ScholaFly

PH06-06 Physics Watch

Reliability, environmental impact and the move away from fossil fuels

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

Energy resources: how to judge energy resources by their reliability and environmental impact to explain how their use is changing. AQA 8463, Edexcel 1PH0 and OCR J249 GCSE. Efficiency and resources 6 of 6. Full Efficiency and resources playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLEn6zSy_gE70 More at https://scholafly.com

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: energy resources: reliability
  2. 0:37 Energy resources: reliability: judging a resource
  3. 1:55 An island on wind power
  4. 3:44 Environmental impact
  5. 7:37 Trends in a made-up country
  6. 9:53 Why the move is slow

Key words

About this video

Energy Resources: Reliability, environmental impact and the move away from fossil fuels | PH06-06

Energy resources: how to judge energy resources by their reliability and environmental impact to explain how their use is changing.
AQA 8463, Edexcel 1PH0 and OCR J249 GCSE. Efficiency and resources 6 of 6.
Full Efficiency and resources playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLEn6zSy_gE70
More at https://scholafly.com

Watch first: PH06-05 - https://youtu.be/Ooj7-pbnXBA
Video code: PH06-06 (search "ScholaFly PH06-06")

#GCSEPhysics #EfficiencyAndResources

For teachers
This GCSE Physics lesson teaches reliability, environmental impact and the move away from fossil fuels. By the end, students should be able to judge energy resources by their reliability and environmental impact to explain how their use is changing. It works through four worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8463
- 4.1.3
Edexcel 1PH0
- 3.13
- 3.14
OCR J249
- P8.2a
- P8.2b

Read the transcript

Why would a country that has decided to stop burning coal keep a coal power station waiting on standby? Imagine a still, freezing winter evening. The wind turbines turn out almost nothing, just as millions of people get home and switch the kettle on. Wind burns nothing and costs nothing to fuel, so the coal station can look like a mistake. It is not a mistake. That coal station on standby gets its full answer at the very end.

Every energy resource is either renewable, meaning replenished as it is used, or non-renewable. Judging a resource asks two more things: how reliable it is, and what using it does to the environment. A reliable resource supplies energy whenever it is needed, in the amount needed. Two different things rise and fall here. Output is the power a resource can supply, and demand is the power people want. Fossil fuels and nuclear fuel can be stored, so their output can be controlled. Geothermal gives a steady output, day and night. Wind, solar and waves depend on the weather and the time of day. The tides are predictable, but their output rises and falls through the day. On a still, dark evening, which keeps the lights on: solar, wind, or a gas power station? The gas power station. It can be switched on and turned up at any hour, while the turbines and panels sit idle.

A small island gets all of its electricity from three wind turbines, and it has power cuts on calm winter days. On a calm day the output falls, even though the islanders' demand does not. The islanders plan to add a small hydro-electric station, fed by a reservoir, which is a lake held back high on a hill. Why does the hydro-electric station make their supply more reliable? Its reservoir stores water, so the station can be switched on quickly whenever the wind drops, and the supply can be matched to the demand. Now look for a weak spot. Even with the new station, something could still go wrong. What could still cut the hydro station's output, with the islanders' demand unchanged? A long dry spell. Less rain means a lower reservoir, so less output, while the demand stays where it was. One examiner's report, on a Foundation paper about a hydroelectric generator, records some students confusing its power output with the power demand of the consumers. A common wrong answer was that people use less power in the summer, and students needed to link the change to rainfall or the water level. So when an output changes, give the cause on the supply side, such as less rain, less wind or less sunlight. Demand is a separate line.

An environmental impact is what using a resource does to the environment. Burning any fossil fuel releases carbon dioxide, which adds to global warming. Burning coal also releases sulfur dioxide, which causes acid rain. Nuclear power releases no carbon dioxide while it generates, but it leaves radioactive waste that must be stored safely for a very long time. Now bio-fuel. Does burning renewable wood pellets give off carbon dioxide? Yes, it does. Wood contains carbon, and burning any fuel that contains carbon releases carbon dioxide, whether the fuel is renewable or not. One examiner's report, on a Higher paper, describes a question asking which two resources give off no carbon dioxide when generating electricity. Just over seventy per cent of the students chose nuclear and solar, which is right, and the most common wrong choice was biofuel. If nuclear and solar were your two, most of the students who sat it chose the same. For the rest, the habit is to remember that being renewable does not make a resource free of carbon dioxide. The other resources have impacts of their own. Hydro-electric dams flood valleys and destroy habitats. Wind turbines change the landscape, make noise and can harm birds, and tidal barrages change the habitats of an estuary. Each fact about a resource belongs in one of three places: whether it is renewable, how reliable it is, or what it does to the environment. Now a misplaced fact. A student gives wind's environmental impact as: wind is unreliable. Which of the three places does unreliable really belong in? It belongs with reliability. It says nothing about what wind turbines do to the environment. One examiner's report, on a Foundation paper, records many students writing that renewable resources were unreliable, and not giving a negative environmental impact. Another report, a year earlier, records some students giving non-renewable as an environmental disadvantage of fossil fuels, which did not score any credit. The fix is to read the question's own words, environmental impact, and answer only that. Name the substance or the damage, and its effect. Now a bigger one. Give one negative environmental impact each for a tidal barrage across an estuary, a gas power station, and a power station that burns wood pellets. Then say why writing that wood pellets are renewable does not answer the last part. Try it on paper before I show you the answer. The barrage changes how long the estuary's mud flats are covered by water, which can destroy the feeding grounds of birds and fish. Burning gas releases carbon dioxide, which adds to global warming, and burning wood pellets releases carbon dioxide too. Renewable says the resource is replenished. It says nothing about what using it does to the environment, so it is not an environmental impact.

