HI02-03 History Watch
How life changed for workers and women in Weimar Germany, 1924-1929
In this lesson
Weimar and the nazi rise for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. Edexcel 1HI0 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Weimar and the Nazi rise 3 of 8. More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: weimar and the nazi rise
- 0:54 Weimar and the nazi rise: workers' living standards
- 3:12 Women: politics, work and leisure
- 4:59 Three Germans in 1928: which gained least?
- 7:27 An explain question
About this video
Weimar and the Nazi Rise: how life changed for workers and women in Weimar Germany | HI02-03
Weimar and the nazi rise for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Edexcel 1HI0 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Weimar and the Nazi rise 3 of 8.
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: HI02-03 (search "ScholaFly HI02-03")
#GCSEHistory #WeimarAndTheNaziRise
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches how life changed for workers and women in Weimar Germany, 1924-1929. By the end, students should be able to students can describe how living standards and the position of women changed in Germany between 1924 and 1929. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
Edexcel 1HI0
- 31 1.4
Eduqas C100
- 1G Recovery of Weimar
Read the transcript
Who in Germany was better off by the late nineteen twenties? In nineteen nineteen German women voted for the first time, and thirty-seven women were elected to the new National Assembly. Ten years on, young women in Berlin worked in offices, cut their hair short and went out dancing on their own. Factory workers had rising wages and, from nineteen twenty-seven, insurance if they lost their jobs. It is tempting to answer everybody, a roaring twenties for the whole country. Yet many Germans, many women among them, saw these changes as a danger. Workers come first, then women, then the question of who gained most.
The standard of living means how well people can live on what they earn. It takes in their pay, their hours, their homes and how secure they feel. Start with wages. Real wages, which means what your pay can buy, rose for many industrial workers in the later nineteen twenties. Strong trade unions pushed for more, and the state stepped in to settle wage disputes, a system called arbitration. Now a reason question, before the next change arrives. Why do real wages tell you more than the number on a pay slip? Because a rise is worth nothing if prices climb faster. In nineteen twenty-three wages had bought almost nothing, so a real rise meant more food, clothes and leisure. Hours had been cut too. The eight-hour day was won in nineteen eighteen, though by the middle of the twenties many people were working longer again. Housing changed fastest. Local councils, paid for partly by a tax on rents, built modern estates in cities such as Berlin and Frankfurt. More than two million new homes went up between nineteen twenty-four and nineteen thirty-one. Then came security. The Unemployment Insurance Act of nineteen twenty-seven covered about seventeen million workers. It worked like a shared pot. Workers and employers each paid in every week. Before going on, make a guess of your own. What would that insurance change for a family whose breadwinner was laid off? For a family whose breadwinner was laid off, losing a job no longer meant instant poverty. Money kept coming in while the search for work went on, which made life far more secure.
The position of women means their place in three areas of life: politics, work and leisure. In politics, women over twenty got the vote in nineteen nineteen, and the new constitution wrote equal rights for men and women into law. The thirty-seven women elected that year made up about one deputy in ten. In work, more women took jobs in offices, shops, the civil service, teaching and medicine. But they were often paid less than men, and in nineteen nineteen many were pushed to give jobs back to returning soldiers. In leisure, the cities produced the new woman. The new woman wore short hair and make-up, smoked, played sport, and went out to cafes, cinemas and dance halls without an escort. Now hold that picture up against the whole of Germany. Was the new woman typical of German women in the twenties? No. She was mostly young, single and living in a big city. Most women, in small towns and the countryside, lived much as their mothers had. Even so, she frightened many people. Conservatives, the churches and nationalists saw her as a threat to the family, and many women agreed with them. Divorce rose and the birth rate fell, and the critics blamed the changes.
Put it all together, and the gains fell unevenly. Here are three Germans in nineteen twenty-eight. The first is a metalworker in Berlin, on a union wage. The second is a young typist in Hamburg. The third is a shopkeeper's widow, living on savings from before the war. Which one gained least, the first, the second or the third? The widow gained least. Her savings vanished in nineteen twenty-three and never came back, and the wage rises and new freedoms passed her by. The same goes for much of the middle class, for farmers, whose incomes fell from the late twenties, and for most women in the countryside. Unemployment never fell below a million either. The gains went most to urban workers and young city women. Now a different question, about dates. Three facts are offered for an answer on women between nineteen twenty-four and nineteen twenty-nine. The first, more women working as teachers and doctors. The second, short hair and nights out at Berlin dance halls. The third, loans to newly married couples if the wife gave up her job. Which one does not belong, the first, the second or the third? Those marriage loans, the last fact, were a Nazi policy, brought in after nineteen thirty-three, so they fall outside the question's dates however true they are. On a question about the mid to late nineteen twenties, one examiner's report says some weaker answers brought in knowledge from after nineteen thirty-three, which could not be rewarded. It names references to changes in women's lives and the impact of Nazi policies on living standards. So check the date of every fact against the question's window before it goes in. Nazi policies on women have their own videos later on.
Turn all of that into an exam answer explaining why living standards improved for Germans from nineteen twenty-four to nineteen twenty-nine, with housing and insurance as hints. Pause it there and work it out for yourself: three explained reasons. First, wages rose. Industry grew on American loans, and unions and arbitration pushed pay up, which meant many workers could afford more food, clothes and leisure. Second, housing improved. Councils, funded by a tax on rents, built modern estates, and more than two million new homes went up in seven years. That meant many families left overcrowded flats for homes with running water and better light. Third, the nineteen twenty-seven insurance act covered about seventeen million workers, which meant losing a job no longer meant instant poverty. The gains were uneven, though, because the middle classes never got back their lost savings. Women's lives also turn up in questions on historians' views. Two views, each put in our own words, are set side by side, and the task is the main difference, with details from each. The first view says the Weimar years transformed women's lives, with the vote, the professions and new freedoms in their social lives. The second view says change was limited, because the new freedoms reached mainly young, single women in the big cities. Answer one says the first view mentions the vote and the second does not. Answer two says the first view sees change for women in general, while the second sees change for a small group only. Which is stronger, answer one or answer two, and why? Answer two. It names the difference in overall view, how far change went and for whom, and it can be backed from both. Answer one picks out a detail, which is weaker.
Back through it now, and you answer each one first.
What did the insurance act of nineteen twenty-seven give workers?
The insurance act gave benefits to workers who lost their jobs, from a fund that workers and employers paid into, covering about seventeen million people.
Now, what was one gain for women at work, and one limit?
A gain for women at work was more jobs in offices, shops, teaching and medicine. A limit was that they were often paid less than men.
Now a case the video never met. A young unmarried woman works in a Frankfurt department store in nineteen twenty-eight.
Did she gain a lot from these years, or a little, and why?
She gained a lot. She is young, single, earning and living in a big city, so the new jobs and freedoms reached her, even if a man would have been paid more.
Back to who was better off by the late twenties. Life did change, most of all for young people in the cities. And the speed of that change made others want the old ways back.
If you could explain who gained and who did not, a thumbs-up says you could teach this one. And if that felt fast, that's normal, so take the workers and the women one half at a time.
Next in the chapter is Weimar culture: new art, architecture and cinema, and the reaction against them. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly H, I, oh two, oh four.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: Edexcel GCSE 1HI0, Eduqas GCSE C100
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| Edexcel GCSE 1HI0 | 31 1.4 | |
| Eduqas GCSE C100 | 1G Recovery of Weimar |
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches how life changed for workers and women in Weimar Germany, 1924-1929. By the end, students should be able to students can describe how living standards and the position of women changed in Germany between 1924 and 1929. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.