ScholaFly

PH05-02 Physics Watch

Energy transfer diagrams and the common scale

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

How to show on one common scale how the total energy of a system is shared, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8463, Edexcel 1PH0 and OCR J249 GCSE. Energy, work and power 2 of 7. Full Energy, work and power playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLPPZkyH7zKm4 More at https://scholafly.com

By the end: Show on one common scale how the total energy of a system is shared between its stores before and after a change.

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: energy diagrams on a common scale
  2. 0:36 Energy diagrams on a common scale: one unit: the joule
  3. 1:56 The kettle on one scale
  4. 4:46 The tennis ball, with numbers
  5. 8:24 The sledge, partly done

Key words

About this video

Energy transfer diagrams and the common scale | GCSE Physics | PH05-02

How to show on one common scale how the total energy of a system is shared, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8463, Edexcel 1PH0 and OCR J249 GCSE. Energy, work and power 2 of 7.
Full Energy, work and power playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLPPZkyH7zKm4
More at https://scholafly.com

Video code: PH05-02 (search "ScholaFly PH05-02")

Videos in this chapter:
PH05-00 Energy stores, work and power - Intro
PH05-02 Energy transfer diagrams and the common scale
PH05-03 Work done and energy transfer
PH05-05 Kinetic energy
PH05-06 Gravitational potential energy
PH05-07 Elastic potential energy

#GCSEPhysics #EnergyWorkAndPower

For teachers
This GCSE Physics lesson teaches energy transfer diagrams and the common scale. By the end, students should be able to show on one common scale how the total energy of a system is shared between its stores before and after a change. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8463
- 4.1.1.1
Edexcel 1PH0
- 3.3
- 8.2
OCR J249
- P7.1d

Read the transcript

Drop a tennis ball from your hand. Why does it never bounce back up as high as your hand? Each bounce is lower than the one before, until the ball lies still on the floor. Nothing was added to it, and nothing was taken away. It is tempting to say the energy simply ran out. It did not run out. It went somewhere, and a drawing to scale can show where. That ball returns with numbers attached, after the two kinds of drawing are built.

In the video on energy stores and the three ways a system's energy changes, you met eight stores and three ways energy moves between them. This video puts sizes on them. Every store is measured in the same unit, the joule. That is what lets a kinetic store and a thermal store sit side by side on one scale. Both tiers need this, Foundation and Higher. Kilojoules and megajoules are converted to joules before anything is drawn. A kilojoule is a thousand joules, and a megajoule is a million. How many joules is two point four kilojoules? Two thousand four hundred. Multiply the kilojoules by a thousand. On one board you also need the kilowatt-hour. It is an amount of energy, and one kilowatt-hour is three point six million joules. The word kilowatt can mislead you here. A kilowatt is a rate, which the video on power as the rate of energy transfer covers. A kilowatt-hour is an amount of energy, so it sits on the same scale as the joule.

A bar chart on one common scale shows every store in the system twice: once before the change, and once after it. Take an electric kettle running for one minute. It receives a hundred and fifty thousand joules by work done when a current flows. The thermal store of the water rises by a hundred and twenty-six thousand joules. The thermal store of the kettle's body rises by fifteen thousand joules. The rest goes to the thermal store of the air. How many joules went to the thermal store of the air? Nine thousand joules went to the air. Here is the working. First add up what is accounted for. A hundred and twenty-six thousand plus fifteen thousand is a hundred and forty-one thousand joules. Then take that from the total. A hundred and fifty thousand take away a hundred and forty-one thousand leaves nine thousand joules. Now the scale: one centimetre for every ten thousand joules, so each length is the energy divided by ten thousand. The before bar holds all one hundred and fifty thousand joules, which makes it fifteen centimetres tall. A dashed line goes across the chart at fifteen centimetres. That is the total line, and every after bar must reach it. The after bar is a stack. Water: a hundred and twenty-six thousand divided by ten thousand is twelve point six centimetres. Kettle body: one point five centimetres. Air: nought point nine centimetres. Add the three heights. Does the after stack reach the total line? Yes, it lands level with the line at fifteen centimetres. Twelve point six plus one point five is fourteen point one. Add nought point nine and you get fifteen point nought centimetres. A different student forgets the air altogether, so their after stack stops below the dashed line. What does that gap below the total line tell the student? A store is missing from the after bar. The parts must add back to the total, so they go looking, and it is usually a thermal store.

