BU04-06 Business Watch
Choosing the right type of business ownership
In this lesson
Choosing the right type: how to analyse the advantages and disadvantages of each type of business ownership against the issues that matter. AQA 8132, Edexcel 1BS0, OCR J204, Eduqas C510QS, WJEC 3160QS and Ccea 3210 GCSE. Types of ownership 6 of 6. More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: choosing the right type
- 0:43 Weighing a type
- 3:32 Choosing the right type: kai and Sana
- 5:15 Tomos, sole trader
- 7:01 Riverside Pets
- 9:06 Ellie again
About this video
Choosing the right type of business ownership | GCSE Business | BU04-06
Choosing the right type: how to analyse the advantages and disadvantages of each type of business ownership against the issues that matter.
AQA 8132, Edexcel 1BS0, OCR J204, Eduqas C510QS, WJEC 3160QS and Ccea 3210 GCSE. Types of ownership 6 of 6.
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: BU04-06 (search "ScholaFly BU04-06")
#GCSEBusiness #TypesOfOwnership #ChoosingTheRightType
For teachers
This GCSE Business lesson teaches choosing the right type of business ownership. By the end, students should be able to analyse the advantages and disadvantages of each type of business ownership against the issues that matter - ownership, management and control, decision making, finance, liability, distribution of profits, formation, size and aims - and evaluate which type is most suitable for a given business, from start-up to large established company. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8132
- 3.1.2
Edexcel 1BS0
- 1.4.1
OCR J204
- 1.3
Eduqas C510QS
- Business ownership
WJEC 3160QS
- 1.5.3
Ccea 3210
- 3.1/Creating a Business/Business ownership
Read the transcript
At sixteen, Ellie sells hair scrunchies from her bedroom. Could the type of business that suits her now one day ruin her? At nineteen, she has two staff, a small unit, and a forty-thousand-pound order from a shop chain that pays sixty days after delivery. At twenty-five, she wants shops in ten cities. Surely a business that is going well should stay as it started? For Ellie, that could be the riskiest choice of all. Each age has its own answer, and each answer can be argued.
Every type of ownership can be weighed on the same set of issues, though courses differ in which types they ask about. Who owns the business decides who makes the decisions. The type decides where the money can come from, and what liability the owners carry. It decides who gets the profit, how easy and costly it is to set up, and whether it suits the business's size and aims. A sole trader is quick to set up and keeps full control and all the profit after tax, but it has unlimited liability and little money. A partnership adds money and skills, but shares control and profit, and still has unlimited liability. A private limited company gives limited liability and more money from private shareholders, and the owners still choose who joins. A public limited company can raise very large sums from the public, at the risk of losing control. A franchise gives a known brand and a tested way of working, paid for with a fee and a royalty, at the cost of freedom over products and prices. A not-for-profit model suits an organisation whose main aim is a cause, because its surplus goes back into that cause and never to owners. Weighing a type in an answer takes five steps. First, identify what type the business is now. Second, give a point that belongs to that type. Third, chain it: say why, then what it means. Fourth, use the case's own facts. Fifth, reach a judgement that names the deciding fact. Step one has its own examiner's comment. One report says students had to understand the type of ownership the business had, then talk about its advantage or disadvantage. Many failed to grasp this and dropped marks. The fix is step one itself: name the type before anything else. Step two has a test of its own: would this point be true of any business? If it would, it belongs to no type in particular. Three disadvantages of being a sole trader, then. A: it is hard work. B: the owner's own savings can be taken to pay the debts. C: customers might not come. Which of the three passes that test? B. A and C could be said of every new firm, whatever its type.
Kai and Sana plan to open a tattoo studio together as a partnership. The task is to explain one disadvantage to them of this type of ownership. Step one is done for us: it is a partnership. A point that belongs to a partnership is unlimited liability, where each partner is responsible for debts the other runs up for the business. Now two ways to finish that point. Answer A ends: this leads to a less successful business. Answer B ends: if Sana signs a fifteen-thousand-pound lease on a bigger studio and the studio cannot pay it, Kai's own savings can be taken to cover a debt he did not choose. Which ending would you rather write, and what does it add? B. A never says in what way the business suffers. B says exactly who pays, with what, and for whose decision. One examiner's report says a question like this was well answered by most students, usually with partner disagreements or unlimited liability. Some, though, made vague development points, such as this leads to a less successful business. The report says students must be more specific, and consider in what way a business would be less successful. The fix is to end every chain on a named result for the people in the case. Here, that means Kai carries risk for decisions he does not control.
