HI01-06 History Watch
The crisis of 1923: why the French occupied the Ruhr and how hyperinflation followed
In this lesson
Germany 1890 to 1923 for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Germany 1890 to 1923 6 of 8. More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: germany 1890 to 1923: the ruhr
- 0:35 Germany 1890 to 1923: the ruhr: reparations and France
- 2:57 Why printing destroys value
- 4:58 Who came out ahead, and why?
- 6:49 Two different crises
- 9:15 The explained answer
- 10:49 Run the chain back
- 11:34 Winners and losers
About this video
Germany 1890 to 1923: why the French occupied the Ruhr and how hyperinflation followed | HI01-06
Germany 1890 to 1923 for GCSE History, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8145, Edexcel 1HI0 and Eduqas C100 GCSE. Germany 1890 to 1923 6 of 8.
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: HI01-06 (search "ScholaFly HI01-06")
#GCSEHistory #Germany1890To1923 #Germany1890To1923TheRuhr
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches the crisis of 1923: why the French occupied the Ruhr and how hyperinflation followed. By the end, students should be able to students can explain the causes and effects of the Ruhr occupation and hyperinflation in 1923. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8145
- 1A/B Part one: Impact of the First World War
Edexcel 1HI0
- 31 1.2
Eduqas C100
- 1G Impact of the First World War
Read the transcript
How does a country's money become almost worthless in a single year, and who could possibly come out of that a winner? A loaf of bread in Germany cost two hundred and fifty marks in January nineteen twenty-three. By November it cost about two hundred thousand million marks, and workers were paid twice a day so they could run to the shops before prices rose again. The chain that caused it began with missed deliveries of coal and timber.
Prices in Germany were already rising before nineteen twenty-three. The government had paid for the war by borrowing and printing money, so a mark bought less every year, and by nineteen twenty-two prices were climbing fast. Some courses ask for the reasons for the occupation and for its effects, and this video gives both. Then came reparations, the payments for war damage set in nineteen twenty-one. Germany paid partly in goods such as coal and timber, and in late nineteen twenty-two it fell behind with its deliveries. France had suffered most damage in the war, and it wanted what it was owed. What do you think France did when the deliveries stopped? It went to take them. On the eleventh of January, nineteen twenty-three, about sixty thousand French and Belgian troops marched into the Ruhr, Germany's main industrial region, to seize coal and goods by force. With an army of only a hundred thousand, Germany could not fight back. The Chancellor, Wilhelm Cuno, called for passive resistance, which means resisting without violence. Ruhr workers went on strike and refused to help the French. The French answered with arrests and expulsions, and violence followed. More than a hundred Germans were killed, including thirteen workers shot by French soldiers at the Krupp works in Essen in March. Output in the Ruhr collapsed, so the government lost tax income. Yet it still had to pay the strikers, whose families still had to eat. Now picture the government's accounts that spring. With less coming in and more going out, how could it pay? It printed the money. The presses ran day and night, turning out banknotes in ever larger amounts.
Printing money destroys its value, and a model shows why. Imagine an island with ten loaves for sale and ten marks between all the islanders, so a loaf costs a mark. Now print ninety more marks. There are still only ten loaves, so sellers can ask ten marks a loaf. More money chasing the same goods pushes prices up, and fewer goods pushes them up again. In nineteen twenty-three Germany had both at once, because the presses were printing more money while the Ruhr was producing less. Prices that rise that fast have a name, hyperinflation, which means prices rising so fast that money becomes almost worthless. In nineteen fourteen one American dollar bought about four marks. In January nineteen twenty-three it bought about eighteen thousand. By November nineteen twenty-three one dollar bought about four point two trillion marks. Written out, that is forty-two followed by eleven noughts. Prices changed by the hour. Workers were paid daily, sometimes twice a day, and carried their wages in baskets. Notes were burned as fuel and used as wallpaper. Now think about a farmer with a cart of potatoes to sell. Why would he refuse to take marks for them? Because by the time he spent the notes, they would buy almost nothing. Food kept its value and money did not, so farmers held back food or swapped it for goods, and the towns went short.
