HI03-02 History Watch
How the Night of the Long Knives and Hindenburg's death gave Hitler total power in 1934
In this lesson
Nazi control, 1933-39 for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0, OCR J410, OCR J411 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Nazi control, 1933-39 2 of 8. More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: nazi control, 1933-39
- 0:51 Nazi control, 1933-39
- 2:53 Night of the Long Knives
- 5:04 Consequences of the purge
- 8:51 Nazi control, 1933-39: explain why
About this video
Nazi Control, 1933-39: how the Night of the Long Knives and Hindenburg's death gave | HI03-02
Nazi control, 1933-39 for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0, OCR J410, OCR J411 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Nazi control, 1933-39 2 of 8.
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: HI03-02 (search "ScholaFly HI03-02")
#GCSEHistory #NaziControl193339
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches how the Night of the Long Knives and Hindenburg's death gave Hitler total power in 1934. By the end, students should be able to students can explain how the Night of the Long Knives and Hindenburg's death gave Hitler total power by August 1934. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8145
- 1A/B Part two: The establishment of Hitler’s dictatorship
Edexcel 1HI0
- 31 3.1
OCR J410
- J410/02 The rise and consolidation of the Nazi regime
OCR J411
- J411 Living under Nazi Rule Dictatorship
Eduqas C100
- 1G Consolidation of power
- 2B The Rise of the Nazi Party and its consolidation of power between 1933 and 1934
Read the transcript
Why would a dictator destroy the very men who had helped him to power? In June nineteen thirty-four, the biggest danger to Hitler was not the Communists or the Social Democrats. It was his own party army, the SA, around three million men, led by one of his oldest friends, Ernst Rohm. On the night of the thirtieth of June, Hitler had Rohm arrested, and within two days Rohm was dead. A quarrel between old friends is the obvious reading, and it misses what Hitler gained. To see what he gained, start with what still stood in his way.
Total power means having no one left at the top who could remove you, by law or by force. In the summer of nineteen thirty-three, Hitler led a one-party state, but three things still stood between him and total power. The first was President Paul von Hindenburg, who could still dismiss him, though Hindenburg was now eighty-five and frail. The second was the army, about a hundred thousand professional soldiers, which had not yet sworn itself to Hitler. The third was the SA, the Nazi Party's own army of brownshirts, which had grown to around three million men by nineteen thirty-four. Ernst Rohm, the SA's leader, wanted what he called a second revolution. By that he meant sweeping aside the old elites, the generals, the landowners and the big businessmen, whom Hitler still needed. Rohm also wanted the army merged into the SA, with himself in command. The generals saw the SA as a rabble of street fighters, and they would not serve under Rohm. Big business feared all the talk of revolution, and the conservatives around Hindenburg were alarmed as well. Why did a hundred thousand soldiers matter more to Hitler than three million SA men? The army was trained and armed, and it could remove him. And when Hindenburg died, Hitler would need the generals behind him to take the President's place, so the army's loyalty was the prize.
Hitler chose the army, and the night he struck, a purge of his own side, became known as the Night of the Long Knives. It began on the thirtieth of June, nineteen thirty-four, and the killing went on until the second of July. Rohm was arrested at a hotel near Munich, and the next day he was shot in his prison cell. The killers came from the SS, Hitler's black-uniformed guard, led by Heinrich Himmler. Now a prediction: who else might Hitler remove on that same night? Old enemies, including people with no link to the SA at all. Kurt von Schleicher, the Chancellor before Hitler, was shot dead at his home. Gregor Strasser, once a Nazi leader who had broken with Hitler, was killed as well. At least eighty-five people died, and possibly many more. On the thirteenth of July, Hitler told the Reichstag, the German parliament, that he had acted as Germany's supreme judge. One other name gets mixed up with this one, so pin it down now. Kristallnacht was a different event: attacks on Jewish homes, shops and synagogues in November nineteen thirty-eight, four years later and against different victims. On a question about these years, one examiner's report says some students confused the Night of the Long Knives with Kristallnacht. The habit that prevents it is to pin each name to its date and its target: June nineteen thirty-four and Hitler's own side, against November nineteen thirty-eight and Germany's Jews.
The purge changed the balance of power in Germany within a single weekend. Its first consequence was that the SA lost its power for good, and never again threatened the army. The SS was rewarded by being made independent of the SA, answering to Hitler alone. The generals were reassured, because their rival had been destroyed for them. And everyone else learned that Hitler would kill, even old comrades, to keep his power. Which of those results would count most once Hindenburg died? The generals' relief, because Hitler would need the army behind him to take Hindenburg's place. Five weeks later, on the second of August, nineteen thirty-four, Hindenburg died. Now a second prediction: what would Hitler do with the President's office? He merged the offices of President and Chancellor into one, and took the title Fuhrer, which means leader. A vote on the nineteenth of August approved the change, with about ninety per cent saying yes. How far that figure shows real support is the question of the video on how far Germans supported the regime. That same month, every soldier swore an oath of allegiance, a solemn promise of loyalty. They swore it to Hitler in person, by name, and not to Germany's constitution. The army had chosen to work with Hitler, rather than being conquered. Two things happened that August, and they were not equal. Why did the soldiers' oath matter more than Hitler's new title? A title was only a name, but the oath bound the army, the one force that could remove him, to Hitler personally. One examiner's report on an essay about these years found much knowledge of the purge, of how it removed rivals inside the party and won the support of the army. So that knowledge is common, and the way to go further is to add the oath, because it gives the army's support a date and a form. Now, pictures of the purge came from both sides. In July nineteen thirty-four, the British cartoonist David Low drew Hitler holding a smoking gun over the purge, for a London newspaper. A student looks at that cartoon and calls it Nazi propaganda. Why is that student wrong about Low's cartoon? Low was a British critic of Hitler drawing for a British paper, so the cartoon shows how the regime's enemies saw the purge. The habit is to read who made a source before what it says.
