BU04-03 Business Watch
Private and public limited companies
In this lesson
Private and public limited companies: how to describe the main features of private limited companies (Ltd) and public limited companies. AQA 8132, Edexcel 1BS0, OCR J204, Eduqas C510QS, WJEC 3160QS and Ccea 3210 GCSE. Types of ownership 3 of 6. More at https://scholafly.com
What it covers
- 0:00 Intro: private and public limited companies
- 0:45 Limited companies
- 2:46 Public limited company (plc)
- 5:44 Should Ridgeway float?
- 8:07 Telling the two apart
About this video
Private and public limited companies | GCSE Business | BU04-03
Private and public limited companies: how to describe the main features of private limited companies (Ltd) and public limited companies.
AQA 8132, Edexcel 1BS0, OCR J204, Eduqas C510QS, WJEC 3160QS and Ccea 3210 GCSE. Types of ownership 3 of 6.
More at https://scholafly.com
Video code: BU04-03 (search "ScholaFly BU04-03")
#GCSEBusiness #TypesOfOwnership
For teachers
This GCSE Business lesson teaches private and public limited companies. By the end, students should be able to describe the main features of private limited companies (Ltd) and public limited companies (plc), explain the advantages and disadvantages to a company of becoming a plc, and compare the two on ownership, control and decision making, finance and liability. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.
Exam board specification references:
AQA 8132
- 3.1.2
Edexcel 1BS0
- 1.4.1
- 2.1.1
OCR J204
- 1.3
Eduqas C510QS
- Business ownership
WJEC 3160QS
- 1.5.1
Ccea 3210
- 3.1/Creating a Business/Business ownership
Read the transcript
JCB, the firm behind the yellow diggers on building sites, is one of the world's biggest makers of diggers. Why does it not sell shares to the public? JCB is still owned by one family, the Bamfords. It could sell shares on the stock market and raise an enormous sum of money. You might guess that a business that big must already belong to the public. It does not. The family has left that money on the table and kept the shares to itself. What the family keeps, and what it gives up, comes down to one choice.
Every company, private or public, starts from the same base. A company is separate from its owners in law. Its owners are its shareholders, and they have limited liability. A company is run by directors, the people who manage it day to day. In a small company, the directors are often shareholders too. A private limited company has the letters L T D after its name. Its shares cannot be offered to the general public. They are sold privately, and only with the agreement of the existing shareholders. They can go to family and friends, but also to staff or to private investors. Now a quick check. Brightwick Candles Limited is owned by its founder, Asha, her brother and two long-serving staff. It wants to raise more money by selling shares. A: sell shares to a third member of staff. B: offer shares for anyone at all to buy. C: sell shares to a private investor the owners agree to. Which of the three is Brightwick not allowed to do? B is ruled out. While Brightwick stays this kind of limited company, it can never sell to the general public. A and C are both allowed, as long as the existing shareholders agree. Brightwick's own staff already hold some of its shares. One examiner's report says a common misconception was that shares in a private limited company could only be sold to family and friends. It says that answer was not accepted, because it is not true. The fix is to state the rule in full: not to the general public, and only with the other shareholders' agreement.
A public limited company goes one step further than a private one. It has the letters P L C after its name, and it can sell its shares to the public on a stock exchange. A stock exchange is a market where shares in public companies are bought and sold. Selling shares to the public for the first time is called floating the company, or a flotation. Public here means the shares are open to the public. A P L C is still a private-sector business owned by its shareholders, not by the government. The big gain for the company is money. A P L C is usually much bigger than a private company, and selling shares to the public can raise very large sums, with no interest to pay and nothing to pay back. The costs come with it. Every new share sold means the founders own a smaller part of the company. That is called dilution. If they end up with less than half of the shares, they can lose control of decisions. Because anyone can buy shares, a rival could buy enough of them to take the company over. A P L C must also publish detailed accounts for anyone to read, and pay the high costs of floating and of running as a public company. Now a reason to work out: why can a stranger not buy up a private limited company? Its shares never go on a stock exchange. They change hands privately, and only when the existing shareholders agree, which keeps control with the owners. Shareholders are the company's owners. They are usually rewarded with dividends, which are a share of the profit paid out to them after the profit has been made. Paying a dividend does not reduce the profit. The profit is made first. Then the directors decide how much of it to pay to the owners, and how much to keep in the business. Here's a company to test it on. Harbour Foods makes a profit of two hundred thousand pounds in a year. Its directors then pay fifty thousand pounds to the shareholders as dividends. What was Harbour Foods' profit for the year? It is unchanged. A dividend is paid out of profit already made, so the year's profit is the same as before the payment. The profit is two hundred thousand pounds. Fifty thousand goes to the owners, which leaves one hundred and fifty thousand pounds kept in the business.