Tomos runs a window-cleaning round on his own. The task is to describe two advantages to him of being a sole trader. Two advantages means two separate points, each developed with a because and a so. And one common phrase needs care. What is wrong with saying Tomos keeps all the money? The money he takes also pays his costs, such as his ladders, his van and his fuel. What he keeps is the profit after tax. One examiner's report says many students used vague terms, and gives the example: they keep all the money. It calls that too vague, and not correct. The fix is to write all the profit after tax, every time. Now write the full answer, two points, for this window cleaner. Have a go at this one before I show you. Advantage one: Tomos keeps all the profit after tax, because no other owner shares it. So every extra street he adds raises his own income. Advantage two: he makes every decision himself, because there is no one else to agree with. So he can change his round or his prices the same day a customer asks. Two bare points, such as keeps the profit and makes the decisions, name two advantages but describe neither of them.
Riverside Pets is a partnership of two sisters. It has three shops and made a profit of ninety thousand pounds last year. The sisters want to open five more shops, costing six hundred thousand pounds in total, and they do not want to lose control. Should they become a private limited company or a public limited company? The first four steps come quickly here. The type now is a partnership, and the points for each option come straight from its features. For a private limited company, the sisters gain limited liability, which matters because six hundred thousand pounds means far bigger debts than three shops ever carried. They can also sell shares privately, for example to a business angel, an investor who backs small firms, and still choose who owns the company. For a P L C, they could raise far more by selling shares to the public. But floating is costly, they must publish detailed accounts, and anyone could buy shares, so they could lose control or face a takeover. Private or P L C? Take your pick, and hold on to your reason before I show you. A private limited company. Six hundred thousand pounds is within reach of a bank loan plus a few private investors, so the big gains of a P L C are not needed. And the sisters have said that keeping control matters to them. A P L C would only make sense if they later needed many millions. One examiner's report says weaker answers to a question like this showed accurate understanding but no application to the business, which severely limited them. The fix is to let the case's facts decide. The judgement for Riverside uses the six hundred thousand pounds, the three shops and the sisters' wish for control.
Back to Ellie, with the method in hand. At sixteen, selling scrunchies from her bedroom, she has little money at risk and wants full control. A sole trader suits her. It is quick and cheap to set up, she makes every decision, and she keeps all the profit after tax. The deciding fact is how little she has at stake. Next comes Ellie at nineteen, with staff, a unit, and that big order waiting to be paid for. Now the stretch: what type should Ellie be at nineteen, and which fact tips it? She should become a private limited company. The forty-thousand-pound order means large debts to suppliers before the chain pays her. If it never pays, limited liability keeps her own savings safe. At twenty-five, with ten cities in mind, a P L C makes sense only if she needs very large sums and accepts losing some control. Franchising is another route, where local owners pay to open the shops under her name, at the cost of some control over quality. Otherwise a private company with a few investors still fits.
A last round of questions on choosing a type.
What comes first, before any advantage or disadvantage is written?
Identifying what type of ownership the business has now comes first.
Now a new case. Zara and Leo run a market stall as a partnership, and someone writes that a disadvantage is that the two partners might disagree on decisions.
Does that disadvantage belong to their type of ownership?
Yes. A sole trader has no co-owner to fall out with, so a dispute between owners who must agree belongs to their type.
Now the last one: what should replace keeps all the money, for a sole trader?
Keeps all the profit after tax, because the money taken also pays the costs.
So Ellie's three ages get three answers. At sixteen, a sole trader, because so little was at stake. At nineteen, a private limited company, because one unpaid order could have reached her own savings. At twenty-five, a P L C only if the money she needs outgrows private investors.
If this one's yours now, give it a thumbs-up. If it isn't yet, save it and come back to it later in the week.
That's the chapter on business ownership done. The next chapter is Business aims, objectives and stakeholders. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly B U oh five, oh oh.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8132, Edexcel GCSE 1BS0, OCR GCSE J204, Eduqas GCSE C510QS, WJEC GCSE 3160QS, CCEA GCSE 3210
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8132 | 3.1.2 | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1BS0 | 1.4.1 | |
| OCR GCSE J204 | 1.3 | |
| Eduqas GCSE C510QS | Business ownership | |
| WJEC GCSE 3160QS | 1.5.3 | |
| CCEA GCSE 3210 | 3.1/Creating a Business/Business ownership |
For teachers
This GCSE Business lesson teaches choosing the right type of business ownership. By the end, students should be able to analyse the advantages and disadvantages of each type of business ownership against the issues that matter - ownership, management and control, decision making, finance, liability, distribution of profits, formation, size and aims - and evaluate which type is most suitable for a given business, from start-up to large established company. It works through three worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.