HI03-04 History Watch
How Goebbels used propaganda and censorship to shape what Germans thought
In this lesson
Nazi control, 1933-39 for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0, OCR J410, OCR J411 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Nazi control, 1933-39 4 of 8. More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: nazi control, 1933-39
- 0:39 Nazi control, 1933-39: propaganda and censorship
- 3:01 Censorship: the press
- 4:48 Rallies and cinema
- 7:06 A source's purpose
- 8:59 Propaganda's effect
About this video
Nazi Control, 1933-39: how Goebbels used propaganda and censorship to shape what Germans | HI03-04
Nazi control, 1933-39 for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0, OCR J410, OCR J411 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Nazi control, 1933-39 4 of 8.
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: HI03-04 (search "ScholaFly HI03-04")
#GCSEHistory #NaziControl193339
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches how Goebbels used propaganda and censorship to shape what Germans thought. By the end, students should be able to students can explain how Goebbels used propaganda and censorship to shape what Germans thought. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8145
- 1A/B Part three: Control
Edexcel 1HI0
- 31 3.3
OCR J410
- J410/02 Nazi Germany and its people
OCR J411
- J411 Living under Nazi Rule Control and Opposition
Eduqas C100
- 1G Terror and persuasion
Read the transcript
Why would a government want a cheap radio in almost every German home? In nineteen thirty-three, a new radio called the People's Receiver went on sale for seventy-six Reichsmarks, far cheaper than most sets. It was built so that it struggled to pick up stations from abroad. A kindness to poorer families is the obvious answer, and it leaves out what came out of the speaker. Behind that radio stood one ministry, and it reached much further.
That radio was one tool of propaganda, which is information spread to make people think or act in a certain way, usually by showing only one side. Censorship is its partner: stopping people from seeing or hearing anything the government does not want them to. In March nineteen thirty-three, Hitler made Joseph Goebbels his Minister of Popular Enlightenment and Propaganda. Goebbels's ministry controlled newspapers, radio and film, so one man's office decided what Germans could read, hear and watch. That date, March nineteen thirty-three, is the start line for everything in this story. On one paper, an examiner's report says students need to recognise the difference between Nazi methods during the rise to power and after nineteen thirty-three. So keep the election posters of nineteen thirty-two for questions on the rise to power, which is the video on why support for the Nazi Party grew. Another report, on a short question about propaganda after nineteen thirty-three, found most students did well, with relatively few slipping back to the posters that had won the Nazis power. Keeping to that start line puts you in good company. Propaganda is a message pushed through the media, while culture policy is what the regime did to the arts themselves. Now sort two examples. The first: a newsreel before a film shows Hitler opening a new motorway. The second: the Bauhaus art school is closed down. Which one is propaganda, the first or the second? The first, because it pushes a message through the media, while closing an art school is culture policy, which has its own video on how the Nazis controlled the arts.
Censorship began with the newspapers, where most Germans got their news. Communist and Social Democrat papers were shut down in nineteen thirty-three, and hundreds more were closed or taken over in the years that followed. The Editors' Law of October nineteen thirty-three made every editor responsible for printing nothing that harmed the regime. Each day, the ministry told the newspapers what to report and how. If an editor's job depended on loyal content, what would happen to criticism? It vanished before anyone had to ban it, because editors cut it themselves to stay safe. In May nineteen thirty-three, students burned books by Jewish, communist and other banned writers in bonfires across Germany. Listening to foreign radio was discouraged, and once war came it became a crime. Radio carried the regime's voice into the home, and that is why the People's Receiver mattered to Goebbels. Hitler's speeches were broadcast across the country, and loudspeakers in streets, cafes and workplaces meant people heard them even without a set. Censorship removed the other side of every story, and radio filled the silence with the regime's own voice.
Every September the party held a vast rally at Nuremberg, with hundreds of thousands marching in perfect order. Searchlights, flags and speeches were staged to show a nation united and strong, and newsreels and papers carried the pictures to Germans who never went. Newsreels, short news films, were shown before every feature in every cinema, and the ministry controlled what went into them. In nineteen thirty-five, Leni Riefenstahl's film Triumph of the Will turned the Nuremberg rally into a vast, almost religious spectacle. In August nineteen thirty-six, Berlin hosted the Olympic Games, and Goebbels used them as a show for the world. Signs attacking Jews were taken down while foreign visitors were in the city. Think about when those signs came down, and when they went back up. Why take those signs down only for the Games? The Games were aimed at foreign visitors, and the signs would have shown them the persecution the regime wanted hidden. Germany finished top of the medal table, which the regime presented as proof of German strength. But the Games also produced a story the regime could not control, because Jesse Owens, a Black American athlete, won four gold medals and cut across Nazi claims about a master race. Through every medium, the same messages came back. Hitler was the man who had saved Germany. All true Germans belonged to one National Community. Communists and Jews were the enemy. Every one of those is a propaganda claim, made by the regime, and none of them is a fact.
