ScholaFly

CS05-05 Computer Science Watch

Choosing the right storage

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

In this video you'll learn about choosing the right storage for GCSE Computer Science. Watch first: {{video:CS05-04}}, {{video:CS02-01}}

By the end: Compare magnetic, solid state and optical storage on capacity, speed, portability, durability, reliability and cost, and recommend a device for a given scenario, justifying the choice by linking each characteristic to a specific need in that scenario and saying what 'faster' means (reading and writing data).

What it covers

  • THE SIX CHARACTERISTICS AS MARK-SCHEME VOCABULARY, each defined in one line: capacity (how much it holds), speed (how fast data is read and written), portability (how easily it is carried), durability (how well it survives physical knocks and wear), reliability (how dependably it keeps data over time), cost (usually per gigabyte)
  • THE COMPARISON TABLE: magnetic, solid state and optical rated on all six - magnetic: high capacity, low cost per gigabyte, slower, moving parts so less durable; solid state: fast, durable, portable, more expensive per gigabyte, limited number of writes; optical: low capacity, cheap, portable, slow, scratches easily
  • 'FASTER' MUST SAY AT WHAT: faster to read and write data, or faster access - never 'faster' alone
  • THE SCENARIO METHOD: pick the device, then justify with characteristics LINKED to the scenario's needs ('high capacity, because the photos are large files'), not a list of generic features
  • That EITHER choice can score if justified: OCR's 2024 report says both magnetic and solid state were accepted for the musician question when justified
  • That solid state does NOT last forever: it has a limited number of write cycles, and 'will outlast magnetic' is a recorded misconception
  • Capacity judgements using CS02-01's units - a DVD holds a few gigabytes, a hard drive can hold terabytes - re-mounted, not re-taught

Key words

About this video

Choosing the right storage | GCSE Computer Science

Choosing the right storage device: comparing capacity, speed, portability, durability, reliability and cost, with exam scenarios.
AQA 8525 and OCR J277 GCSE. Memory and storage 5 of 6.
Full Memory and storage playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLN6LILUAa4Zs
More at https://scholafly.com

Watch first: Secondary storage: magnetic, solid state and optical - https://youtu.be/5Amsjf0nS8E, Bits, bytes and the units of storage - https://youtu.be/6NVNIeA80bU
Video code: CS05-05 (search "ScholaFly CS05-05")

Videos in this chapter:
CS05-00 Memory and storage - Intro: https://youtu.be/HP7hdjSfVjI
CS05-01 RAM, ROM and types of memory: https://youtu.be/uyM_YCx5vAU
CS05-02 Cache: https://youtu.be/GZUhJCGdqMY
CS05-03 Virtual memory: https://youtu.be/BUkacndz4Nc
CS05-04 Secondary storage: magnetic, solid state and optical: https://youtu.be/5Amsjf0nS8E
CS05-05 Choosing the right storage: https://youtu.be/79gK1sMFliI
CS05-06 Cloud storage: https://youtu.be/8bnzEUvDMfQ

#GCSEComputerScience #MemoryAndStorage #ChoosingTheRightStorage

For teachers
This GCSE Computer Science lesson teaches choosing the right storage. By the end, students should be able to compare magnetic, solid state and optical storage on capacity, speed, portability, durability, reliability and cost, and recommend a device for a given scenario, justifying the choice by linking each characteristic to a specific need in that scenario and saying what 'faster' means (reading and writing data). It works through four worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.

Exam board specification references:
AQA GCSE Computer Science (8525)
- 3.4.5 Systems architecture
Cambridge OCR Level 1/Level 2 GCSE (9-1) in Computer Science
- 1.2.2 Secondary storage

Read the transcript

A photographer is about to fly to Iceland for a week of shooting. In the drawer are three options: a big hard drive, a small SSD and a stack of DVDs. Any one of them can store a photo. The question is which is best for this trip, and every reason has to be about the trip: the weight in the bag, the size of the files, the knocks along the way.

Memory and storage, video five of six: you know how each kind of storage works, so now you pick one. If the three kinds are not clear yet, start with Secondary storage: magnetic, solid state and optical.

