EL02-08 English Literature Watch
Stave 2: the schoolroom, Fan, and the woman who left
In this lesson
A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit. AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 8 of 18. Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: A Christmas Carol: Stave 2
- 0:35 A Christmas Carol: Stave 2: scene one: the schoolroom
- 3:17 A Christmas Carol: Stave 2: scene two: Fan
- 4:17 Scene three: Belle
- 7:36 A Christmas Carol: Stave 2: recap: one gap
About this video
A Christmas Carol: Stave 2: the schoolroom, Fan, and the woman who left | GCSE English Lit | EL02-08
A Christmas Carol for GCSE English Lit.
AQA 8702, Edexcel 1ET0, Eduqas C720QS and OCR J352 GCSE. A Christmas Carol 8 of 18.
Full A Christmas Carol playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF3MX7efzu2k
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: EL02-08 (search "ScholaFly EL02-08")
#GCSEEnglishLit #AChristmasCarol #AChristmasCarolStave2
For teachers
This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Stave 2.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8702
- 3.1.2, Paper 1 Section B The 19th-century novel
Edexcel 1ET0
- Component 2 (1ET0/02) Section A 19th-century novel
Eduqas C720QS
- Component 2 Section B 19th Century Prose
OCR J352
- Component 01 (J352/01) Section B 19th century prose
Read the transcript
How do you make readers feel sorry for a man they have spent a whole chapter disliking? Stave two, the second chapter of A Christmas Carol, has to do exactly that. The obvious way is to give Scrooge a speech in his own defence. Dickens does the opposite: three scenes from that chapter, put in a careful order, and a silence. The three scenes come one at a time, in the order Dickens chose for them.
Dickens calls his five chapters staves, like the verses of a carol, and in the second one the Ghost of Christmas Past takes Scrooge back to his old boarding school. The house is a decaying mansion. Inside, they found them poorly furnished, cold, and vast, rooms with an earthy smell, and not too much to eat. Poorly furnished and cold could just as well describe the rooms Scrooge lives in now. The school is where his coldness was first put into him. Then the schoolroom itself: a long, bare, melancholy room, made barer still by lines of plain deal forms and desks. Deal is cheap pine, and forms are benches. Bare appears twice in one breath, and the second time it is barer still. The emptiness gets worse the longer you look. At one of these a lonely boy was reading near a feeble fire. The fire is weak, but it is not out. Dickens keeps a little warmth alive in the coldest room in the book. Old Scrooge sits down on a bench and wept to see his poor forgotten self as he used to be. These are the first tears in the novella, and they are for himself. Then Dickens lists sounds: the mice behind the panelling, the drip from a half-thawed water-spout, the empty store-house door swinging. Every one of them is a negative, not a sound, not a drip, not a sigh, but fell upon the heart of Scrooge with a softening influence, and gave a freer passage to his tears. Why do you think Dickens makes that sentence so long before it reaches the tears? Because the length is the thaw. Small memory after small memory builds up, and the sentence only lets go at softening, the way a frozen man does. A moment later he says poor boy, and cries again, in pity for his former self. Pity for yourself is not usually a virtue, but here it is the first time Scrooge feels anything for anyone.
The second scene is short. Years later, at the same school, a little girl runs in to take him home: his younger sister, Fan. She tells him their father is much kinder now, and that he is to come home for good. She is the one member of his family who came for him. The Ghost describes Fan as delicate, a creature a breath might have withered, but says she had a large heart. Then it reminds Scrooge that Fan died a grown woman, with one child. That child is Fred, the nephew Scrooge turned away on Christmas Eve. Scrooge seemed uneasy in his mind, and answers in a single word: yes. Uneasy is a small word for a large thing. His sister's only son is the man whose dinner he refused.
The third scene is the hardest. The Ghost shows Scrooge as a young man beside Belle, the woman he was engaged to marry, and she has come to end it. She says it quietly: Another idol has displaced me. An idol is something worshipped, and displaced means pushed out of its place. He asks what she means, and the exchange goes: "What Idol has displaced you?" he rejoined. "A golden one." Dickens prints his Idol with a capital letter, as if it were a god Scrooge knows by name. And notice there is no golden idol here, only idol in one line and a golden one in the next. Quote them that way. Belle explains how it happened: I have seen your nobler aspirations fall off one by one, until the master-passion, Gain, engrosses you. Aspirations are hopes. Engrosses means swallows up completely. One by one gives the change a speed: slow, over years, like leaves dropping. When he protests that he has not changed towards her, she answers in two flat sentences: You are changed. When it was made, you were another man. She adds that he would never now choose a poor girl, you, who in your very confidence with her, weigh everything by Gain. Even in private, he is valuing. Some readers come away from this scene blaming Belle for Scrooge's coldness. Hold the two of them side by side for a moment: Scrooge, or Belle. Who actually ends the engagement: Scrooge, or Belle? Belle does, and she does it generously. I do; and I release you. With a full heart, for the love of him you once were. She releases him for love of the young man he used to be. She is not the villain of his story; she is the last person who believed in his better self. May you be happy in the life you have chosen! Chosen is the sharpest word she uses. It puts the responsibility where Dickens wants it: Scrooge picked money, and Belle only names the choice.
So that is how Dickens wins your sympathy, without a word of defence. He shows the losses in order: a boy nobody sent for, a sister who came, a woman who left. And the Scrooge who is watching never once defends himself, so the pity is built out of his silence.
How these scenes start the change in Scrooge is traced step by step in How Scrooge changes, stave by stave.
Now the lines that won Scrooge your sympathy come back, one gap each, finishing with a Belle line you have not studied. The schoolroom: a long, bare, melancholy room, made what still? Barer still. Bare, then barer, so the emptiness grows as you look at it. Now Fan: the Ghost says she had a large what? A large heart, and her one child is Fred, which leaves Scrooge uneasy in his mind. Try Belle: until the master-passion, what, engrosses you? Gain. She names his love of money with a capital letter, as if it were a rival. One more Belle line, from earlier in the same conversation: Our contract is an old one. What does calling their engagement a contract tell you about how she is speaking to him? She uses his language, the language of business, to reach a man who now understands only deals. Even their love has to be explained to him as an agreement.
Explaining why Belle is no villain, in her own words, means you've got this down, and the thumb marks it as finished business. Lines still blurring? Save the video and read her scene aloud once, slowly.
Next in the chapter: Ignorance and Want: the moment the story stops. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly E L oh two, oh nine.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For teachers
This GCSE English Lit lesson teaches A Christmas Carol: Stave 2.