ScholaFly

CH06-05 Chemistry Watch

Why the mass seems to change when a gas is involved

Watch on YouTube

In this lesson

Why the mass seems to change for GCSE Chemistry, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report. AQA 8462, Edexcel 1CH0 and OCR J248 GCSE. Formulae and equations 5 of 6. More at https://scholafly.com

By the end: Explain why the mass on the balance goes up or down in a reaction that is open to the air, by naming the gas that came in or went out.

What it covers

  1. 0:00 Intro: why the mass seems to change
  2. 0:42 Why the mass seems to change: an apparent loss
  3. 2:12 Two wrong explanations
  4. 3:46 A sealed flask
  5. 4:51 An apparent gain
  6. 6:18 Your turn: why the mass seems to change

Key words

About this video

Why the mass seems to change when a gas is involved | GCSE Chemistry | CH06-05

Why the mass seems to change for GCSE Chemistry, with worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
AQA 8462, Edexcel 1CH0 and OCR J248 GCSE. Formulae and equations 5 of 6.
More at https://scholafly.com

Watch first: CH06-03 - https://youtu.be/czlyn2cWyEo
Video code: CH06-05 (search "ScholaFly CH06-05")

#GCSEChemistry #FormulaeAndEquations #WhyTheMassSeemsToChange

For teachers
This GCSE Chemistry lesson teaches why the mass seems to change when a gas is involved. By the end, students should be able to explain why the mass on the balance goes up or down in a reaction that is open to the air, by naming the gas that came in or went out. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.

Exam board specification references:
AQA 8462
- 4.3.1.3
Edexcel 1CH0
- 1.47
OCR J248
- C3.1i
- C3.1j

Read the transcript

How can burning one thing make it heavier, and burning another make it lighter? Burn a strip of magnesium ribbon in an open crucible, and the white ash left behind weighs more than the ribbon did. Burn a candle on a balance, and the reading goes down. Nothing was added to the crucible, and nothing was taken off the candle. It's tempting to blame the balance. But both results are real, and mass is never created or destroyed. The answer lies in what the balance can weigh, and what it cannot.

Mass is conserved in every reaction; what changes is whether all of it stays on the balance. This is for Foundation and Higher tier. A student heats twelve point four grams of green copper carbonate in an open test tube. It all turns black, and the solid left weighs eight point nought grams. The colour change shows a reaction happened. Where did the missing mass go? Into the air. The reaction made a gas, carbon dioxide, which escaped, so it was no longer being weighed. The equation shows it: C u C O three, solid, gives C u O, solid, plus C O two, gas. What mass of carbon dioxide escaped from the tube? Four point four grams of carbon dioxide: twelve point four take away eight point nought. A full explanation has three steps. Name the gas. Say whether it went in or out. Say whether it was ever on the balance. Here, the gas is carbon dioxide. It went out. Once out of the tube, it was off the balance.

One examiner's report, on a question where a test tube lost mass, records two wrong explanations. "Many referred incorrectly to evaporation." And: "Many thought the loss in mass was due to energy being lost." Why can't evaporation explain the copper carbonate losing mass? Evaporation is a liquid turning into a gas, and there's no liquid there. The solid reacted and made a new substance, a gas. Energy leaving as heat can't explain it either. The energy given out has no mass a school balance could ever detect. Here's an answer that is nearly right: a gas was produced. That answer stops one step short. Which word is missing? Escaped. A gas was produced and escaped from the tube, so it left the balance. The same report notes that some students "correctly said that a gas was produced, but did not say that it escaped, so did not gain the mark." The habit that earns it is saying the second step out loud every time: the gas went out, or it came in.

Now the same reaction in a sealed flask, standing on the balance the whole time. At the end, is the reading higher, lower or the same as at the start? No change. The carbon dioxide still forms, but it's trapped inside, so the balance goes on weighing it. A sealed container like that is called a closed system: nothing can get in or out. An open tube or crucible is not closed, so gases can cross its edge. One exam specification's own teaching note warns that learners "may think that the original substance vanishes completely and forever in a chemical reaction." Nothing vanishes. In the open tube, the carbon dioxide's atoms are still there, in the air of the room, outside what the balance can weigh.

Now the other direction. Four point nought grams of magnesium ribbon is burned in an open crucible, and the white powder left weighs six point six grams. Nothing was added to the crucible. Where did the extra mass come from? Oxygen, from the air. It joined the magnesium to make magnesium oxide, but it was never on the balance before it reacted. The equation shows the oxygen joining in: two M g plus O two gives two M g O. What mass of oxygen joined the magnesium? Two point six grams of oxygen: six point six take away four point nought. The same three steps work. The gas is oxygen. It came in. And it wasn't on the balance until it joined the metal. Rusting iron gains mass in the same way, with oxygen and water from the air joining the metal. A gain like that isn't an error; it's reactants the balance never saw arrive.

Time to use the three steps on reactions you haven't seen here. Zinc carbonate heated in an open tube loses mass. What are the three steps? The gas is carbon dioxide. It left the tube. Once outside, it was no longer on the balance. Now calcium: two point nought grams burns to two point eight grams. Mass of oxygen? Nought point eight grams of oxygen came in from the air. One more: the candle from the start. Why did its reading go down? Its wax burns to carbon dioxide and water vapour, both gases, and both leave the flame. The magnesium took a gas in; the candle let gases out.

That was lesson five of Chemical formulae and equations, on why a balance can seem to break the law of conservation of mass. If you're solid on this, a thumbs up takes it off your list. If the mass gain still feels odd, save it; this one often lands on a second viewing.

Next in the chapter, for Higher tier only: Writing balanced ionic equations. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly C H oh six, oh six.

Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.

Related terms

For: AQA GCSE 8462, Edexcel GCSE 1CH0, OCR GCSE J248

On the specification

BoardSpecStatement
AQA GCSE 84624.3.1.3Mass changes when a reactant or product is a gas
Edexcel GCSE 1CH01.47Explain the law of conservation of mass applied to: a a closed system including a precipitation reaction in a closed flask b a non-enclosed system including a reaction in an open flask that takes in or gives out a gas
OCR GCSE J248C3.1iRecall and use the law of conservation of mass
OCR GCSE J248C3.1jExplain any observed changes in mass in non-enclosed systems during a chemical reaction and explain them using the particle model
For teachers

This GCSE Chemistry lesson teaches why the mass seems to change when a gas is involved. By the end, students should be able to explain why the mass on the balance goes up or down in a reaction that is open to the air, by naming the gas that came in or went out. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report, and suits Foundation and Higher tier students.