Ridgeway Outdoor Limited makes tents. Its two founders own all the shares, and they need twenty million pounds to build a factory. They are thinking about becoming a public limited company. The task is to discuss the impact on Ridgeway of making that move. Start with the money: what pays for the factory if Ridgeway becomes a P L C? The money raised by selling shares to the public. Ridgeway could raise the twenty million pounds that way, with no interest and nothing to repay. That means the factory can be built now, rather than over years of saved-up profit. One examiner's report looks at answers that chose becoming a P L C to pay for new production lines. It says they often showed a lack of understanding of how that would fund them, and many drifted off into limited liability. The fix is to say how the money arrives before anything else. Limited liability protects the shareholders, but it pays for nothing. Now the other side. To raise that much, the founders might have to sell most of the shares. Say their stake falls from one hundred per cent to forty-five per cent. Why does a stake of forty-five per cent matter so much? Forty-five per cent is less than half. They no longer hold a majority, so the other shareholders together can outvote them. And because anyone can buy shares in a P L C, a rival could buy enough to take Ridgeway over. Ridgeway would also have to publish detailed accounts and pay the costs of floating. The judgement turns on how much the founders value control. Here, twenty million pounds is far more than two founders could find themselves. That makes becoming a P L C likely to be worth it, as long as the founders keep a large enough block of shares to stay the biggest owners.
Comparing the two types means finding a point that is true of one and not of the other. Now pick the real difference. A: both have limited liability. B: a P L C can sell shares to anyone on a stock exchange, and a private limited company cannot. C: both are separate from their owners in law. Which of the three is a difference between the two types? B. A and C are true of both, so neither one tells the two types apart. Limited liability, being separate in law and being owned by shareholders are true of every company. The differences all grow from who is allowed to buy the shares. Because a P L C's shares are open to anyone, it can raise far more money. Its founders can also lose control, it can be taken over, and it must publish its accounts. One examiner's report says some students gave advantages and disadvantages that applied to both public and private limited companies, and failed to consider the differences between them. The fix is a quick test for every comparison point: would it still be true of the other type? If it would, it is not a difference. Back to Brightwick Candles. The task is to outline one difference between a private limited company like Brightwick and a public limited company. Use the case's own facts, not just the names of the two types. Pause it there and work it out for yourself. One strong answer: the difference is who can buy the shares. Brightwick's shares cannot be offered to the general public. They are held by people the owners agreed to: Asha, her brother and two staff. That means Asha keeps control of decisions. A public limited company can sell shares to anyone on a stock exchange. It can raise far more money that way, but anyone could then build up a large stake.
To finish, three questions on the two company types.
Who can buy shares in a private limited company?
People the existing shareholders agree to, such as family, friends, staff or private investors. Never the general public.
Now a company that has not come up yet. Tallis Media P L C pays out one million pounds in dividends.
Has its profit fallen because of that payment?
No. Dividends are paid from profit already made, so the profit figure stays the same.
Another one: what is a difference between the two company types that is not true of both?
For example, a P L C can be taken over through the stock market, and a private limited company cannot. Or a P L C must publish detailed accounts.
That is JCB's choice. By staying a private company, the Bamford family keeps control of every decision and keeps out any buyer it has not agreed to. The price is all the money it could have raised by selling shares to the public.
If this one feels like it's in the bag, give it a thumbs-up and move on. If not, save it, give it a day and look again.
Next in the chapter is Not-for-profit and purpose-driven organisations. Hopefully that's next in your feed, but if not, search for ScholaFly B U oh four, oh four.
Every other video is on scholafly.com too, easy to search by video code or by keyword. Whatever you're revising, go there and have a look, or, watch the next video.
Related terms
For: AQA GCSE 8132, Edexcel GCSE 1BS0, OCR GCSE J204, Eduqas GCSE C510QS, WJEC GCSE 3160QS, CCEA GCSE 3210
On the specification
| Board | Spec | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| AQA GCSE 8132 | 3.1.2 | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1BS0 | 1.4.1 | |
| Edexcel GCSE 1BS0 | 2.1.1 | |
| OCR GCSE J204 | 1.3 | |
| Eduqas GCSE C510QS | Business ownership | |
| WJEC GCSE 3160QS | 1.5.1 | |
| CCEA GCSE 3210 | 3.1/Creating a Business/Business ownership |
For teachers
This GCSE Business lesson teaches private and public limited companies. By the end, students should be able to describe the main features of private limited companies (Ltd) and public limited companies (plc), explain the advantages and disadvantages to a company of becoming a plc, and compare the two on ownership, control and decision making, finance and liability. It works through two worked examples and the mistakes examiners report.