A source question can ask for a source's purpose, which is what its maker wanted the audience to think or do. The source is a speech Goebbels gave to the directors of German radio stations, in Berlin, on the twenty-fifth of March, nineteen thirty-three. In it, he told them that radio must now serve the government's aims. Before the content, read who was talking, and to whom. What does that audience tell you about Goebbels's purpose? He was addressing the men who ran the radio, so this was an order, not an advert to the public. On a source question about a book from the Nazi Party, one examiner's report says many thought it was a set of instructions for ordinary Germans. They missed, it says, that the book was produced by the party to instruct its own officials. The habit is to read the audience first, because a source aimed at officials gives orders. In the model answer, the message is that radio must follow the government. The purpose is to give orders: less than two weeks after his ministry was created, Goebbels was telling the men who ran radio what was now expected. Own knowledge backs it, because the regime wanted radio in every home, hence the cheap People's Receiver, and Hitler's speeches went out across Germany. The purpose, then, was to bring radio under Nazi control, so that it could be used to win Germans over.
The last question is how well the propaganda worked. It worked best where it built on what many people already believed: fear of communism, anger at the Treaty of Versailles, and faith in Hitler as a strong leader. It worked best, too, when real success backed it up, such as jobs coming back. It worked less well at changing deep loyalties, such as people's attachment to their Church, or their grumbles about pay. And nobody could answer back in public, so how far Germans truly believed it is hard to measure. Two judgements of that, to compare. The first: propaganda brainwashed every German. The second: propaganda worked best where it built on existing beliefs and where success backed it up. Which of the two judgements is stronger, and why? The second, because it says where propaganda worked and where it did not, while the first claims something no evidence could show. An essay might claim that propaganda was the main reason the Nazis kept their grip on Germany from nineteen thirty-three to nineteen thirty-nine. Pick one, then hold on to it before I reveal it: agree or disagree, and why? For: Goebbels's ministry controlled every newspaper, radio station and cinema, which meant most Germans heard only the Nazi version of events. Rallies and the Olympics showed a strong, united Germany, and propaganda built the image of Hitler as the man who saved the country. Against: propaganda worked best when it matched what people saw, such as jobs returning and Versailles being torn up, so success did much of the persuading. And where persuasion failed, terror took over, because the Gestapo, the camps and the captured courts made open opposition too dangerous. My verdict: propaganda mattered, but it was not the main reason, because terror removed the opponents it could never convert, and real successes gave it something to boast about.
A few questions now to bring it together, so answer each one out loud. What is the start line for Nazi propaganda in power, and why? March nineteen thirty-three, when Goebbels's ministry was created; posters from before then belong to the rise to power. Now, what did the Editors' Law make every editor responsible for? Printing nothing that harmed the regime, so editors censored themselves. Now, why did antisemitic signs come down in Berlin in nineteen thirty-six? To hide the persecution from foreign visitors during the Olympic Games. Imagine a poster from nineteen thirty-six telling Germans to buy a People's Receiver. What was that poster's purpose, beyond selling radios? To get the regime's voice into every home, so more Germans heard Hitler's speeches and the ministry's messages. Back to that cheap radio with its weak reach abroad. By nineteen thirty-nine, about seven in ten German homes had a radio, and the voice coming out of it belonged to Goebbels's ministry.
Once you can explain each medium and judge how well it worked, that's in the bag, and a thumbs-up says so. If you are not there yet, keep it saved, because it comes with the questions.
Next in the chapter is How the Nazis controlled art, architecture, literature and film. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly H, I, oh three, oh five.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8145, Edexcel GCSE 1HI0, OCR GCSE J410, OCR GCSE J411, Eduqas GCSE C100
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8145 | 1A/B Part three: Control | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1HI0 | 31 3.3 | |
| OCR GCSE J410 | J410/02 Nazi Germany and its people | |
| OCR GCSE J411 | J411 Living under Nazi Rule Control and Opposition | |
| Eduqas GCSE C100 | 1G Terror and persuasion |
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches how Goebbels used propaganda and censorship to shape what Germans thought. By the end, students should be able to students can explain how Goebbels used propaganda and censorship to shape what Germans thought. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.