Now the surprising part, because some Germans did well out of this. Here are four people in nineteen twenty-three. The first is a pensioner on a fixed monthly pension. The second is a farmer with a big mortgage on his land. The third is a shop assistant whose wages rise once a month. The fourth is a widow with her savings in the bank. Which one came out ahead, and why? The farmer. He could pay off his whole mortgage with a handful of near-worthless notes, and the food he grew kept its value. Others gained in the same way. Anyone in debt cleared it cheaply. Some big industrialists, such as Hugo Stinnes, borrowed marks to buy up factories and paid the loans back in worthless money. And foreigners with dollars found Germany astonishingly cheap. The losers were everyone who depended on a fixed sum of marks. Savers saw a lifetime's savings wiped out. Pensioners and people on fixed incomes could no longer buy food. Workers' wages lagged behind prices, and the sick and the old suffered most. Many of those who lost were middle-class Germans who had worked hard and saved, which meant they lost faith in the Republic that had let it happen. The crisis also encouraged extremists to try to seize power, which is where the Munich Putsch video picks up. How the crisis was finally ended is the next chapter's story.
One more distinction keeps your answers safe. Hyperinflation belongs to nineteen twenty-three, when money became worthless and prices rose by the hour. The Depression began in nineteen twenty-nine, and its problem was mass unemployment, with prices falling. One report from the examiners puts it plainly: it is important that students differentiate between hyperinflation and the Depression. The fix is to say the year every time you name either crisis. Now a source question. Source A is a well-known photograph from nineteen twenty-three. It shows a woman in her kitchen, feeding banknotes into her stove to burn as fuel. The question asks what the source tells you about how hyperinflation affected ordinary Germans. A report on a question like this records that some students drifted from the focus: the enquiry was about the impact of hyperinflation, not about women's position in society. So check every inference against the question's own focus words. Two inferences are needed, each backed by something you can see. Write two inferences, each with a detail from the source. Inference one: money had become worth less than the paper it was printed on. The detail is that she is burning the notes, instead of using them to buy coal or wood. Inference two: hyperinflation made ordinary daily life a struggle, even for basic needs like heating a home. The detail is that this is an ordinary kitchen, and the notes are keeping the stove going. Saying prices were high because the government printed money is true, but it comes from your own knowledge, not from the source, so it is not an inference from the source. Another report found good knowledge demonstrated regarding hyperinflation. If these facts feel solid to you, you are in a good place, and the work left is pointing them at the exact question asked.
Last, the whole chain as an explained answer. A question asks why prices rose out of control in Germany in nineteen twenty-three, with two hints, the occupation of the Ruhr and reparations. Three causes, each one leading into the next. Try planning the chain on paper, three linked causes, then compare it with the model. First, Germany fell behind with reparations, missing deliveries of coal and timber in late nineteen twenty-two. That mattered because it gave France its reason to act, and in January nineteen twenty-three French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr. Second, the occupation wrecked the economy. Passive resistance meant Germany's main industrial region produced almost nothing, which meant fewer goods to buy and less tax coming in, while the government still paid the strikers. Third, the government printed money to fill the gap. That meant far more money chasing far fewer goods, so prices shot up, until by November one dollar bought about four point two trillion marks. Each cause fed the next. Reparations led to the Ruhr, the Ruhr led to printing, and printing destroyed the mark.
Run the chain back, one question at a time.
What did Germany fail to do that sent France into the Ruhr?
It fell behind with its reparations deliveries of coal and timber, in late nineteen twenty-two.
Now another: why did passive resistance lead to printing money?
Output and taxes collapsed while the government still paid the strikers, so it printed banknotes to cover the gap.
One more, about someone this video never mentioned. A doctor in nineteen twenty-three had a large loan on his house, and very little in the bank.
Did hyperinflation help the doctor or hurt him, and why?
On balance it helped the doctor. He could clear what he owed with near-worthless notes, and he had little saved to lose.
So back to the loaf that cost two hundred thousand million marks. The money became worthless because the government printed it to pay for resistance in the Ruhr. The winners were those who owed money or owned things, and the losers were those who had saved.
If you can run the chain from missed deliveries to worthless money, and name a winner and a loser, thumbs this one up, there's no need to see this twice. If not, save it, and start your next revision session with this one.
Next in the chapter is How Hitler joined the German Workers' Party and built the early Nazi Party. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly H, I, oh one, oh seven.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8145, Edexcel GCSE 1HI0, Eduqas GCSE C100
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8145 | 1A/B Part one: Impact of the First World War | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1HI0 | 31 1.2 | |
| Eduqas GCSE C100 | 1G Impact of the First World War |
For teachers
This GCSE History lesson teaches the crisis of 1923: why the French occupied the Ruhr and how hyperinflation followed. By the end, students should be able to students can explain the causes and effects of the Ruhr occupation and hyperinflation in 1923. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.