Now the trends. A table shows the share of a made-up country's electricity from each resource, in twenty ten and in twenty twenty-five. Coal falls from thirty per cent to two per cent, gas from forty-five to thirty-five, and nuclear from sixteen to fourteen. Wind climbs from three per cent to thirty, solar goes from nothing to six, bio-fuel from three to ten, and hydro-electricity stays at three. Pick out two trends, and give a reason for each one, from reliability or environmental impact. Pick your two, and hold on to your reasons before I show you. Coal fell from thirty per cent to two. Burning coal releases the most carbon dioxide, which adds to global warming, and sulfur dioxide, which causes acid rain. Wind rose from three per cent to thirty. It is renewable, and it releases no carbon dioxide as it generates. Add the renewables together, and they rise from nine per cent to forty-nine. Now a reason question. Why is gas still the largest share in twenty twenty-five? Gas can be switched on quickly whenever the wind drops, so it keeps the supply reliable. For the same electricity, burning it also releases less carbon dioxide than burning coal. One examiner's report, on a long-answer question about trends, notes that the trends were identified from the graph, especially the decline of coal. It adds that harm to the environment from burning fossil fuels was often mentioned, but often lacked detail. If you can read the fall of coal off a table, you are doing what that report found most students could. The detail is the gas and its effect, so name both every time.

Science can identify the environmental problems a resource causes. It does not always have the power to deal with them, because of political, social, ethical and economic considerations. Back to the coal station on standby. Give two different kinds of reason why the country keeps it ready for years. Have a go at this one before I show you. Reliability is one kind of reason. On a still, dark winter evening, wind and solar output can fall to almost nothing just as demand peaks, so something that can be switched on whenever it is needed has to wait in reserve. Cost is another kind, an economic one. Building enough wind farms, solar farms and storage costs a great deal and takes years, so the switch is slow. A social or political reason counts too, such as jobs in coal towns, or people objecting to new wind farms near their homes. Science found the problem with coal. Dealing with it depends on all of these things as well.

Four last questions to round off the judging, and each one is yours first. An oil-fired power station: what is one environmental impact, and its effect? Burning oil releases carbon dioxide, which adds to global warming. Now reliability. Why are solar panels less reliable than a nuclear power station? Their output depends on daylight and the weather, while a nuclear station's output can be controlled whenever it is needed. Now a slip to judge. Is being non-renewable an environmental impact of oil? It is not. That fact belongs with whether oil is renewable. Its environmental impact is the carbon dioxide it releases, which adds to global warming. Now the last. What reason, not about science, could slow a switch to wind farms? People may object to wind farms near their homes, or building enough of them may cost too much and take years. And the coal station on standby makes sense now. It is kept for reliability, while enough wind, solar and storage are built to take its place.

If there's no need to see this twice, give it a thumbs-up, and you will know it is finished. If not, save it, and say aloud once how you would judge a resource, because it sticks better once you have said it.

That completes our chapter on Energy efficiency and resources. The next chapter is Stopping distances and momentum. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly P H oh seven, oh oh.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8463, Edexcel GCSE 1PH0, OCR GCSE J249

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 84634.1.3National and global energy resources
Edexcel GCSE 1PH03.13Describe the main energy sources available for use on Earth (including fossil fuels, nuclear fuel, bio-fuel, wind, hydro- electricity, the tides and the Sun), and compare the ways in which both renewable and non-renewable sources are used
Edexcel GCSE 1PH03.14Explain patterns and trends in the use of energy resources
OCR GCSE J249P8.2aDescribe the main energy sources available for use on Earth, compare the ways in which they are used and distinguish between renewable and non-renewable sources
OCR GCSE J249P8.2bExplain patterns and trends in the use of energy resources
For teachers

This GCSE Physics lesson teaches reliability, environmental impact and the move away from fossil fuels. By the end, students should be able to judge energy resources by their reliability and environmental impact to explain how their use is changing. It works through four worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.