An explain-why question turns this story into causes, using the purge itself. The task is to explain why Hitler ordered the Night of the Long Knives in nineteen thirty-four. Pause it there and work it out for yourself: three causes, each with a which meant. First, the threat from Rohm: the SA had around three million men and Rohm wanted it to swallow the army, which meant Hitler risked losing control of his own movement. Second, the army: the generals would not accept Rohm, and with Hindenburg close to death, Hitler needed them to take over as head of state. Removing Rohm was the price of the generals' loyalty. Third, the chance to settle scores: killing Schleicher and Strasser left no one, inside or outside the party, able to challenge him. The causes link, because the army mattered most while Hindenburg's death was close, and the SA threat made that support uncertain. Now an interpretation, which is a later view by a historian rather than a source from the time. One historian argues, in our own paraphrase, that Hitler acted against the SA mainly to win over the generals before Hindenburg died. Test that view against the story you now know. Which evidence supports that view, and which does not? It fits that the generals feared Rohm's plan, Hindenburg was dying, and within weeks the army swore its oath, which looks like a deal. It does not explain everything, because Rohm's second revolution also scared big business, and killing Schleicher and Strasser had nothing to do with the army. My verdict: the generals were the main reason, because the timing and the oath show the army was the prize, and settling old scores was a useful extra. Step back over the whole road, from January nineteen thirty-three to August nineteen thirty-four, and the method changed over time. In nineteen thirty-three, laws did most of the work: the Reichstag Fire decree and the Enabling Act. In nineteen thirty-four, force and a deal finished it: the purge, and the army's oath in return. That leaves a judgement between two very different methods. Now, for total power, which mattered more, the laws or the purge? The laws gave Hitler control of Germany's government, but only the purge and the oath removed the last rivals at the top, so total power came from the deal with the army. On an essay about how Hitler gained total power, one examiner's report says a large number of answers drifted towards how Hitler controlled the population at large. The fix is to keep total power at the top: Hindenburg gone, the army sworn to Hitler, and the SA broken. The same report that praised knowledge of the purge also records a slip in timing: answers that saw the purge as a direct consequence of the Enabling Act. Instead, date both: the Act in March nineteen thirty-three and the purge in June nineteen thirty-four, fifteen months apart, with causes of its own.
Time to check the story has stuck, with you answering first. What three things still stood in Hitler's way in the summer of nineteen thirty-three? President Hindenburg, the army, and Rohm's SA. Now, why did Hitler side with the army against Rohm? He needed the generals behind him to take over when Hindenburg died, and they would never accept Rohm. Now, what did soldiers swear in August nineteen thirty-four, and to whom? An oath of loyalty, to Hitler in person rather than to the constitution. Imagine a cartoon of the purge, printed in a Paris newspaper in July nineteen thirty-four. Is it likely to be Nazi propaganda, and what do you check first? Unlikely, because a French paper was outside the regime's control, so check who drew it and read it first as an outsider's view. Back to June nineteen thirty-four, and Rohm's three million brownshirts. By August nineteen thirty-four the SA was broken and Rohm was dead, while the army swore its loyalty to Hitler in person, and that is what destroying his own side had gained him.
If you can explain why the army mattered more than the SA, this one's done, and a thumbs-up tells you it never needs watching again. If the reasons are still blurry, keep it saved, then give it a day and look again.
Next in the chapter is How the SS, the Gestapo, the camps and the courts kept the Nazis in control. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly H, I, oh three, oh three.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8145, Edexcel GCSE 1HI0, OCR GCSE J410, OCR GCSE J411, Eduqas GCSE C100
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8145 | 1A/B Part two: The establishment of Hitler’s dictatorship | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1HI0 | 31 3.1 | |
| OCR GCSE J410 | J410/02 The rise and consolidation of the Nazi regime | |
| OCR GCSE J411 | J411 Living under Nazi Rule Dictatorship | |
| Eduqas GCSE C100 | 1G Consolidation of power | |
| Eduqas GCSE C100 | 2B The Rise of the Nazi Party and its consolidation of power between 1933 and 1934 |
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches how the Night of the Long Knives and Hindenburg's death gave Hitler total power in 1934. By the end, students should be able to students can explain how the Night of the Long Knives and Hindenburg's death gave Hitler total power by August 1934. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.