Back to the tennis ball, now with numbers. Held still above the floor, its gravitational store holds six joules. After one bounce, it rises to a height where its gravitational store holds four point five joules. How many joules are missing at the top of the bounce? One and a half joules are unaccounted for. Six take away four point five leaves one point five joules. That share went to the thermal stores of the ball, the floor and the air, and a little was carried away as sound. For the bars, the scale is one centimetre for every nought point five joules. So the start bar, six joules, is six divided by nought point five, which is twelve centimetres tall. Four point five divided by nought point five is nine centimetres of gravitational store. One point five divided by nought point five is three centimetres of thermal store. Nine plus three is twelve, right on the total line. The second kind of drawing is a transfer diagram. One arrow comes in and splits into arrows for the stores that end up larger, and each arrow's width stands for its share. Choose the scale first and write it on the diagram: five millimetres for every joule. Then each width gets its own line: energy times scale equals width. The arrow in carries six joules. One arrow out carries four point five joules, and the other carries one point five. Pause and find all three arrow widths, at five millimetres per joule. Thirty millimetres in. Twenty-two point five out to the gravitational store, and seven point five to the thermal stores. Six times five is thirty. Four point five times five is twenty-two point five. One point five times five is seven point five. Check before drawing: twenty-two point five plus seven point five is thirty millimetres, the same as the arrow in. Bars and arrows are the same accounting, drawn two ways. In both, the parts add back to the total. One student's whole answer about this ball reads: as it falls, its gravitational store decreases and its kinetic store increases. That answer is marked incomplete. What is it missing? An after picture. It describes one moment of the fall, and never accounts for the whole system before and after. One examiner's report, on a Foundation paper about a bouncing ball, records this. "The majority of students simply described, correctly or incorrectly, the energy change as the ball fell or landed. There was little appreciation that the question required students to consider the energy changes within a closed system." Draw two bars instead, before and after, with every store in the system on both of them.

The last example comes partly ready-made. A sledge and rider at the top of a snowy slope have nine thousand joules in their gravitational store. The before bar and its total line are already drawn at nine thousand joules. Lower down, at the foot of the slope, the kinetic store holds six thousand five hundred joules. How many joules are missing from the bottom bar? It is two thousand five hundred joules, found by subtraction. Nine thousand take away six thousand five hundred is two thousand five hundred joules. Now the new step. Where did those joules go, and how did they get there? To the thermal stores of the runners, the snow and the air, by heating, because work was done against friction and air resistance, the drag of the air. The stores at the top and the bottom are different kinds, so the total line is the only thing tying them together.

Time to check what stuck about drawing energy to scale. On a common scale, what must every after stack reach? The total line, level with the top of the before bar. Here's a playground swing. At the top, its gravitational store holds two hundred joules. At the bottom, its kinetic store holds a hundred and seventy. How many joules went to thermal stores on the way down? Thirty joules, to the thermal stores of the swing and the air. Now a transfer diagram at five millimetres per joule. How wide is a twelve-joule arrow? Sixty millimetres: twelve joules times five millimetres per joule. And the tennis ball's missing height was never lost. Each bounce moved a share into the thermal stores of the ball, the floor and the air.

Once drawing to scale is in the bag, a thumbs up records it, and this one never needs watching again. If it is still wobbly, save the video, then write the kettle's sums out once yourself and it stays.

Next in the chapter is Work done and energy transfer. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly P H oh five, oh three.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8463, Edexcel GCSE 1PH0, OCR GCSE J249

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 84634.1.1.1Energy stores and systems
Edexcel GCSE 1PH03.3Draw and interpret diagrams to represent energy transfers
Edexcel GCSE 1PH08.2Draw and interpret diagrams to represent energy transfers
OCR GCSE J249P7.1dMake calculations of the energy changes associated with changes in a system, recalling or selecting the relevant equations for mechanical, electrical, and thermal processes; thereby express in quantitative form and on a common scale the overall redistribution of energy in the system work done by forces, current flow, through heating and the use of kW h to measure energy use in electrical appliances in the home
For teachers

This GCSE Physics lesson teaches energy transfer diagrams and the common scale. By the end, students should be able to show on one common scale how the total energy of a system is shared between its stores before and after a change. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.