EL02-15 English Literature Watch
Ghosts and warnings: why this had to be a ghost story
In this lesson
A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit, with the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 15 of 18. Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: A Christmas Carol: Warnings
- 1:56 A Christmas Carol: Warnings: a warning with a clock
- 3:03 A country warned
- 3:41 The silent warning
- 4:32 Why it had to be a ghost story
- 5:43 An essay to plan
About this video
A Christmas Carol: Ghosts and warnings: why this had to be a ghost story | EL02-15
A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit, with the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 15 of 18.
Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: EL02-15 (search "ScholaFly EL02-15")
#GCSEEnglishLit #AChristmasCarol #AChristmasCarolWarnings
For teachers
This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Warnings. It works through the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8702
- 3.1.2, Paper 1 Section B The 19th-century novel
Edexcel 1ET0
- Component 2 (1ET0/02) Section A 19th-century novel
Eduqas C720QS
- Component 2 Section B 19th Century Prose
OCR J352
- Component 01 (J352/01) Section B 19th century prose
Read the transcript
Would you change a rich man's mind about the poor with an article full of facts, or with a ghost story? The article sounds like the serious choice, and the ghost story like a bit of fun. Dickens chose the ghost story, and that choice is part of his argument, not decoration around it.
The claim: Dickens needs ghosts because a warning has to be impossible to dismiss, and it has to come with a deadline. Start in stave one, the first chapter, or stave, as he calls it, at Scrooge's front door. Dickens insists the door knocker was ordinary, and that Scrooge had no imagination at all. Then, key in the lock, Scrooge sees not a knocker, but Marley's face. The face is not in shadow like the rest of the yard, but had a dismal light about it, like a bad lobster in a dark cellar. A rotten lobster glowing in the dark is funny and horrible at once. Dickens keeps the reader off balance, so the supernatural arrives in the most ordinary object in Scrooge's life. And Scrooge refuses it. He checks behind the door, finds nothing, so he said "Pooh, pooh!" and closed it with a bang. Why does Dickens show Scrooge refusing the first warning before the real ghost arrives? Because a warning only works on someone who cannot wave it away. Dismissing is his answer to everything, so Dickens has to escalate to a visitor no lock can keep out.
Marley's ghost itself does not moralise; it measures. He asks if Scrooge would like to know the weight and length of the strong coil you bear yourself. It was full as heavy and as long as this, seven Christmas Eves ago. You have laboured on it, since. It is a ponderous chain! A coil is a chain wound round and round. Ponderous means very heavy. There is a date, seven Christmas Eves ago, and a rate of growth. The warning has a clock in it. Which spirit visits Scrooge first after Marley: Past, Present, or Yet to Come? The Past, first of the three spirits. It works through memory: the lonely schoolboy, and the engagement he let money end.
The warning widens at the end of stave three, where the Ghost of Christmas Present shows Scrooge two starving children, named Ignorance and Want. It warns: Beware them both, and all of their degree, but most of all beware this boy, for on his brow I see that written which is Doom, unless the writing be erased. Doom is written on the boy's forehead, but the sentence ends on unless. The second warning is about a whole country, and it too has a way out.
Most frightening of all is a warning with no words. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come never speaks. In the churchyard, Scrooge begs it to answer one question: Are these the shadows of the things that Will be, or are they shadows of the things that May be only? The reply: Still the Ghost pointed downward to the grave by which it stood. No answer, only the finger, and the grave is Scrooge's. A prophecy that cannot change is not a warning; it is a sentence. By refusing to say which this is, the silent spirit leaves Scrooge to decide, and that is far more frightening than anything the first two say.
So that is why it had to be a ghost story. An article can be argued with, and a haunting cannot. A ghost brings a deadline, a chain grown for seven years, a warning about what happens if these shadows remain unaltered, and a deadline turns an opinion into a decision.
One examiner's report, on a question about warnings that printed Marley's visit, names the strongest reading in one clause. The stronger responses understood Marley's ghost as both a literal and symbolic warning. Literal means a real ghost in the story, rattling a real chain. Symbolic means standing for something larger, here a life of greed. The weaker answers chose one and dropped the other. The fix is to say both in one sentence every time you use a ghost: what it does in the plot, and what it stands for in the argument.
Now a question to plan: Why does Dickens make his argument about poverty in a ghost story? Three things to look for first. Start with what a ghost can do that a narrator cannot. Look for the deadline in each warning. And ask why the last spirit never speaks. Pause and plan three paragraphs on paper, then come back for one possible plan. One plan that answers it. First, the dead are undismissable: Scrooge says Pooh, pooh to a knocker, but Marley's chain will not go away. Second, every warning carries a deadline: seven Christmas Eves of chain, and Doom unless the writing be erased. Third, the silent spirit forces Scrooge to decide for himself, and that is why the haunting can end inside him. Two wrong turns. One is describing the three ghosts in order and stopping there, which is a summary, not an argument. The other is using terms like pathetic fallacy as labels, without saying what they do. And keep each warning with its own spirit. The grave belongs to the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come, never to Marley or the first two.
The warnings come back now, one gap each, with the last one asking where the ghosts end up. The knocker: not a knocker, but whose face? Marley's face, with a dismal light like a bad lobster in a dark cellar. Now Marley's measurement: it is a what chain? Ponderous. A ponderous chain is a heavy one, and it has been growing for seven Christmas Eves. Try the silent spirit: still the Ghost pointed what? Downward. Still the Ghost pointed downward, to the grave by which it stood, which is Scrooge's own. And the last line of the haunting. On his knees, Scrooge promises: The Spirits of all Three shall strive within me. I will not shut out the lessons that they teach. Where have the ghosts gone, according to that promise? Inside him. The three visitors go on working in him after the night is over, which is where a ghost's warning has to end up if it is going to work.
What a ghost story gives Dickens that an article never could: once you can explain it, this one's locked in, so tap the thumb. Hasn't landed? Save the video and write the three deadlines on one slip of paper to keep by your bed.
Next in the chapter: Isolation: what being alone does to a person. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly E L oh two, sixteen.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For teachers
This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Warnings. It works through the mistakes examiners report.