Every judgement about which storage device to choose uses the same six words, so start with one line on each. Capacity is how much data it holds. Speed is how fast data is read and written. Portability is how easily it is carried. Durability is how well it survives knocks and wear. Reliability is how dependably it keeps data over time. Cost is usually counted per gigabyte. If your specification compares only magnetic and solid state, the optical column is background for you, and your board's line is here. Now rate the three. On capacity, hard drives and SSDs both reach terabytes, which is thousands of gigabytes, while a standard DVD holds under five gigabytes. On speed, solid state reads and writes data fastest. Magnetic is slower, because the arm and the platter have to move, and optical is slowest of all. Now, which type wins on cost per gigabyte when there is a huge amount to store? Magnetic. A hard drive gives the most gigabytes for the money, which is why big stores still use it. On portability, solid state and optical are both small and light. A portable hard drive travels too, but it is heavier, and its moving parts dislike being thrown about. On durability, solid state wins, because there are no moving parts to break. Magnetic suffers from knocks, and optical discs scratch. Now, solid state has no moving parts, so does it last forever? No. It survives knocks well, but each cell can only be rewritten a limited number of times before it wears out. On reliability, each has its own weak spot. A hard drive's moving parts can fail, solid state cells wear with heavy rewriting, and a disc fails when its surface is damaged. On cost, solid state costs more per gigabyte than magnetic. Discs are cheap one at a time, but each holds very little. One examiner's report gives this its own misconception box: A misconception is that solid state devices have more longevity than magnetic, that they have an unlimited life span and will outlast magnetic. So keep two separate rows. Solid state wins on durability, against knocks, and has a limited lifespan, counted in rewrites.

Next, the method for a scenario. Choose the device, then justify it with characteristics, each one tied to a need in the scenario by the word because. The shape is a characteristic, then because, then the need. Portable, because it travels in a pocket every day. Back to the photographer, with a week of photos to carry in a backpack, choosing between an optical disc and a solid state drive. Optical disc or SSD for two hundred gigabytes of photos? Give two linked reasons. The SSD. Capacity, because two hundred gigabytes would fill more than forty DVDs. Durability, because a backpack gets knocked about, and discs scratch. One examiner's report, on a question choosing between optical and solid state storage for a student's files, describes the strongest answers: The stronger responses justified the choices for the given scenario, identifying that images could have large file sizes so the solid-state would be more likely to hold all of the required files, or that the need to transport that device might damage an optical disk by scratching it. Both of those follow the same shape: a characteristic, because, and a need from the scenario. A list of features with no because is the habit to drop. A different scenario. A musician recording at home wants extra storage for big sound files, and the drive will sit on the desk. Magnetic or solid state for the musician? Pick one and justify it. Either can work. Magnetic gives lots of capacity for little money, because recordings take up a lot of room. Solid state is quicker to read and write data, so recordings open and save sooner. Both picks hold up, as long as each reason is tied to the musician. Durability barely matters here, because a drive that never leaves the desk is never knocked.

Now one word that needs finishing every time it is used: faster. A student writes: I would choose solid state because it is faster, more durable and lasts forever. How would you fix faster, more durable and lasts forever in that answer? Faster needs its object: faster to read and write data. More durable needs a need, such as a laptop carried every day. And lasts forever is wrong, because the cells inside wear out after many rewrites. One examiner's report on a magnetic versus solid state question says: Candidates often identified that solid state has a faster access speed than magnetic, although some responses just stated that it was faster without identifying what it was faster at. Instead of faster alone, finish the sentence: faster to read and write data. Next, if solid state is faster, why do so many new computers still come with a hard drive? Cost. Solid state costs more per gigabyte, so a computer built to a budget may use a cheaper hard drive to keep its price down. One examiner's report on that question records: There were some very good responses to the second part, with a large number of students giving good explanations of how computers built to a price point or budget would reduce the opportunity to include more expensive components. If cost was your answer, you were in good company. The habit to keep is the link: cost, tied to a computer built to a budget.

To check it held, open the photographer's drawer once more. What must follow the word faster in an answer about storage? What is faster: faster to read and write data, or faster access speed. Next, durability or lifespan: which one does solid state win? Durability. Its lifespan is limited, because each cell wears out after many rewrites. Now, a school keeps ten years of CCTV footage on a shelf. Which type, and one linked reason? Magnetic storage. High capacity at a low cost per gigabyte, because years of video take up a huge amount of space, and a drive on a shelf is never knocked. One more: why is a list like small, durable, portable not a justification? It has no because. Each feature has to be tied to a need in the scenario.

If you are comfortable with it, any scenario, one device, two reasons each carrying a because, give this video the thumbs up and let it drop off your list. If your reasons still come out as lists, save it for later. Three questions in, the because starts to feel normal.

Next in the chapter: Cloud storage, where your files leave the building altogether.

For more, visit scholafly.com, or watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8525, OCR GCSE J277

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 85253.4.5Systems architecture
OCR GCSE J2771.2.2Secondary storage
For teachers

This GCSE Computer Science lesson teaches choosing the right storage. By the end, students should be able to compare magnetic, solid state and optical storage on capacity, speed, portability, durability, reliability and cost, and recommend a device for a given scenario, justifying the choice by linking each characteristic to a specific need in that scenario and saying what 'faster' means (reading and writing data). It works through four worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.