goats. Third, they join the suffering to Christ's, as Pope John Paul the Second taught, so that it can gain meaning and draw them closer to God.

A final statement brings the responses together, weighed from different Christian points of view. It says suffering proves that God cannot love the world. For it: some Christians find that great suffering shakes or ends their faith. If the God of Psalm one hundred and three heals all diseases, they ask why the faithful still suffer, and Job himself complains that God has treated him unfairly. Against it: most Christians say suffering does not prove that. Job comes to trust God without an answer, and Romans eight says nothing can separate believers from God's love. Many add that free will makes love possible, and point to the cross as God sharing human pain. Now weigh the strongest word in that statement, which is proves. Why might a Christian accept that suffering tests faith, yet deny it proves anything? Because a test is not a proof. Many Christians see love in God's presence with those in pain, and in Jesus sharing that pain, even when no reason is given. A strong answer might conclude that suffering is a real test of faith for Christians but does not prove God cannot love, while recognising that some believers do lose faith over it.

To close, the problem and the responses, tested in turn.

First, what is the difference between natural evil and moral evil? Natural evil comes from the natural world with no human choice, like an earthquake. Moral evil comes from human choices, like theft or war.

Now, how does suffering challenge belief in God's benevolence? A loving God would want to stop suffering, as a loving parent would, so its existence makes some Christians ask whether God loves them.

Here is a verse this video has not used, from Romans eight, verse twenty-eight. It says "in all things God works for the good of those who love him". Which response to suffering does that verse fit best? Soul-making, along with trust in purposes beyond human sight: hardship can still lead somewhere worthwhile.

Now the last one. What does the vale of soul-making mean? A world where hardship lets people's characters grow, building courage, patience and compassion. It does not mean God making a soul.

Back to the hospital bed, and the psalm prayed beside it. The Christians who pray it have arguments to give: free will, soul-making and the trust of Job. For many of them the answer is also lived beside the bed, in prayer and in care, and for Catholics in sharing the suffering of Christ.

If you can now state the problem, give two responses with their thinkers, and weigh them with Christian views on both sides, you nailed it, so hit the thumbs up. There is a lot in here, and nobody gets all of it first time, so if it has not all landed, keep it saved and unmarked.

That completes the chapter on Christian beliefs about God, creation and evil. The next chapter is Christian beliefs about Jesus, salvation and life after death. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly R, S, oh two, oh oh.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8062, Edexcel GCSE 1RA0, OCR GCSE J625, Edexcel GCSE 1RB0, Eduqas GCSE C120

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 80623.1.2.1 Key beliefs
Edexcel GCSE 1RA01B 1.7
Edexcel GCSE 1RA01B 1.8
Edexcel GCSE 1RA02B 1.7
Edexcel GCSE 1RA02B 1.8
Edexcel GCSE 1RA03A 1.8
OCR GCSE J625J625/01 Beliefs and teachings > The problem of evil and suffering and a loving and righteous God
OCR GCSE J625J625/06 The existence of God > The Question of God
Edexcel GCSE 1RB01B 1.7
Edexcel GCSE 1RB01B 1.8
Edexcel GCSE 1RB02B 1.7
Edexcel GCSE 1RB02B 1.8
Edexcel GCSE 1RB03A 2.8
Edexcel GCSE 1RB03B 1.7
Edexcel GCSE 1RB03B 1.8
Eduqas GCSE C1202.2 Beliefs and teachings / The nature of God
Eduqas GCSE C1202.4 Theme 2: Good and Evil / Beliefs: Incarnation
Eduqas GCSE C1202.4 Theme 2: Good and Evil / Good, Evil and Suffering
Eduqas GCSE C1202.4 Theme 2: Good and Evil / Sources: Jesus and moral authority
For teachers

This GCSE Religious Studies lesson teaches christian responses to the problem of evil and suffering. By the end, students should be able to explain how Christians respond to the problem that evil and suffering raise for belief in an all-powerful, all-loving God. It works through six worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.